San Diego council votes to halt Flock license plate readers and smart streetlights
San Diego's City Council voted on Monday to stop using about 500 Flock license plate cameras and the Ubicquia smart streetlight program, after criticism over surveillance and police use of the data. Outlets differ on whether the contracts have ended or are still active.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2On Monday evening, 16 November 2026, San Diego's City Council voted to stop using Flock Safety's license plate reader cameras and the Ubicquia smart streetlights they were paired with. Ars TechnicaLC “On Monday evening, San Diego’s city council voted to end its contracts with two surveillance equipment vendors, Flock and Ubicquia.” Read at Ars Technica ↗ New York PostR “On Monday, the City Council voted 7–0 to suspend the use of the Flock Safety cameras.” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1According to the New York Post, the council voted 7–0 to suspend the Flock cameras and then 5–2 to halt the Smart Streetlights program, opening the door to scrapping a contract of nearly $12 million that covers both systems. New York PostR “But in a surprising development, the council then voted 5–2 to halt the city’s Smart Streetlights program, opening the door to scrapping a nearly $12 million contract covering both surveillance systems.” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1Ars Technica describes the vote as ending the contracts, while the New York Post says the contract with Flock and Ubicquia remains active for now. The Post adds that a police official told council members that withdrawing approval for both systems would give the city grounds to end the deal, and that officials could also try to renegotiate it. A $2 million payment for the coming year's services is due in December. New York PostR “The city’s contract with Flock and Smart Streetlights vendor Ubicquia currently remains active.”“A $2 million payment for the coming year’s services is due in December.” Read at New York Post ↗
Right · 1The New York Post reports that police officer access to the system was restricted as of noon on Tuesday and all cameras were off by 10 p.m. that night. It says police expect a plan by the end of the week to start dismantling the roughly 500 cameras citywide. New York PostR “All officer access to the system was restricted as of noon yesterday and by 10 p.m. last night, all of the cameras were turned off.”“officials are expected to have a plan by the end of the week to start dismantling the hundreds of cameras citywide.” Read at New York Post ↗ Left · 1Ars Technica says San Diego is one of the largest cities to end its relationship with Flock, a startup with an estimated valuation of $8.3 billion. Secure Justice, an Oakland-based advocacy group, says it has documented at least 513 Flock contracts that have ended nationwide. Ars TechnicaLC “San Diego is one of the largest cities to end its relationship with Flock, the startup with an estimated valuation of $8.3 billion.”““We’ve documented at least 513 Flock contracts that have ended in red and blue states, in large and small cities,”” Read at Ars Technica ↗ Right · 1The vote followed three hours of public comment. Residents asked who could access the data, including whether federal immigration authorities could. Speakers cited a case in which an erroneous plate-reader hit led to a man spending months in jail for a crime he did not commit, and another in which a stolen-car alert preceded a police officer shooting a 19-year-old passenger; the car's owner said it had not been stolen. New York PostR “an erroneous plate-reader hit led to a man spending months in jail for a crime he didn’t commit.”“The votes to end the use of the Flock cameras followed three hours of public comment on Monday” Read at New York Post ↗
Right · 1The New York Post reports that Councilmember Raul Campillo reversed course after learning police had used license plate data in an internal affairs investigation of an officer who had a relationship with a domestic violence victim. Voice of San Diego reported that police used the technology to track the victim, while the department said its policy allowed investigators to use the readers in that probe; the officer has since left the department. New York PostR “Councilmember Raul Campillo reversed course after learning that police used license plate data in an internal affairs investigation involving an officer who had a relationship with a domestic violence victim.”“The department said its policy allowed investigators to use the readers in the officer probe, according to CBS8.” Read at New York Post ↗ Left · 1Ars Technica separately reports that Councilmember Stephen Whitburn revoked his support in October, which opened a path to a majority against the program. Lily Irani of the TRUST SD Coalition credited a national coalition across the political spectrum for the result. Ars TechnicaLC “it was only last month that one of the councilmembers revoked his support, creating an opening for a political majority to halt the surveillance.”““The national energy creating left and right and center coalitions was the major cause [of the political victory],” she said” Read at Ars Technica ↗ Mixed · 2Mayor Todd Gloria, a longtime backer of the program, said he would not veto the council's decision. The Post quotes his statement that "Flock Safety and the City's use of this technology have clearly lost public trust, and that cannot be ignored." Ars TechnicaLC “San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria said in a social media post that he “respect[ed] the Council’s decision” and would not veto the move” Read at Ars Technica ↗ New York PostR ““Flock Safety and the City’s use of this technology have clearly lost public trust, and that cannot be ignored,”” Read at New York Post ↗
