Reviews of Bruce Norris's 'Downstate' on Broadway praise play about sex offenders
Bruce Norris's play 'Downstate', about convicted sex offenders in an Illinois group home, opened on Broadway at the Booth Theatre. Reviewers at Deadline and the New York Post both praise the writing, direction and cast, and both address the controversy around the subject.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Bruce Norris's play 'Downstate', directed by Joe Mantello, opened on Broadway at the Booth Theatre on Sunday night, 15 November 2026. New York PostR “which opened Sunday night” Read at New York Post ↗ DeadlineN “Venue: Broadway’s Booth TheatreWritten By: Bruce NorrisDirected By: Joe Mantello” Read at Deadline ↗ Mixed · 2It is set in a shabby group home in downstate Illinois where four men who are convicted sex offenders live after serving their prison sentences, under strict observation and restrictions. DeadlineN “is a convicted sex offender and child predator who has officially served his time in prison but, with no where to go, is living in this group home under strict observation and restrictions.” Read at Deadline ↗ New York PostR “four very different men are confined to this cramped, gray apartment after serving their prison sentences for their crimes” Read at New York Post ↗ Mixed · 2The residents are Fred (Francis Guinan), an elderly, frail man; Dee (K. Todd Freeman), an older man who acts as the house's de facto spokesman or house mother; Gio (Al’Jaleel McGhee), the youngest, whose victim was 17; and Felix (Adrian Martinez), a quiet, religious loner. DeadlineN “Sharing the home (flawlessly designed by the ever-reliable Scott Pask) with Fred are Dee (K. Todd Freeman)” Read at Deadline ↗ New York PostR “He hooked up with a 17-year-old who used a fake ID.” Read at New York Post ↗
Mixed · 2The central event is a visit from Andy (Thomas Sadoski), a former piano student of Fred's, who comes with his wife Em (Cassie Beck) to confront the man who abused him; Liza Colón-Zayas plays the probation officer who oversees the men. DeadlineN “Fred is a former piano teacher, Andy his former student and you can probably guess the rest.” Read at Deadline ↗ New York PostR “visits the home with his wife (Cassie Beck) to confront Fred and get some closure” Read at New York Post ↗ Centre · 1Deadline's Greg Evans calls the play 'commandingly written and shrewdly directed', says it questions the limits of compassion and empathy, and writes that it 'dares us to forgive the unforgivable'. DeadlineN “a commandingly written and shrewdly directed (by Joe Mantello) work that asks us to confront some of the very things we prize most in ourselves”“Downstate dares us to forgive the unforgivable, challenging the very concept of grace.” Read at Deadline ↗ Centre · 1Evans says he left convinced that none of the four characters should live unrestricted in society, and that seeing their humanity is 'not the same as asking us to excuse their crimes'. DeadlineN “not one of these four characters should live unrestricted among society”“that is most certainly not the same as asking us to excuse their crimes” Read at Deadline ↗
Right · 1The New York Post's Johnny Oleksinski calls it 'the best new play on Broadway' and 'one of the finest works of the decade', citing its 'palpable danger' and 'unrelenting shocks'. New York PostR “Easily one of the finest works of the decade, “Downstate” is the best new play I’ve seen since, well, “Downstate.”” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1Oleksinski writes that Norris does not tell the audience how to feel about the men, and that they are made to seem friendly and repentant before some are revealed as pathological liars or people who would offend again. New York PostR “doesn’t decide how you should feel about any of these pariahs”“reveal them as pathological liars or sickos who would do it all over again the next” Read at New York Post ↗ Mixed · 2Both reviewers praise the cast and Mantello's direction, and both note that the play is unexpectedly funny. DeadlineN “somehow, Downstate has an improbable amount of genuine humor” Read at Deadline ↗ New York PostR “Joe Mantello, fresh off “Death of a Salesman,” directs each scene as a cage match with not a single wasted second.” Read at New York Post ↗
Mixed · 2Both reviews recall earlier controversy. The Post says the play caused a huge controversy during its off-Broadway run at Playwrights Horizons four years ago, stirred up largely by people who had not seen it; Deadline says earlier productions in Washington, Off Broadway, London and at Chicago's Steppenwolf drew some right-wing ire. New York PostR “The play caused a huge controversy four years ago during its otherwise acclaimed off-Broadway run at Playwrights Horizons” Read at New York Post ↗ DeadlineN “drawing some right-wing ire” Read at Deadline ↗ Centre · 1Deadline says Senator Ted Cruz tweeted, after a positive Washington Post review, 'So now the corporate media is praising pedophilia'; Evans calls that reaction 'wrong-headed' and 'Nonsense'. DeadlineN “Ted Cruz tweeted, “So now the corporate media is praising pedophilia””““Praising pedophilia?” Nonsense.” Read at Deadline ↗ Mixed · 2The reviews differ on some details: Deadline gives a running time of 2 hours 20 minutes and has Fred in a wheelchair, while the Post gives 2 hours 30 minutes and describes a motor scooter. DeadlineN “Running Time: 2 hr 20 min (including intermission)” Read at Deadline ↗ New York PostR “Two hours and 30 minutes, with one intermission.”“an elderly man who’s confined to a motor scooter” Read at New York Post ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Deadline treats the play as a morally challenging work about the limits of forgiveness and empathy, and defends it against critics who say it praises pedophilia.
