Fewer than 2,000 people remain in Russian-occupied Oleshky as winter nears with no evacuation deal
Food, medicine, power, heat and water are lacking in Oleshky, a Russian-occupied Ukrainian city on the Dnipro. Russia and Ukraine blame each other, and no humanitarian corridor has been agreed.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Oleshky, a Russian-occupied city on the Dnipro River in southeastern Ukraine, has had scarce food and medical supplies for months, and has no electricity, heating or running water, according to an Associated Press report. Arab NewsRC “Food and medical supplies have been scarce for months in Oleshky, which sits on the Dnipro River that separates Ukrainian forces from the city’s Russian occupiers.” Read at Arab News ↗ The IndependentLC “The city has been left entirely without electricity, heating or running water.” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2The remaining population has fallen to fewer than 2,000, from about 24,000 before Moscow's forces captured the city on the first day of the full-scale invasion in 2022. Arab NewsRC “Once a city of about 24,000, Oleshky was captured by Moscow’s forces on the first day of their full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022.” Read at Arab News ↗ The IndependentLC “With the stranded population shrinking to under 2,000” Read at The Independent ↗ Right · 1The city was further hit in June 2023, when floodwaters followed the Kakhovka Dam collapse; an AP investigation found the explosion was likely caused by the Russian military, and hundreds of residents were killed. Arab NewsRC “Further calamity struck in June 2023 when floodwaters inundated the city after the Kakhovka Dam collapsed from an explosion that an Associated Press investigation found was likely caused by the Russian military, killing hundreds of residents.” Read at Arab News ↗
Mixed · 2A 40-year-old former hairdresser, who fled in August and spoke anonymously, walked 20 kilometres (12 miles) along the partly mined route to the occupied village of Radensk, known as "the road of death", saying "every step could have been my last"; she said an acquaintance bringing food was killed on the road when his car came under fire. Arab NewsRC “So the 40-year-old former hairdresser walked — for 20 kilometers (12 miles), along the partially mined road — fearing that “every step could have been my last,” she said.” Read at Arab News ↗ The IndependentLC “She said an acquaintance who tried to bring food into Oleshky was killed on the road when his car came under fire” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2Tetiana Hasanenko, the exiled head of the city's Ukrainian military administration, said the route is called "the road of death" because corpses lie on it, citing an explosion this month that killed four people; she also said about 100 bodies fill the hospital basement and at least 35 children remain in the city. Arab NewsRC “Hasanenko said the route from Oleshky to Radensk is known as “the road of death” because “corpses lie on this road and no one is taking them away.” She cited an explosion this month that killed four people and left an 86-year-old man badly wounded.” Read at Arab News ↗ The IndependentLC “Another 100 bodies fill the basement of Oleshky's hospital, said Tetiana Hasanenko” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2The UN human rights office said the last regular food delivery by road was on 26 May, and that the hospital lacks medicine and basic supplies while drone attacks stop ambulances reaching patients; Russian-installed officials said this month they delivered 2 tonnes of aid but admitted it was hardly enough. Arab NewsRC “The UN human rights office said the last regular food delivery by road was May 26. Oleshky’s Russian-installed officials said this month they delivered 2 tons of aid, although they admitted it was hardly enough.” Read at Arab News ↗ The IndependentLC “The U.N. office said Oleshky's hospital lacks medicine and basic supplies, drone attacks prevent ambulances from reaching patients, and it's unsafe to take them elsewhere.” Read at The Independent ↗
Mixed · 2Lt. Yevhen Voronetskyi of Ukraine's 34th Separate Marine Brigade said his unit has flown food, hygiene kits and medicine, including insulin, into the city by drone for at least a year, and that the aid is meant to help people gather strength to leave rather than to last the winter; the two outlets give different totals delivered since September (more than 7 tons versus more than two tonnes). Arab NewsRC “adding that more than 7 tons were delivered since September.” Read at Arab News ↗ The IndependentLC “adding that more than two tonnes were delivered since September.” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2Russia says Ukraine deliberately blocks supplies and evacuations, while Kyiv says Moscow is effectively holding civilians hostage; Ukraine has repeatedly asked for a local ceasefire to organise evacuations, and Russia, which as occupying power is obliged under international law to ensure civilians have what they need to survive, has made no commitment. Arab NewsRC “Both sides blame each other for the catastrophe. Russia says Ukraine deliberately blocks supplies and evacuations; Kyiv counters that Moscow is effectively holding civilians hostage.” Read at Arab News ↗ The IndependentLC “Russia, which as the occupying power is obligated by international law to ensure civilians under its control have what they need to survive, has made no commitment.” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2President Volodymyr Zelensky said on 12 October at a forum in Poland that Oleshky had been "razed to the ground", and on Friday Pope Leo XIV urged President Vladimir Putin by phone to agree a ceasefire for aid deliveries and evacuations, the Vatican said; the Kremlin said Putin backed the Vatican's efforts and was ready to cooperate. Arab NewsRC “In a phone call Friday with President Vladimir Putin, Pope Leo XIV urged a ceasefire to allow food and medicine deliveries to Oleshky and to safely evacuate civilians, the Vatican said.” Read at Arab News ↗ The IndependentLC “President Volodymyr Zelensky mentioned Oleshky’s suffering at the hands of Russia on 12 October at an international forum in Poland, saying the city had been “razed to the ground.”” Read at The Independent ↗
