Queen Camilla hosts Commonwealth Writing Competition winners at St James's Palace
Queen Camilla received the winners of The Queen's Commonwealth Writing Competition at St James's Palace on 20 November. Celebrity readers included Henry Golding, Geri Halliwell-Horner and Dame Jacqueline Wilson.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Queen Camilla hosted a reception at St James's Palace on Friday 20 November for the winners of The Queen's Commonwealth Writing Competition. Evening StandardN “Camilla congratulated the winners of The Queen’s Commonwealth Writing Competition at an event at St James’s Palace on Friday.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “was hosting a reception for winners and runners-up of The Queen's Commonwealth Writing Competition at St James's Palace in London” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2The Daily Mail says the Queen hosted as Vice-Patron of the Royal Commonwealth Society, which has run the competition since 1883. It is described as the world's oldest writing competition for schools. Daily MailR “Her Majesty, as Vice-Patron of the Royal Commonwealth Society” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Evening StandardN “The competition is the world’s oldest writing competition for schools, which has been run by the Royal Commonwealth Society since 1883.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Mixed · 2This year's theme was "Common Ground: Better Together", and entries reached a record. The Daily Mail gives the figure as 53,840 entries from 54 nations; the Evening Standard says more than 53,000. Daily MailR “There was a record-breaking number of entries this year, with 53,840 entries from 54 nations.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Evening StandardN “which received more than 53,000 entries” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Mixed · 2Each of the five Commonwealth regions had a winner, and an overall winner was chosen from them. The overall winner was Itumeleng Mhlongo, 18, a medical student from Johannesburg, South Africa, for her piece Foundation, about a daughter inspired to become a surgeon after her father's death. Evening StandardN “The 18-year-old is a medical student from Johannesburg, South Africa, who won for her piece Foundation” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “The overall winner was South Africa's Itumeleng Mhlongo, 18.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2The other regional winners were Aarav Roy, 15, for Asia (from India, per the Mail); Emma Cai for the Caribbean and Americas (18, from Canada, per the Mail; a first-year university student, per the Standard); Kangwoo Moon, 15, for the Pacific (from New Zealand, per the Mail); and Lydia Siqing, 13, for Europe (from Cyprus, per the Mail). The Mail says the five won an all-expenses-paid week-long trip to London. Evening StandardN “Aarav Roy, 15, was Asia’s winner, first-year university student Emma Cai the top in the Caribbean and Americas, and 13-year-old Lydia Siqing the winner from Europe.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “Aarav Roy, 15, from India; Emma Cai, 18, from Canada; Kangwoo Moon, 15, from New Zealand; and Lydia Siqing, 13, from Cyprus.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2Extracts from the winning pieces were read out by actor Henry Golding, former Spice Girl Geri Halliwell-Horner and author Dame Jacqueline Wilson. The Mail also names Sir Ben Okri and DJ Florence Otedola as celebrity readers. Gyles Brandreth compered, per the Mail. Evening StandardN “including by actor Henry Golding, former Spice Girl Geri Halliwell-Horner and popular children’s author Dame Jacqueline Wilson.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “Other celebrity readers at the event were writers Dame Jacqueline Wilson and Sir Ben Okri, as well as DJ Florence Otedola.”“Gyles Brandreth, who was compering the event” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Mixed · 2In her speech the Queen quoted Beatrix Potter on the "something delicious" about writing the first words of a story. She said reading a well-written piece without knowing where it would lead was also delicious, and that she was "whisked all over the globe, into outer space, under the sea, and into the minds of a few animals". She told the writers they were "truly inspiring writers with exciting futures". Evening StandardN ““I was whisked all over the globe, into outer space, under the sea, and into the minds of a few animals, which Beatrix Potter would thoroughly approve.”” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “you are truly inspiring writers, with exciting futures ahead of you.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Right · 1The Mail reports that the Queen also said the writers had "highlighted how, side by side with our diversity, we share historic ties, values, challenges and, above all, hope", and ended with a Beatrix Potter quotation. Daily MailR “you have highlighted how, side by side with our diversity, we share historic ties, values, challenges and, above all, hope for what lies ahead.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Centre · 1The Queen chatted with the winners and told Mhlongo her story was "absolutely wonderful". She said the competition must be "a nightmare to judge", and Sir Ben Okri joked that the judges came close to strangling each other. Evening StandardN “telling the overall winner Itumeleng Mhlongo how “absolutely wonderful” her story was.”