Russian strike on buses in Kramatorsk, eastern Ukraine, kills at least 12; toll later put at 30
A Russian bomb hit a street with two city buses in Kramatorsk on the morning of 8 October. Early reports said at least 12 dead; later official figures cited by France 24 put the toll at 30.
1 / 8
The story, neutrally told
Right · 1A Russian bomb attack on Kramatorsk, in the eastern Ukrainian region of Donetsk, killed at least 12 people on the morning of Thursday 8 October, authorities said in the first reports carried by Reuters. The Straits TimesRC “A Russian bomb attack on the embattled eastern Ukrainian city of Kramatorsk killed at least 12 people, authorities said on Thursday” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Centre · 1Later reporting by France 24 said the toll had risen to 30 dead and 18 wounded, citing the Donetsk regional prosecutor's office; the governor's office gave the same figures and said public transport had been suspended. France 24N “"As of now, the death toll from this morning's attack on buses has risen to 30. Eighteen people were wounded," the Donetsk regional prosecutor's office said.”“The governor's office gave the same toll and said public transport had been suspended.” Read at France 24 ↗ Right · 1The Reuters report said 14 people were wounded and that police described a street where two city buses were operating, while President Volodymyr Zelenskiy called the site a bus stop. The Straits TimesRC “Another 14 people were wounded in the morning attack on a street where two city buses were operating, police said. President Volodymyr Zelenskiy described it as a bus stop.” Read at The Straits Times ↗
Centre · 1Ukraine's national police said the buses were hit with a glide bomb, and the strike happened at about 10:00 local time (0700 GMT). France 24N “Ukraine's national police said Russia had hit the buses with a glide bomb.”“Thursday's strike, which happened at 10:00am (0700 GMT)” Read at France 24 ↗ Right · 1Police images showed bodies strewn across a street littered with debris and the charred shell of what appeared to be a bus. The Straits TimesRC “Images posted by police showed bodies strewn across a street littered with debris, as well as a charred shell of what appeared to be a bus.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Mixed · 2Regional governor Vadym Filashkin said the dead were "people killed by the Russian army", and Kramatorsk City Council called the attack "yet another horrific crime" and said there were "absolutely no military targets" at the location. The Straits TimesRC “"These are not 'the consequences of war', nor dry statistics. These are people killed by the Russian army," regional governor Vadym Filashkin said on the Telegram app.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ France 24N “Kramatorsk City Council said it was "yet another horrific crime committed by the Russian army against the civilian population".” Read at France 24 ↗
Mixed · 2Kramatorsk is part of Ukraine's so-called "fortress belt" of defences in Donetsk and has long been a logistics and supply hub for the Ukrainian military; local officials say Russian forces have stepped up drone and guided-bomb strikes on it, and Russian troops have edged close to its eastern edge, prompting calls for remaining civilians to relocate. The Straits TimesRC “Moscow's forces have stepped up drone and guided-bomb strikes on Kramatorsk and other cities in Ukraine's so-called "fortress belt"” Read at The Straits Times ↗ France 24N “Russian forces have edged close to the city's eastern edge, which has prompted calls for civilians who remain to relocate to safer regions of Ukraine.” Read at France 24 ↗ Mixed · 2The strike followed a large Russian air attack on Wednesday that Reuters said killed dozens and mainly targeted the power grid; France 24 reported that a Russian missile hit an apartment block in Chernigiv, killing 22 including five children, and that three more people died in a strike on Kyiv, according to its mayor. The Straits TimesRC “Thursday's attack came a day after dozens were killed in a massive Russian air attack across Ukraine, primarily targeting the country's power grid.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ France 24N “came a day after a Russian missile hit an apartment block in the northern region of Chernigiv, killing 22, including five children.”“Another three people were killed in a Russian strike on Kyiv, according to the city's mayor.” Read at France 24 ↗ Right · 1Russia has demanded that Ukraine cede the rest of Donetsk still under Kyiv's control before it stops fighting, which Kyiv refuses to do. The Straits TimesRC “Russia has demanded that Ukraine cede the rest of the region still under its control before it stops fighting, which Kyiv refuses to do.” Read at The Straits Times ↗
Centre · 1Separately on Thursday, a drone started a fire at a Yandex data centre in Sasovo, in Russia's Ryazan region; the company said there were no casualties but the facility stopped operating entirely. Andriy Kovalenko, former head of Ukraine's Centre for Countering Disinformation, said Ukrainian forces carried out the strike, while Yandex did not say where the drone came from and the Ryazan governor said two Ukrainian drones had been shot down overnight. France 24N “"A drone attack caused a fire at the Yandex data centre in Sasovo, affecting part of its infrastructure," a Yandex spokesperson told AFP, without specifying the origin of the drone.”“"Two can play at this game. Ukrainian forces struck a Yandex data centre in the Ryazan region," he wrote.”“two Ukrainian drones had been shot down over the region overnight” Read at France 24 ↗ Centre · 1Ukraine's military also said it struck the Gazprom Neftekhim Salavat refinery and petrochemicals complex in Bashkortostan, sparking a fire. France 24N “Ukrainian forces also struck the Gazprom Neftekhim Salavat oil refinery and petrochemicals complex in central Russia's Bashkortostan region, Kyiv's military said.” Read at France 24 ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left8 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre3 outlets
- Framing
- France 24 leads with the higher toll of 30 and places the Kramatorsk strike alongside a Ukrainian drone strike on a Yandex data centre and other cross-border attacks.
- Emphasis
- Updated casualty figures, the wider exchange of long-range strikes, Yandex and refinery attacks.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Russia's demand that Ukraine cede the rest of Donetsk.
- Charged language
- “yet another horrific crime”
- For example
-
“At least 30 people were killed and 18 others wounded on Thursday when Russia struck two passenger buses in Kramatorsk” — France 24
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- The Straits Times, running Reuters copy, focuses on the Kramatorsk attack alone, stressing it as another strike on a stronghold coveted by Moscow and quoting the governor.
- Emphasis
- Early toll of 12, governor's condemnation, Russian demands over Donetsk.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Carries the earlier toll and does not report the later rise to 30, the glide bomb detail or the Yandex strike.
- Charged language
- “embattled”“stronghold coveted by Moscow”
- For example
-
“"Russia comes to Ukrainian land with death."” — The Straits Times
What every side reports
- A Russian strike hit buses or a bus stop in Kramatorsk on the morning of 8 October.
- Kramatorsk is a key Ukrainian-held city in Donetsk's 'fortress belt'.
- Ukrainian officials blamed the Russian army and described the victims as civilians.
- The attack came a day after a large Russian attack elsewhere in Ukraine.
Where accounts differ
-
Death toll in Kramatorsk
- Centre
- France 24 reports at least 30 dead and 18 wounded, citing the Donetsk prosecutor's office and governor's office.
- Right
- The Straits Times (Reuters) reports at least 12 dead and 14 wounded, an earlier figure.
Kramatorsk place
City council and governor condemn the attack as a crime against civilians at a location with no military targets.
“"Once again, the Russians have struck a location where there are absolutely no military targets," it added.” — France 24
Left8 articles
Show 4 moreShow fewer
Centre3 articles
-
Dozens killed in Russian strike on buses in Ukraine's Kramatorsk as Kyiv targets data centre
Neutral Reports the higher toll of 30 and pairs it with Ukraine's strike on a Yandex data centre, presenting both sides' long-range attacks.