Mixed · 2The UN human rights office said Russia and Ukraine have discussed a temporary ceasefire and humanitarian corridor without agreement; Ukraine's human rights commissioner's office said Russia has not given clear, verifiable guarantees; Russian-installed officials said mined roads make evacuation impossible and not all residents want to leave; and the ICRC said it would help only if both sides agree and civilians have security guarantees. Arab NewsRC ““Russia has not provided clear, verifiable guarantees for conducting a humanitarian operation,” according to the office of Ukrainian human rights commissioner Dmytro Lubinets.” Read at Arab News ↗ The IndependentLC “The mined roads make an evacuation impossible, and not all residents want to leave, according to the city's Russian-installed officials.”“The International Committee of the Red Cross was ready to assist an evacuation but only if both countries agree and there are security guarantees for civilians, said ICRC spokesperson Sarah Davies.” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2Vladimir Saldo, the Moscow-appointed governor of the occupied part of Kherson region, promised earlier this month to help anyone wishing to leave, but the former hairdresser said residents' appeals and lists of people wanting to leave led to nothing. Arab NewsRC “Vladimir Saldo, who was appointed by Moscow as governor of the occupied part of the Kherson region, promised earlier this month to help anyone who wants to leave the town.” Read at Arab News ↗ The IndependentLC “residents have appealed to local authorities several times for a humanitarian corridor and submitted lists of those hoping to leave, but nothing came of it.” Read at The Independent ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- The Independent runs the AP report under a headline stressing starvation and the 'road of death', rewritten with a more dramatic lede about the city's seizure in 2022.
- Emphasis
- Civilian peril and the threat of starvation; the account of the escape along the mined road.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Drops the AP's subheadings and gives a lower figure for drone aid delivered (two tonnes).
- Charged language
- “starvation”“road of death”“severe humanitarian catastrophe”
- For example
-
“Trapped civilians in Russian-occupied city in Ukraine face starvation or ‘road of death’” — The Independent
“plunge deeper into a severe humanitarian catastrophe” — The Independent
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Arab News carries the AP report under a headline about a looming winter of hunger for trapped residents, with the AP's subheadings on the overflowing morgue, evacuee help, stalled evacuation talks and Ukrainian drone aid.
- Emphasis
- Humanitarian crisis and the winter ahead; the stalled talks on evacuation.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the Independent's lower drone-aid total; the text is otherwise close to the same AP copy.
- Charged language
- “winter of hunger”“The morgue overflows with bodies”
What every side reports
- Oleshky lacks electricity, heating, running water, food and medical supplies, and fewer than 2,000 residents remain.
- The last regular UN-recorded road food delivery was on 26 May.
- Russia and Ukraine blame each other, and no humanitarian corridor or ceasefire has been agreed.
- Pope Leo XIV urged Putin by phone on Friday to allow aid and evacuations.
Where accounts differ
-
Who is responsible for the lack of aid and evacuation
- Left
- Reports Russia's claim that Ukraine blocks supplies and evacuations and Kyiv's claim that Moscow holds civilians hostage, noting Russia's obligations as occupying power.
- Right
- Reports the same two claims and notes Russia's obligations as occupying power, in the same words.
-
Amount of aid Ukrainian drones have delivered since September
- Left
- The Independent: more than two tonnes.
- Right
- Arab News: more than 7 tons.
Left1 article
-
Trapped civilians in Russian-occupied city in Ukraine face starvation or ‘road of death’
Alarmist AP-bylined report in The Independent, headlined on starvation and the 'road of death', with a vivid lede on the occupation.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Arab NewsRC · · via AP
A winter of hunger looms for residents trapped in Russian-occupied city in Ukraine
Alarmist AP copy carried by Arab News, presenting a looming humanitarian disaster with subheaded sections and a stalled evacuation process.

- 17 Oct 05:50 First Arab NewsRC A winter of hunger looms for residents trapped in Russian-occupied city in Ukraine via AP
- 17 Oct 16:49 +11h The IndependentLC Trapped civilians in Russian-occupied city in Ukraine face starvation or ‘road of death’
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…