Councillor Alan Feeney resigns Reform UK and council seats after secret filming
Alan Feeney, a Reform UK councillor in Solihull and Birmingham, resigned his council posts and left the party after ITV News undercover footage showed him calling Asian homeowners "parasites". He has apologised.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Alan Feeney has resigned from Solihull Council and Birmingham City Council and has left Reform UK, after undercover ITV News filming captured him calling Asian homeowners "parasites". BBC NewsN “A Reform UK councillor filmed calling Asian homeowners "parasites" has resigned from two councils and apologised for his comments.” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “Alan Feeney has resigned as a Reform councillor for Solihull and Birmingham after backlash over racist comments that were captured in an undercover investigation.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2The footage came from an ITV News investigation, gathered over about a year, that featured several Reform members. Feeney was recorded while campaigning before the May council elections. BBC NewsN “Feeney was one of several Reform members featured in the ITV investigation, which was gathered over the course of a year.” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “Secretly filmed footage showed Feeney making racist remarks alongside two other Reform candidates who went on to become councillors, Jamie Campbell and Chris Whelan, while canvassing during May’s local elections.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Centre · 1In the footage he described an area as "infested" with Asian families, called them "absolute parasites", and said no more than 1% of the UK population should be non-white. BBC NewsN “Feeney described an area as "infested" with Asian families and called them "absolute parasites".”“He was also recorded saying no more than 1% of the UK population should be non-white.” Read at BBC News ↗
Mixed · 2In a Facebook post on Friday 16 October, Feeney said: "There is no excuse for my comments." He said he had resigned every post he held on both councils, called his remarks "wrong, offensive and completely unacceptable", and said he took full responsibility. The GuardianLC ““There is no excuse for my comments. With responsibility comes accountability, and it is for that reason that I have resigned every post I hold on both Solihull borough council and Birmingham city council.”” Read at The Guardian ↗ BBC NewsN “his remarks "were wrong, offensive and completely unacceptable"” Read at BBC News ↗ Left · 1He also said the comments did not reflect his true beliefs, particularly about communities he said he had supported for many years. He added that he would undertake "intensive personal analysis" of how such sentiments took root. The GuardianLC “The comments do not reflect my true beliefs or opinions, particularly of the communities mentioned in the report.”“I will be undertaking intensive personal analysis to understand how these sentiments could have taken root” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2The reports differ on how he left Reform. The BBC says the party told it Feeney had "mutually agreed" to resign from the party. The Guardian says he announced on Facebook that he was leaving for "personal reasons" and kept his seats as an independent before resigning them. BBC NewsN “the party told the BBC that Feeney had "mutually agreed" to resign from the party.” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “Feeney announced on Facebook that he was leaving Reform for “personal reasons”, but kept his seats as an independent councillor before resigning.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Mixed · 2Feeney won the Shard End ward on Birmingham City Council in May. The Guardian adds that he also won Castle Bromwich on Solihull council and was appointed deputy mayor of Solihull. The BBC says he defected from the Conservatives to Reform last year. The GuardianLC “Earlier this year, Feeney won seats in the Shard End ward of Birmingham city council and the Castle Bromwich ward of Solihull metropolitan borough council, and was then appointed deputy mayor of Solihull.” Read at The Guardian ↗ BBC NewsN “Feeney, who defected from the Conservative Party to Reform last year, was elected to the Shard End ward on Birmingham City Council in May.” Read at BBC News ↗ Left · 1The Guardian reports that Jamie Campbell and Chris Whelan, two other Reform candidates filmed making racist remarks who later became councillors, have also resigned. The GuardianLC “Both Campbell and Whelan have also resigned after the fallout from the investigation.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Centre · 1Feeney has also been suspended from his job with the prison service, where he was recorded as a custodial manager. The Ministry of Justice called the comments "despicable" and said they would be investigated, with action taken in line with its policy. BBC NewsN “He has also been suspended from his job with the prison service, with the Ministry of Justice [MoJ] describing the comments captured during the documentary as "despicable".”“The MoJ has stated the comments featured in the documentary would be investigated and action taken in line with its policy.” Read at BBC News ↗
