Russia claims Dobropillia and seven more settlements; Ukraine says the claims are false
Russia's defence ministry said it took eight more Ukrainian settlements, including Dobropillia. Ukraine's General Staff said the town is still under Ukrainian control and rejected Russia's wider claims of territorial gains since 1 September.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
Right · 1Russia's defence ministry said on Saturday 17 October that its forces had taken control of eight more Ukrainian settlements, including the town of Dobropillia in the eastern Donetsk region, according to Interfax. The Jerusalem PostRC “its forces had taken control of eight more Ukrainian settlements, including the town of Dobropillia in the eastern Donetsk region, news agency Interfax reported.” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ Right · 2Ukraine's General Staff said Ukrainian forces remained in control of Dobropillia, which lies southwest of Sloviansk and Kramatorsk, and called the Russian claim untrue; it said the town was still held despite sustained Russian attacks. The Jerusalem PostRC “Ukrainian forces remained in control of the eastern town of Dobropillia, describing Russia's claim to have captured it as untrue.” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ The Straits TimesRC “He said Dobropillia, southwest of the two cities, remained under Ukrainian control despite sustained Russian attacks.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Right · 2On Friday, Russia's General Staff chief Valery Gerasimov told President Vladimir Putin that Russian forces had captured 92 Ukrainian settlements, more than 1,800 square km (695 square miles) of territory, since 1 September, and that they had reached the outskirts of Kramatorsk and were advancing in the suburbs of Sloviansk. The Straits TimesRC “Valery Gerasimov, told President Vladimir Putin that Russian forces had captured 92 Ukrainian settlements and made significant territorial gains since the start of last month.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Arab NewsRC “Kovaliov also rejected Gerasimov’s claims that Russian troops had reached the outskirts of Kramatorsk and were advancing in the suburbs of Sloviansk.” Read at Arab News ↗
Right · 2General Staff spokesman Andriy Kovaliov rejected these claims in an emailed statement, saying Ukrainian forces had in fact liberated more territory since the start of autumn than Russia had captured, and that Russian military leadership was creating "an illusion of major victories" for its political leadership and domestic audience. The Straits TimesRC “"In fact, through their active operations, the Ukrainian Defence Forces have liberated more territory since the beginning of autumn than the enemy has managed to capture," he said in an emailed statement.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Arab NewsRC ““The Russian military leadership continues to create an illusion of major victories for its political leadership and domestic audience,” he said.” Read at Arab News ↗ Right · 2Reuters said it could not independently verify the battlefield claims on either side. The Straits TimesRC “Reuters could not independently verify the battlefield claims.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ The Jerusalem PostRC “Reuters could not independently verify the battlefield report.” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ Right · 1Russia's advances have slowed this year, but its forces have been closing on the "fortress belt" cities of Sloviansk and Kramatorsk, whose capture would bring Russia closer to seizing the whole industrialised Donetsk region. Arab NewsRC “Russia’s advances along the front line have slowed this year but its forces have been bearing down on the so-called “fortress belt” cities of Sloviansk and Kramatorsk” Read at Arab News ↗
Right · 1The Russian ministry also said it had struck Ukrainian drone storage sites and transport infrastructure over the past 24 hours, and President Volodymyr Zelensky said Russia attacked more than 15 Ukrainian energy facilities in western and central regions overnight, accusing Moscow of trying to stretch Ukraine's reserves and repair capacity. The Jerusalem PostRC “The ministry also said it had struck Ukrainian drone storage sites and transport infrastructure used by Ukraine's armed forces over the past 24 hours.”“Russia attacked more than 15 Ukrainian energy facilities in western and central regions overnight.” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ Right · 2With front lines largely static, both sides have stepped up air campaigns: Russia fired hundreds of ballistic missiles over the summer and early autumn and is expected to target heating and power sites into winter, while Ukraine has launched hundreds of long-range drone attacks on Russian refineries, ships and warehouses. The Straits TimesRC “Russia fired hundreds of ballistic missiles over the summer and early autumn and is widely expected to target critical infrastructure including heating and power sites into the winter.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Arab NewsRC “Ukraine, which has a far smaller missile arsenal, has launched hundreds of long-range drone attacks on Russian refineries, ships and warehouses.” Read at Arab News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right3 outlets
- Framing
- All three outlets run Reuters copy. Two lead with Ukraine's rejection of Russia's claims as "an illusion"; the Jerusalem Post leads with the Russian claim and Ukraine's denial.
