Skip to content
Bramble

Entertainment

Russell T Davies says he keeps a knife by his door after a stranger came to his home

In a Guardian interview ahead of the memoir The Queerest of Folk, screenwriter Russell T Davies said online smears over his support for trans rights have led to threats and one person turning up at his house. The Independent followed up with a short report on the remarks.

2 outlets · 2L · 0C · 0R First reported Account updated
Image: The Guardian
Image: The Independent

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Left · 2Screenwriter Russell T Davies, 63, told The Guardian that he keeps a kitchen knife by his front door, "ready to use", after one person turned up at his house. Left · 2Davies said his support for trans rights has brought years of death threats and "groomer" smears, which he used to brush off, and that he is called a paedophile and a groomer online by people such as Father Ted creator and anti-trans activist Graham Linehan. Left · 2Davies said: "If you believe a paedophile lives here, it's not the maddest thing in the world to come and get me," and added that he cannot see an end to the problem, blaming "tech barons" and saying hatred is being monetised by an algorithm.

Left · 2The interview, by Joe Stone, was held at Davies's Swansea home to discuss The Queerest of Folk, a memoir of Davies's career that The Independent says is due out later this month. Left · 1Davies discussed the 2011 brain tumour diagnosis of partner Andrew Smith, who was initially given 18 months to live; Davies quit work to become a carer, and Smith lived until 2018. Left · 1Davies said that after Smith's death, the schedule of Years and Years forced a return to work within days, and that writing was "a nice escape"; the memoir says Davies then spent eight years sitting at home, during which Davies made Years and Years, returned to Doctor Who and wrote It's a Sin, Nolly and Tip Toe.

Left · 1On Tip Toe, a drama about neighbours on opposite sides of the political divide, Davies defended including a gender-critical character, Stephanie, saying "it's important to hear all voices" and asking "Where is the debate?"; the show upset some viewers. Left · 1Asked whether he would still write Queer As Folk's storyline of a one-night stand between a 29-year-old and a 15-year-old, given today's accusations of grooming against gay men, Davies said he would, arguing the context of Section 28 in 1999 was different. Left · 1Davies led the revival of Doctor Who, which was the No 1 show on British television during the 2005–2010 tenure, and later returned as showrunner; the Guardian piece also covers Davies's family, including a father who never knew Davies wrote for television full-time.

Left · 1The Independent added background on Davies's shows and on paedophile hunters, describing them as controversial groups that some call "vigilantes" and others praise, and noted the activity is not against the law in itself. It also quoted Davies on rights closing like slow pneumatic hinges.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left2 outlets

Framing
The Guardian runs a long, warm profile of a beloved showrunner whose fame has brought hatred; the Independent condenses it into a news item on the knife and the threats. Both treat the online smears as a real danger.
Emphasis
Guardian: personal history, grief, fandom and Davies's views on Tip Toe and Queer As Folk. Independent: the knife, the address leak and the threats.
Leaves out or plays down
The Independent leaves out the grief, fandom and gender-critical character debate that the Guardian covers. Neither outlet reports comment from anyone accused of the smears, and neither reports police involvement.
Charged language
“titan of TV”“paedophile hunters”“vigilantes”
For example
“He’s the titan of TV who revived a flatlined Doctor Who and turned British queer life into jaw-dropping drama.” — The Guardian
“Former ‘Doctor Who’ showrunner’s support of trans rights has resulted in years of death threats” — The Independent

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right0 outlets

No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.