Centre · 1Reform MP Robert Jenrick told BBC Radio 4's Today programme he "didn't like what I heard" but said the party had acted quickly. He added that all parties have "bad apples" and denied Reform had a bigger problem than others. A Reform Solihull spokesperson said Feeney was briefly with the party and did not reflect "the views of the group". BBC NewsN “Reform MP Robert Jenrick said he "didn't like what I heard in the documentary" but argued that the party had acted quickly, removing or suspending those in the undercover film.”“A spokesperson for Reform Solihull said Feeney was briefly with the party, but spent the majority of his time as a Conservative councillor, and did not reflect "the views of the group".” Read at BBC News ↗ Mixed · 2The Guardian notes that Nigel Farage has pledged to rid Reform of "extremists" and "bigots" and that the party says it vets everyone who wants to stand. BBC headlines linked to the article refer to questions over Reform's candidate vetting. By-elections will follow on timescales set by the councils. The GuardianLC “Nigel Farage has repeatedly pledged to rid Reform of “extremists” and “bigots”. The party says it carries out vetting checks on everyone who wants to stand for election.” Read at The Guardian ↗ BBC NewsN “Reform faces questions over candidate vetting after undercover filming” Read at BBC News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Headline and lede call the remarks "racist" and put them in the context of Reform's promises on extremists and its vetting.
- Emphasis
- Feeney's own apology, his Solihull deputy mayor role, the two other councillors who resigned, and Farage's pledge.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not include the Ministry of Justice suspension or Jenrick's response.
- Charged language
- “racist remarks”“extremists”“bigots”
- For example
-
“Reform councillor resigns after being filmed making racist remarks” — The Guardian
“Nigel Farage has repeatedly pledged to rid Reform of “extremists” and “bigots”.” — The Guardian
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Straight news report that calls the remarks "offensive" and carries a content warning. It leads on the resignation and gives Reform's responses.
- Emphasis
- The prison-service suspension and Ministry of Justice reaction, Jenrick's defence, Reform Solihull's distancing, and Feeney's Conservative background.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the other two councillors who resigned or his Solihull deputy mayor role.
- Charged language
- “despicable”“infested”“bad apples”
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Alan Feeney was filmed undercover by ITV News calling Asian homeowners "parasites" and saying no more than 1% of the UK population should be non-white.
- He resigned his posts on Solihull and Birmingham councils and apologised in a Facebook post on 16 October.
- He is no longer a Reform UK member and was elected in Shard End, Birmingham, in May.
- He said the remarks do not reflect his true beliefs.
Where accounts differ
-
How Feeney left Reform
- Left
- The Guardian: he said he was leaving for "personal reasons" and briefly stayed on as an independent councillor.
- Centre
- BBC: Reform told it he had "mutually agreed" to resign from the party.
-
Whether the party has a wider problem
- Left
- The Guardian sets the case against Farage's pledge to rid Reform of "extremists" and "bigots" and the party's vetting claims.
- Centre
- The BBC quotes Robert Jenrick saying all parties have "bad apples" and that Reform acted quickly.
Alan Feeney person
Apologised, said there was "no excuse", resigned all his council posts and said the remarks did not reflect his true beliefs.
“There is no excuse for my comments.” — The Guardian
“adding that his remarks "were wrong, offensive and completely unacceptable"” — BBC News
Reform UK party
Says it acted quickly, with Jenrick saying all parties have "bad apples". Reform Solihull says Feeney did not reflect the group's views. The party says it vets all candidates.
“He added that all parties had "bad apples" and denied it was any more of a problem in Reform than other parties.” — BBC News
“The party says it carries out vetting checks on everyone who wants to stand for election.” — The Guardian
Left1 article
-
Reform councillor resigns after being filmed making racist remarks
Critical Calls the remarks racist and places the resignation against Farage's pledge on extremists and Reform's vetting.

Centre1 article
-
Reform councillor quits over offensive remarks
Neutral Straight report on the resignation with responses from Reform, the Ministry of Justice and Feeney.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 16 Oct 16:18 First BBC NewsN Reform councillor quits over offensive remarks
- 16 Oct 23:30 +7h 12m The GuardianLC Reform councillor resigns after being filmed making racist remarks
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…