- Emphasis
- Ukraine's General Staff denial, Gerasimov's figures, and the Sloviansk and Kramatorsk context.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No independent or Russian-side detail beyond Interfax and Gerasimov's reported statement; the Straits Times and Arab News omit the eight-settlement ministry claim.
- Charged language
- “an illusion”“fortress belt”“kill zone”
- For example
-
“The Russian military leadership continues to create an illusion of major victories for its political leadership and domestic audience” — The Straits Times
“Russia claims control of eight more Ukrainian settlements, Ukraine disputes” — The Jerusalem Post
What every side reports
- Russia says it captured Dobropillia and other settlements; Ukraine's General Staff says Dobropillia is still under Ukrainian control.
- Gerasimov claimed 92 settlements and over 1,800 sq km captured since 1 September; Ukraine rejected this.
- Reuters could not independently verify the battlefield claims.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether Russia captured Dobropillia
- Right
- Russia's defence ministry says it did; Ukraine's General Staff says the town remains under Ukrainian control. Reuters copy in all three outlets could not verify either account.
-
Who is gaining ground since 1 September
- Right
- Gerasimov says Russia took 92 settlements and over 1,800 sq km; Kovaliov says Ukraine has liberated more territory than Russia has captured.
-
Russian forces captured the town of Dobropillia.
Disputed- Disputes 3
- Arab News, The Jerusalem Post, The Straits Times
-
Russian forces captured over 1,800 sq km and 92 settlements since September 1.
Reported- Reports 3
- Arab News, The Jerusalem Post, The Straits Times
Russia place
Russia's defence ministry and General Staff chief Gerasimov say Russian forces are taking settlements, including Dobropillia, and nearing Kramatorsk and Sloviansk.
“its forces had taken control of eight more Ukrainian settlements” — The Jerusalem Post
Ukraine place
Ukraine's General Staff calls the claims false and says Ukraine has gained more territory than it lost this autumn; Zelensky highlights Russian strikes on energy sites.
“Ukraine’s General Staff spokesman Andriy Kovaliov dismissed the claims as false.” — Arab News
Dobropillia place
Dobropillia is the town at the centre of the dispute; Ukraine says it remains under its control.
“Dobropillia, southwest of the two cities, remained under Ukrainian control despite sustained Russian attacks.” — The Straits Times
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right3 articles
-
The Straits TimesRC · · via Reuters
Ukraine says Russia's claimed territorial advances are 'an illusion'
Neutral Reuters copy led by Ukraine's rejection, with Kovaliov's quotes and context on the Donetsk front and air campaigns.
-
Ukraine says Russia’s claimed territorial advances are ‘an illusion’
Neutral Reuters-based text under a Kyiv dateline, near-identical to the Straits Times version.
-
Russia claims control of eight more Ukrainian settlements, Ukraine disputes
Neutral Reuters copy leading with Russia's claim and Ukraine's denial, adding Zelensky's report of strikes on energy facilities.
- 17 Oct 13:10 First The Jerusalem PostRC Russia claims control of eight more Ukrainian settlements, Ukraine disputes
- 17 Oct 14:00 +51m The Straits TimesRC Ukraine says Russia's claimed territorial advances are 'an illusion' via Reuters
- 17 Oct 14:21 +1h 11m Arab NewsRC Ukraine says Russia’s claimed territorial advances are ‘an illusion’
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…