Plastic treaty chair says deal possible in March after Bangkok informal talks
The chair of UN plastics treaty talks, Chile's Julio Cordano, told AFP after informal meetings in Bangkok that a deal could be adopted in March. Advocates quoted by Inside Climate News say observers are shut out and the Iran war strengthens the case for limits.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 1Julio Cordano, the Chilean ambassador chairing negotiations on a world-first plastic pollution treaty, told AFP on 1 October in Bangkok that countries are less divided than before and a deal could be agreed in March. CNAN “Countries negotiating a world-first treaty to limit plastic pollution are less divided than before and a deal could be agreed in March, the diplomat chairing the talks told AFP on Thursday (Oct 1).” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1Cordano said he expects to adopt the treaty at the next official round, INC 5.4 in March, if the right steps are followed, progress is consistent and his roadmap is completed. CNAN “"My plan and my expectation is that we will be able to adopt the treaty in INC 5.4 (March meeting), if we follow the correct steps, if we make consistent progress, and if we complete the roadmap that I presented," he said.” Read at CNA ↗ Mixed · 2Cordano took over the chair earlier this year after his predecessor resigned; talks began in 2022 with a two-year timeline and have overrun it by more than a year. CNAN “Chilean ambassador Julio Cordano took over the role earlier this year after his predecessor resigned, and with the talks having overrun their initial schedule by more than a year.” Read at CNA ↗ Inside Climate NewsLC “The resolution called for an intergovernmental negotiating committee to draft a legally binding agreement by the end of 2024.” Read at Inside Climate News ↗
Mixed · 2Talks in South Korea in 2024 fell apart and a renewed effort in Geneva in 2025 made no progress; negotiations then resumed this year as informal talks restricted to member state representatives. CNAN “But crunch talks in South Korea in 2024 fell apart, and a renewed effort in Geneva the following year made no progress either.” Read at CNA ↗ Inside Climate NewsLC “Negotiations then resumed as “informal talks” restricted to representatives of member states in June.” Read at Inside Climate News ↗ Centre · 1A majority of nations want ambitious, legally binding limits on plastic production, which is expected to triple by 2060, while a smaller bloc of mostly oil-producing states, including Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and Russia, wants a narrower focus on waste management. CNAN “A majority of nations have called for ambitious, legally binding measures to curb production of plastic, which is expected to triple by 2060.”“But a smaller bloc of mostly oil-producing states - including Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and Russia - have pushed back against such restrictions, seeking to focus more narrowly on waste management.” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1Before the Bangkok meetings Cordano released a non-binding "aid to negotiations" with brackets around contentious items such as a production cap, mention of human health, and designating problematic plastic products or chemicals of concern; he plans a new version next month, before a last informal round in January. CNAN “Ahead of the Bangkok talks, Cordano released an "aid to negotiations" - a non-binding outline of a possible treaty, with brackets around the most contentious sections.”“The diplomat expects to release a new "aid to negotiations next month, before a last round of informal talks in January.” Read at CNA ↗
Centre · 1Cordano said positions are closer than binary and that the mandate embeds "different pathways or different departure points"; AFP's sources said some countries increasingly back a text offering options, with ambitious countries choosing to limit production or products and others not. CNAN “Sources told AFP some countries are increasingly supportive of a document that would offer options, with more ambitious countries choosing to limit production or certain products, while others do not.” Read at CNA ↗ Mixed · 2Decision-making rules remain a serious dispute: some countries want consensus on everything, which opponents say lets a small minority block progress, and Cordano acknowledged concerns about a consensus rule while saying he wants a treaty "accepted by everyone". CNAN “Some countries want all decisions to be made by consensus, which opponents say allows a small minority to block progress.” Read at CNA ↗ Inside Climate NewsLC “The bloc, though a small minority, derailed an agreement last year because the treaty’s consensus approach allows even a single country to block a deal.” Read at Inside Climate News ↗ Left · 1Inside Climate News reported that environmental advocates said more than 70 developing countries back addressing all causes and drivers of plastic pollution, and that countries making up over a quarter of global plastics demand support strong measures, according to Giulia Carlini of the Center for International Environmental Law; the outlet said this is unlikely to be enough to prevail over the fossil-fuel-producing "like-minded group". Inside Climate NewsLC “more than 70 developing countries supported addressing all causes and drivers of plastic pollution, environmental advocates said.”“But it’s unlikely to be enough to prevail over the “like-minded group” led by fossil-fuel producing nations that oppose limits on the production of plastics.” Read at Inside Climate News ↗
Left · 1Advocates, including Greenpeace's Jacob Kean-Hammerson, argue that market shocks from the US and Israeli strikes on Iran in February, including polyethylene and naphtha shortages and price rises, show the vulnerability of fossil-based plastics supply chains and strengthen the case for a treaty. Inside Climate NewsLC “Military strikes on Iran by the United States and Israel in February triggered market shocks that disrupted economic sectors dependent on oil and gas.”“The war caused a “huge naphtha crisis,” Kean-Hammerson said” Read at Inside Climate News ↗ Left · 1Scientists and observers criticise the closed format: Martin Wagner of the Scientists' Coalition for an Effective Plastics Treaty and Kean-Hammerson said excluding observers lacks scientific scrutiny and violates UN precedents, while Cordano said observers were invited to submit written views, he holds regular webinars, and the informal meetings are "not decision-making meetings". Inside Climate NewsLC “Kean-Hammerson said excluding observers from discussions violates U.N. legal precedents that grant civil society, Indigenous peoples and other groups the right to access information and participate in negotiations on international agreements.”“The events are “not decision-making meetings,” Cordano said” Read at Inside Climate News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Advocacy-sourced feature framing the talks as struggling, with the Iran war as added urgency for a treaty.
