'The Fantasticks' opens on Broadway with a gender-swapped cast; reviews warm
Second Stage's revival of 'The Fantasticks', directed by Christopher Gattelli, opened at Broadway's Hayes Theater with the young lovers now two men and the fathers now mothers. Deadline and the New York Post both review it favourably, with reservations about the second act.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2'The Fantasticks', the Tom Jones–Harvey Schmidt musical, opened on Broadway for the first time at the Hayes Theater on Monday 16 November 2026, in a revival directed and choreographed by Christopher Gattelli. DeadlineN “opening for the first time ever on Broadway tonight” Read at Deadline ↗ New York PostR “their upgraded and cute-as-ever production that opened Monday night at the Hayes Theater” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1The New York Post says the production is by Second Stage Theater. New York PostR “director Christopher Gattelli and Second Stage Theater have found a pretty decent one” Read at New York Post ↗ Mixed · 2The revival changes the genders of three roles: the young lovers, Matt (Maxim Chlumecky) and Lewis (Nathan Levy, in the role of Luisa in the original), are now two men, and their feuding fathers are now mothers, played by Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer (Mildred) and Ruthie Ann Miles (Bessie May). DeadlineN “reimagines the musical’s star-crossed boy-meets-girl plot for a boy-meets-boy world” Read at Deadline ↗ New York PostR “Guns-a-blazin’ Kritzer plays Mildred and snappy Miles is Bessie May” Read at New York Post ↗
Mixed · 2Zane Phillips makes his Broadway debut as El Gallo, the magician who narrates and sings 'Try to Remember'. David Patrick Kelly and Kevin del Aguila play the two itinerant actors, and Ahmad Simmons plays the wall. DeadlineN “Fire Island‘s Zane Phillips making an impressive Broadway debut as El Gallo” Read at Deadline ↗ New York PostR “sings the musical’s most famous song, “Try to Remember,” in a soothing baritone” Read at New York Post ↗ Mixed · 2The show ran Off Broadway for decades. Deadline cites 42 years in total; the Post says 42 years at the Sullivan Street Playhouse, then another nine at the Jerry Orbach Theater until 2017, and calls it the longest-running musical in the world. DeadlineN “kept The Fantasticks running Off Broadway for a total 42 years (!)” Read at Deadline ↗ New York PostR “Its record stands as the longest-running musical in the world.” Read at New York Post ↗ Centre · 1Deadline's Greg Evans calls it a welcome debut that is faithful to the show's winsomeness while having a fresh attitude, and says the musical supports the gender switch with remarkable ease. He notes Tom Jones revised the lyrics shortly before his death in 2023, and that Sam Davis's new orchestrations add strings, woodwinds and some brass to the original's piano and harp sound. DeadlineN “the musical supports the gender-switch with remarkable ease”“Sam Davis’ appealing new orchestrations that add strings, woodwinds and some brass” Read at Deadline ↗
Right · 1The Post's Johnny Oleksinski says a revival so soon after the Off Broadway run needs 'a damn good reason' and finds the gender swap a pretty decent one. He says it removes some dated 'Mad Men'-era wrinkles but leaves the takeaway as it would have been in 1960. He praises the score and the performances of Kritzer, Miles, Levy, Chlumecky and Phillips. New York PostR “you better have a damn good reason.”“What the casting choices do, beneficially, is iron out some of those “Mad Men”-era wrinkles for 2026.” Read at New York Post ↗ Mixed · 2Both critics see weaknesses in the second act. Deadline calls it 'increasingly cloying' and says it 'drags and strains under its own contrivances'. The Post says it is less boisterous or tidy than the first, but that fixating on its flaws is trite after five decades of success. DeadlineN “the musical’s increasingly cloying second act drags and strains under its own contrivances” Read at Deadline ↗ New York PostR “The second act isn’t as boisterous or tidy as the first” Read at New York Post ↗ Mixed · 2Both note the 'abduction' lyric change. Deadline says the original used the word 'rape', an archaic synonym for abduction, and that most productions now say 'abduction'. The Post dates the rewrite to 2006. Deadline notes the character 'The Mute' keeps its traditional billing. DeadlineN “most productions of the musical, they make the wise decision to just say abduction” Read at Deadline ↗ New York PostR “Back in 2006, the creators had to redo an upbeat comic song that mentioned rape.” Read at New York Post ↗
