Protesters interrupt imam's invocation at Bartow, Florida city commission meeting
Christian protesters recited the Lord's Prayer over Imam Sajid Bhuiya's invocation at a Bartow, Florida city commission meeting on Monday. Police escorted them out with no arrests, and the city said invocations are open to all faiths.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Right · 1At a Bartow, Florida city commission meeting on Monday evening, Christian protesters interrupted an invocation by Imam Sajid Bhuiya of the town's Masjid Al-Nur Mosque. Fox NewsR “An imam who was scheduled to deliver the invocation at a city commission meeting Monday evening in a southwest Florida town was interrupted by Christian protesters” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1Footage obtained by Fox News showed dozens of activists crowded at the back of the room who began reciting the Lord's Prayer in unison as Bhuiya stepped up to the lectern, and some chants of "USA!" broke out. Fox NewsR “they began reciting the Lord's Prayer in unison. Some chants of "USA!" broke out, as well.” Read at Fox News ↗ Left · 1Raw Story reported that the meeting went off the rails for nearly 10 minutes as irate Christians repeatedly shouted down the imam trying to deliver the opening prayer. Raw StoryL “A Florida city commission went off the rails for nearly 10 minutes this week when irate Christians repeatedly shouted down an imam trying to deliver the opening prayer” Read at Raw Story ↗
Right · 1Robert Goodman, southeast regional director of the conservative group Citizens Defending Freedom, said word of the imam's scheduled appearance spread on social media the previous weekend, that he shared it, and that about 100 people from different groups attended. Fox NewsR “Goodman said about 100 people from different groups ended up attending the meeting.” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1Goodman said the group believes Christian voices deserve to be heard and that people have the right to challenge teachings they believe conflict with human dignity and religious liberty; he asserted that the Quran teaches forced submission and permits men to strike their wives, a characterisation of Islamic teaching presented in the article without rebuttal. Fox NewsR “He said the Quran teaches forced submission and permits men to strike their wives, while viewing the opinions of women as lesser than the opinions of men.” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1Some protesters made off-color comments, including telling Bhuiya to go back to his own country; Goodman said he and his organisation do not support such remarks, which he attributed to two or three individuals. Fox NewsR “including telling Bhuiya to go back to his own country, which Goodman clarified that neither he nor his organization support.” Read at Fox News ↗
Right · 1Police escorted the protesters out of the building, though no arrests were made, while commission members mostly sat quietly. Fox NewsR “Police eventually escorted the Christian protesters out of the building, though no arrests were made.” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1Bhuiya then spoke, quoting Quran passages he said are meant to unify people and saying differences in background, culture and faith should not prevent people from treating one another with dignity. Fox NewsR “Bhuiya then spoke, quoting passages from the Quran that he said are meant to unify people.” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1The city of Bartow said residents, joined by people from other cities, tried to prevent the imam from speaking and the Mayor from conducting business. Fox NewsR “attempted to prevent the imam from speaking and the Mayor from proceeding to conduct the business at hand.” Read at Fox News ↗
Right · 1The city added that meetings have traditionally opened with a prayer by a faith leader or elected official, that invocations have historically been Christian but are open to all faiths, which it said is consistent with the US Constitution, and it urged residents and religious leaders to help keep Bartow welcoming. Fox NewsR “While historically the opening invocation/prayer is one based on Christian traditions, the opportunity is open to all faiths. This is consistent with the United States Constitution.” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1Goodman said a city official invited Bhuiya, and Fox News said it had asked the mosque for comment; the video from the city's livestream went viral online. Fox NewsR “Goodman said Bhuiya was invited to deliver the invocation by a city official.”“Video from the city's official livestream of the event quickly went viral online.” Read at Fox News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Raw Story frames the event as a chaotic, angry shouting-down of an imam at a public meeting.
- Emphasis
- The anger of the protesters, the disorder and the roughly 10-minute duration.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not include the protest organiser's or the city's statements that Fox News reports.
- Charged language
- “Enraged Christians”“shout down”“devolves into chaos”
- For example
-
“'Quiet down!' Enraged Christians shout down imam as public meeting devolves into chaos” — Raw Story
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Fox News frames the story as Christians 'rebelling' with a prayer of their own, relying on an organiser from Citizens Defending Freedom, with the city's statement included.
- Emphasis
- The organiser's account and criticism of the Quran, his distancing from insulting remarks, the city's statement, and no arrests.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not include the mosque's response (it had asked for comment) or any rebuttal of the organiser's claims about the Quran.
- Charged language
- “rebel against Imam's prayer”
What every side reports
- Christian protesters interrupted Imam Sajid Bhuiya's invocation at a Bartow, Florida city commission meeting this week.
- The disruption was captured on video from the city commission's livestream.
Where accounts differ
-
Character of the protest
- Left
- Raw Story calls the Christians 'enraged' and 'irate' and says the meeting 'devolves into chaos' for nearly 10 minutes.
- Right
- Fox News calls it a 'rebel[lion]' with a prayer 'of their own', and quotes an organiser distancing the group from the 'two or three individuals' who made insulting remarks.
Sajid Bhuiya person
Bhuiya, after the interruption, quoted Quran passages he said unify people and called for treating one another with dignity despite differences.
“"This is a reminder that our differences in background, culture and faiths should not prevent us from treating one another with dignity," he said.” — Fox News
Bartow, Florida place
The city says invocations are open to all faiths, consistent with the Constitution, and says protesters tried to stop the imam and the Mayor from conducting business.
“the opportunity is open to all faiths. This is consistent with the United States Constitution.” — Fox News
Left1 article
-
'Quiet down!' Enraged Christians shout down imam as public meeting devolves into chaos
Critical Portrays the protesters as enraged and the meeting as descending into chaos.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Florida Christians rebel against Imam's prayer opening a city meeting with a message of their own
Mixed Presents the protest as a Christian 'rebellion', with extensive space for the organiser's views, alongside the city's statement and the imam's remarks.

- 19 Nov 18:16 First Fox NewsR Florida Christians rebel against Imam's prayer opening a city meeting with a message of their own
- 19 Nov 23:09 +4h 53m Raw StoryL 'Quiet down!' Enraged Christians shout down imam as public meeting devolves into chaos
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…