- Emphasis
- Advocates' and scientists' voices, health and climate costs, exclusion of observers, fossil-fuel influence.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Cordano's March deal prediction and his claim that positions are closer; the roadmap and bracketed draft.
- Charged language
- “black box of negotiations”“scientific misinformation”“like-minded group”
- For example
-
“He worries that even as scientists are not privy to what’s being said during “this black box of negotiations,”” — Inside Climate News
“Some member states are strategically wielding scientific misinformation, Wagner said.” — Inside Climate News
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Interview-driven report relaying AFP, leading with the chair's optimism about a March deal.
- Emphasis
- Cordano's quotes, the roadmap, bracketed text and consensus rules.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Observer-exclusion concerns and the Iran war's market effects.
- Charged language
- “world-first treaty”“crunch talks”
- For example
-
“Countries negotiating a world-first treaty to limit plastic pollution are less divided than before and a deal could be agreed in March” — CNA
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Informal closed-door talks on a UN plastics treaty took place in Bangkok this week, chaired by Chile's Julio Cordano.
- Talks began in 2022, missed the end-2024 target and have not produced a treaty.
- A small bloc of oil-producing states opposes production limits, and the consensus rule is a obstacle.
- Formal negotiations are due to resume in March.
Where accounts differ
-
Prospects for a deal
- Left
- Inside Climate News stresses that the opposing bloc is likely to prevail and that negotiations have moved away from a science-based treaty.
- Centre
- CNA, relaying AFP, reports Cordano's optimism that countries are closer and a March deal is possible, while noting serious unresolved disputes.
-
Closed-door format
- Left
- Advocates and scientists say exclusion of observers breaches UN precedents and removes fact-checking.
- Centre
- Cordano says informal meetings are not decision-making and observers can give written views.
Global plastics treaty topic
The chair says the treaty could be adopted in March and that countries are closer than they seem; advocates say a strong treaty is needed and the talks are being hampered by a small bloc and a closed process.
“I think people are seeing eye-to-eye ... I think this is a reason to be optimistic.” — CNA
“So far, negotiations have moved away from an effective, science-based plastics treaty” — Inside Climate News
East and Southeast Asia1 outlet
CNA reports the chair's optimism from Bangkok.
“BANGKOK: Countries negotiating a world-first treaty to limit plastic pollution are less divided than before” — CNA
CNA
North America1 outlet
Inside Climate News focuses on advocacy concerns and the Iran war's economic effects.
“Still, environmental advocates see the economic upheaval caused by the war in Iran as an opportunity” — Inside Climate News
Inside Climate News
Left1 article
-
As Negotiators Struggle to Advance a Plastics Treaty, Iran War Underscores the Urgency
Critical Advocacy-led feature on stalled talks, closed-door process and Iran war supply shocks as reason for action.

Centre1 article
-
CNAN ·
Plastic treaty talks chair sees deal possible in March
Neutral Straight report of the chair's AFP interview, with background on divisions.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 1 Oct 09:59 First CNAN Plastic treaty talks chair sees deal possible in March
- 2 Oct 20:20 +34h 22m Inside Climate NewsLC As Negotiators Struggle to Advance a Plastics Treaty, Iran War Underscores the Urgency
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.