-

-

Right3 articles
-
The Straits TimesRC · · via Reuters
Russian bomb kills 12 in street in east Ukraine stronghold
Neutral Reuters wire copy on the early toll of 12, with the governor's quote and the context of Russian demands over Donetsk.
-

-

- 8 Oct 10:39 First The Straits TimesRC Russian bomb kills 12 in street in east Ukraine stronghold via Reuters
- 8 Oct 11:08 +29m France 24N Dozens killed in Russian strike on buses in Ukraine's Kramatorsk as Kyiv targets data centre
- 8 Oct 11:16 +37m The GuardianLC Russian attack on two buses kills 30 near Ukraine frontline
- 8 Oct 11:16 +37m BBC NewsN Russian strike on buses kills 33, say officials, as deadly attacks on Ukraine surge
- 8 Oct 11:26 +48m MeduzaLC Russian strike on two passenger buses in Ukraine’s Kramatorsk kills 33
- 8 Oct 11:30 +51m Irish IndependentRC Russian strike kills 33 on street in eastern Ukrainian city
- 8 Oct 11:30 +51m Deutsche WelleN Ukraine says 30 killed, 18 wounded in Russian attack on passenger buses in Kramatorsk
- 8 Oct 11:30 +51m Irish IndependentRC Russian strike on buses kills 33 in eastern Ukraine
- 8 Oct 11:31 +52m Al JazeeraLC Russian attack on Ukraine’s Kramatorsk kills at least 12 people
- 8 Oct 11:40 +1h 1m ABC News (Australia)LC Breaking: Russian strike on Ukrainian bus stop kills 33
- 8 Oct 11:43 +1h 4m The HinduLC Death toll from Russian bus strike in eastern Ukraine jumps to 30: authorities
- 8 Oct 11:53 +1h 15m NBC NewsLC At least 30 people feared killed in Russian bus bombing in Ukraine
- 8 Oct 11:55 +1h 16m ABC NewsLC At least 35 killed in Russian attacks on Ukraine, officials say
- 8 Oct 12:25 +1h 46m NPRLC Strike on Ukrainian public bus leaves 30 dead as blackouts worsen in Kyiv
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.