Right · 1Police Chief Scott Wahl said the department respected the decision and would work with the vendor to turn the system off. New York PostR “the department respected the decision of the council and would work with the vendor to turn the system off.” Read at New York Post ↗ Mixed · 2Police and supporters defended the cameras. Ars Technica reports that police told the council vehicle theft had fallen 20 percent since 2023 and that 689 stolen vehicles were recovered thanks to the cameras. The Post says Councilmember Marni von Wilpert, who had called for a pause and clearer rules, said the readers helped police in more than 900 cases, including kidnappings, killings, stolen vehicles and gun recoveries. Ars TechnicaLC “police representatives said there has been a 20 percent decline in vehicle theft since 2023, with 689 stolen vehicles recovered as a result of the Flock cameras.” Read at Ars Technica ↗ New York PostR “the readers had helped police in more than 900 cases, including kidnappings, killings, stolen vehicles and gun recoveries.” Read at New York Post ↗ Mixed · 2Flock spokesperson Andrew Smith said the company respects the city's decision but warned that "public safety moves backward," with cases taking longer to solve and victims waiting longer for justice. Ars TechnicaLC ““When a tool that is actively helping solve violent crimes is removed, public safety moves backward,”” Read at Ars Technica ↗ New York PostR “will work with them on next steps” Read at New York Post ↗
Left · 1Ars Technica notes the reversal comes three years after the mayor and other leaders urged approval of the program. It says San Diego previously bought thousands of smart streetlights from GE Current, which a prior administration shut down in 2020. Ubicquia later acquired that platform and proposed the 500-camera installation with Flock in 2023, over the objection of the city's Privacy Advisory Board. Board member Pegah Parsi now says she feels "vindication." Ars TechnicaLC “The vote is a remarkable turnabout from just three years ago, when the mayor and other municipal leaders urged the city council to approve the program.”“the City of San Diego Privacy Advisory Board, asked the city council to vote down the plan.” Read at Ars Technica ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Ars Technica treats the vote as a win for privacy advocates and a reversal of a 2023 decision, putting critics' voices and the history of failed smart streetlight programs at the centre.
- Emphasis
- Advocates' reaction, the Privacy Advisory Board's earlier warning, the national trend of cancelled Flock contracts, and Flock's valuation.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the 7–0 and 5–2 vote counts, the nearly $12 million contract, the internal affairs case, or that the contract remains active.
- Charged language
- “dumps”“go dark”“vindication”
- For example
-
“500+ cameras will go dark just 3 years after mayor urged approval.” — Ars Technica
“It’s pretty clear that Americans do not consent to their government tracking them as we go about our daily lives.” — Ars Technica
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- The New York Post leads with the cameras being removed after backlash and police misuse, presenting them as tools used to spy on the public.
- Emphasis
- Police misconduct in an internal affairs case, wrongful-arrest and shooting cases, vote counts, the contract's cost and the timeline for dismantling.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the Privacy Advisory Board's 2023 objection or the national count of ended Flock contracts, and gives less on the 20 percent vehicle-theft decline cited by police.
- Charged language
- “ripping out”“controversial cameras used to spy on the public”“massive backlash”
- For example
-
“San Diego is pulling the plug on about 500 license plate readers after massive backlash over how police were using them in the city.” — New York Post
“But it was the way San Diego police used the cameras in their own backyard that cost the program one of its former supporters.” — New York Post
What every side reports
- The San Diego City Council voted on Monday to halt use of the Flock license plate cameras and the associated smart streetlights.
- About 500 cameras are involved.
- Mayor Todd Gloria, a past supporter, said he would not stand in the way of the council's decision.
- Flock said it respects the decision but argued public safety will suffer.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether the contracts have been ended
- Left
- Ars Technica says the council voted to end its contracts with Flock and Ubicquia.
- Right
- The New York Post says the council voted to suspend or halt the systems and that the roughly $12 million contract remains active, with ending it still to be decided.
-
Which councilmember's change of position opened the way to the majority
- Left
- Ars Technica names Stephen Whitburn, who revoked support in October.
- Right
- The New York Post names Raul Campillo, who reversed course after the internal affairs case.
Flock Safety organisation
Flock says it respects San Diego's decision but argues that removing a tool helping solve violent crimes sets public safety back.
““When a tool that is actively helping solve violent crimes is removed, public safety moves backward,”” — Ars Technica
““The San Diego Police Department has solved countless crimes and made a measurable public safety impact with Flock technology,”” — New York Post
San Diego place
The council voted to halt the systems, Mayor Gloria said he would not veto, and police said they would comply and turn the system off.
“would not veto the move to stop operation of the cameras across the city.” — Ars Technica
“would work with the vendor to turn the system off.” — New York Post
Left1 article
-
San Diego dumps both Flock cameras and smart streetlights
Sympathetic Presents the vote as a victory for privacy critics and a striking reversal, with Flock's response included.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
San Diego starts ripping out hundreds of controversial cameras used to spy on the public
Critical Frames the cameras as a surveillance tool that police misused, citing wrongful-arrest and shooting cases and a domestic violence-related probe.

- 17 Nov 23:09 First Ars TechnicaLC San Diego dumps both Flock cameras and smart streetlights
- 18 Nov 21:10 +22h 2m New York PostR San Diego starts ripping out hundreds of controversial cameras used to spy on the public
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…