Mixed · 2On design, Deadline describes Jason Sherwood's minimalist set (brick backdrop, cut-out crescent moon), Linda Cho's costumes and Gattelli's restrained choreography. The Post says Gattelli is 'rightly restrained' and praises an opening that dissolves a Sullivan Street Playhouse tableau into the Hayes's white stage. Running time is 2 hours 5 minutes with one intermission. DeadlineN “Jason Sherwood’s set design (the usual brick theater backdrop, a cut-out crescent moon” Read at Deadline ↗ New York PostR “disappears to reveal the Hayes’ gleaming, stark-white stage” Read at New York Post ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Deadline treats the opening as a long-awaited Broadway debut and a faithful, fresh revival, with measured reservations about the material.
- Emphasis
- The show's Off Broadway history, the boy-meets-boy reimagining, orchestrations, design and the cast's mix of newcomers and veterans.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not dwell on whether the revival needed a justification so soon after the 2017 close of the Off Broadway run.
- Charged language
- “impossibly twee”“theatrical warhorse”
- For example
-
“a fresh attitude and a devotion to the spirit of a work that all but defined Off Broadway charm” — Deadline
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- The New York Post asks why revive the show so soon, then judges the gender swap a good enough reason, in a breezy, jokey review.
- Emphasis
- The gender swap as justification, the performances, the score's tunefulness and the Hayes's intimacy.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Gives less detail on orchestrations and design than Deadline.
- Charged language
- “pure bubblegum”“demon twink”“ear-worm farm”
- For example
-
“For the most part, “The Fantasticks” is still pure bubblegum.” — New York Post
What every side reports
- The revival opened at Broadway's Hayes Theater, directed by Christopher Gattelli.
- The lovers are now two men and the parents mothers, with Kritzer and Miles as the mothers.
- Zane Phillips makes his Broadway debut as El Gallo.
- Both reviews praise the score and cast and criticise the second act.
- The original's 'rape' lyric was changed to 'abduction'.
Where accounts differ
-
How much the gender swap changes the show
- Centre
- Deadline says the musical supports the switch 'with remarkable ease' and that the revival has a fresh attitude while staying devoted to the original's spirit.
- Right
- The Post says the swap irons out dated wrinkles but doesn't alter the bones of the piece; the takeaway is identical to 1960.
The Fantasticks other
Both reviews present the musical as a beloved, minimalist classic whose gender-swapped Broadway revival honours its origins while still showing the second act's flaws.
“a devotion to the spirit of a work that all but defined Off Broadway charm” — Deadline
“nodding to the show’s humble origins while recognizing Broadway audiences expect a touch of glitz” — New York Post
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre1 article
-
DeadlineN · · Opinion
‘The Fantasticks’ Review: A Welcome Broadway Debut Seven Decades In The Making
Sympathetic Warm review that welcomes the faithful, gender-swapped revival while faulting the second act.

Right1 article
-
New York PostR · · Opinion
‘The Fantasticks’ review: World’s longest-running musical returns — with a twist
Sympathetic Playful, mostly positive review that frames the gender swap as the revival's justification and praises the cast.

- 17 Nov 03:00 First DeadlineN ‘The Fantasticks’ Review: A Welcome Broadway Debut Seven Decades In The Making Opinion
- 17 Nov 18:08 +15h 9m New York PostR ‘The Fantasticks’ review: World’s longest-running musical returns — with a twist Opinion
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…