- Emphasis
- Themes of compassion and forgiveness, character detail, the cast and design, and the political backlash including Ted Cruz's tweet.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not describe the play's audience reaction at performances or rank it against other current Broadway plays.
- Charged language
- “Provocative”“cognitive dissonance”“dares us to forgive the unforgivable”
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- The New York Post gives a rave, calling it the best new play on Broadway, and presents it as bracing, impolite theatre that contrasts with a theatre scene it says tends to 'lecture, coddle and affirm'.
- Emphasis
- Shock value, danger and audience discomfort, the performances of Sadoski, Freeman and Martinez, and the claim that critics of the earlier controversy had not seen the play.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the political criticism of the play from figures such as Ted Cruz.
- Charged language
- “loathsome, real-life Gargamels”“sickos”“gasp-a-thon”“lecture, coddle and affirm”
- For example
-
“What a nice change from the theater’s recent tendency to lecture, coddle and affirm.” — New York Post
“largely stirred up by people who didn’t actually watch it. Big shock.” — New York Post
What every side reports
- 'Downstate' by Bruce Norris, directed by Joe Mantello, is playing at Broadway's Booth Theatre.
- The play centres on convicted sex offenders living in a group home in downstate Illinois.
- Both reviewers praise the writing, direction and cast.
- Both note the play's humour and its earlier controversy.
Where accounts differ
-
Running time and some staging details
- Centre
- Deadline lists 2 hr 20 min including intermission and describes Fred as in a wheelchair.
- Right
- The Post lists 2 hr 30 min with one intermission and describes Fred as confined to a motor scooter.
-
Whether the play invites sympathy for the offenders
- Centre
- Deadline says it asks us to see their humanity without excusing their crimes, and rejects the claim that it praises pedophilia.
- Right
- The Post says Norris does not tell the audience how to feel, and stresses that the men are scary because they are likeable.
Bruce Norris person
As described by the reviewers, the playwright shows the men's humanity and does not tell the audience how to judge them; the Post says he 'doesn't decide how you should feel' and Deadline says the play does not ask us to excuse their crimes. Norris is not quoted in either review.
“doesn’t decide how you should feel about any of these pariahs” — New York Post
“True, Downstate insists that we see and consider the humanity of these men” — Deadline
Downstate (play) other
Both reviews present the production as a critical success with a strong cast, following an earlier controversial run.
“Bruce Norris‘ tricky new play that’s gained considerable acclaim and controversy” — Deadline
“Controversial ‘Downstate’ is the best new play on Broadway” — New York Post
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre1 article
-
DeadlineN · · Opinion
Sympathetic A favourable review that treats the play as a serious exploration of forgiveness and rebuts the 'praising pedophilia' charge.

Right1 article
-
New York PostR · · Opinion
Controversial ‘Downstate’ is the best new play on Broadway
Celebratory A rave that calls the play the best new Broadway play and celebrates its shocks and refusal to be 'polite'.

- 16 Nov 03:00 First New York PostR Controversial ‘Downstate’ is the best new play on Broadway Opinion
- 16 Nov 03:00 First DeadlineN ‘Downstate’ Broadway Review: Provocative Play About Sex Offenders Questions The Nature Of Forgiveness Opinion
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…