“Booker Prize winning novelist Sir Ben Okri joked the judges came close to strangling each other.” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Right · 1The Mail leads on Halliwell-Horner, a Royal Commonwealth Society Ambassador, greeting the Queen with a hug after the pair kissed on each cheek. It says Golding greeted the Queen with a handshake and a bow of the head. Halliwell-Horner said of the competition, "the standards have gone up". Daily MailR “The singer then appeared to surprise Queen Camilla with a hug.”“'Pleasure to meet you, Ma'am,' he smiled. 'Very nice to see you,' she replied.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2Golding praised the winners' "artistic integrity" and said the day would be one "they will not forget". He said he wanted to inspire his daughters, aged five and three, who are "obsessed with books". The Standard also reports him joking about the casting director and Kangwoo Moon. Evening StandardN “Golding said the reception at St James’s Palace will be “a day that they will not forget.”” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “I have a five-year-old and a three-year-old girl and they are obsessed with books.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2Asked about creativity and AI, Halliwell-Horner said people must accept the shift "from the horse to the car" and treat AI as a tool, because "no-one can ever replace the human heart". She also said she had read to her son the night before. Evening StandardN “But if we see it, embrace it, in the sense that it’s a tool, no-one can ever replace the human heart.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “Geri said has always read to her own children and was reading to her son last night.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Focuses on the Queen's speech and the winners, leading on her "delicious" Beatrix Potter line. It reads as a straightforward event report.
- Emphasis
- The Queen's remarks, the overall winner's story, the celebrity readers' comments on young writers and AI.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the hug, the Royal Commonwealth Society Vice-Patron role, the 54 nations or the winners' trip to London.
- For example
-
“The Queen has recalled the “delicious” feeling of reading the beginning words of a great story as she congratulated young essay prize winners.” — Evening Standard
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Leads on a light, personality-led moment, Halliwell-Horner's "unexpected bear hug", under a playful headline. It then gives a long account of the speech and the readers' comments, with many photo captions.
- Emphasis
- Royal-celebrity interactions, exchanges with Golding (including the James Bond remark), and long verbatim quotes from the speech and the readers.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not report the judges joke by Sir Ben Okri or Golding's casting-director joke.
- Charged language
- “unexpected bear hug”
- For example
-
“The Queen was given a rather unexpected bear hug by former Spice Girl Geri Halliwell-Horner at an event celebrating the talent of young Commonwealth writers.” — Daily Mail
What every side reports
- The reception took place at St James's Palace on Friday 20 November.
- The theme was 'Common Ground: Better Together' and entries were a record.
- Itumeleng Mhlongo, 18, of South Africa was the overall winner.
- Henry Golding, Geri Halliwell-Horner and Dame Jacqueline Wilson read extracts from winning entries.
- The Queen quoted Beatrix Potter on the 'delicious' feeling of a story's first words.
Where accounts differ
-
Number of entries
- Centre
- The Standard says more than 53,000 entries.
- Right
- The Mail gives 53,840 entries from 54 nations.
-
Emma Cai's background
- Centre
- The Standard describes Emma Cai as a first-year university student.
- Right
- The Mail says Emma Cai is 18 and from Canada.
Queen Camilla person
Presents the event as a celebration of inspiring young writers, using Beatrix Potter to say the writers had shown that people across the Commonwealth are "better together".
“We are, as you have demonstrated, better together.” — Daily Mail
“you are truly inspiring writers with exciting futures.” — Evening Standard
Geri Halliwell-Horner person
Says the event showed that human spirit and the heart cannot be replaced, even as AI is accepted as a tool.
“no-one can ever replace the human heart.” — Evening Standard
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre2 articles
-
Queen hails ‘delicious’ feeling of starting new story at essay prize reception
Sympathetic Event report centred on the Queen's speech and winners, with quotes from the celebrity readers.

-

Right1 article
-
Sympathetic Light, celebrity-focused account led by the hug, with extensive quotation of the speech and readers.

- 20 Nov 16:00 First Evening StandardN Queen hails ‘delicious’ feeling of starting new story at essay prize reception
- 20 Nov 16:39 +40m Daily MailR Who Do You Think You Are! Geri Halliwell gives Queen Camilla an unexpected bear hug as pair meet at St James's Palace
- 20 Nov 17:58 +1h 58m Evening StandardN Queen celebrates ‘truly inspiring’ winners of Commonwealth essay prize
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…