Santa Barbara students and parents protest district's response to blackface TikTok
Students walked out and parents spoke at a Santa Barbara Unified board meeting on 13 October, criticising the district's handling of a TikTok in which four San Marcos High School students wore blackface. The superintendent called it racist, and board members said they would discuss it at a further meeting.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Four San Marcos High School students posted a TikTok last month in which they darkened their skin to mimic an AI-generated image of four Black children. NewsweekN “Last month four San Marcos students received backlash over a post on TikTok where they recreated an AI-generated meme by darkening their skin to mimic Black children.” Read at Newsweek ↗ New York PostR “the girls’ TikTok video in which the girls are seen mimicking an AI-generated image of four young black boys in various poses” Read at New York Post ↗ Mixed · 2Principal Dare Holdren told families the school had "instituted consequences" for the students, who "portrayed blackface". The coverage does not say what the consequences were. NewsweekN “San Marcos High School has "instituted consequences" for the group of students who "portrayed blackface" on social media.” Read at Newsweek ↗ New York PostR “San Marcos High School Principal Dare Holdren previously said the students “portrayed blackface” in the post” Read at New York Post ↗ Mixed · 2On Tuesday, 13 October, students from San Marcos and Dos Pueblos high schools walked out of class. That evening, students, parents and community members spoke at the Santa Barbara Unified School District board meeting. NewsweekN “On Tuesday, October 13, students from San Marcos and Dos Pueblos high schools walked out of class, while students, parents and community members spoke at the Santa Barbara Unified School District board meeting that evening.” Read at Newsweek ↗ New York PostR “Students from two Goleta Valley high schools, San Marcos and Dos Pueblos high schools stormed out ahead of a district board meeting.” Read at New York Post ↗
Right · 1Parents held signs at the meeting, including "Don't be a bystander, stop ignoring racism". Some questioned why it took about two weeks to notify them. Leticia Forney Resch of Healing Justice Santa Barbara said images had been circulating among students for a week and a half. New York PostR “Parents wondered why it took Holdren two weeks to notify them of the incident.”““They had pictures and images going out to students for a week-and-a-half… Y’all didn’t do your job.”” Read at New York Post ↗ Centre · 1Superintendent Dr. Hilda Maldonado told the meeting that the incident "was racist and harmful" and that she was "committed to listening". She said the problem reaches beyond one incident. NewsweekN “What happened was racist and harmful, and there is no place for hate, racism or discrimination in our schools,”“I recognize that this reaches beyond one incident and touches deeper experiences of racism and exclusion. I am committed to listening.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Centre · 1Speakers said the blackface post was part of a recurring pattern. A student named Yeko said a student with tardies gets lunch detention while someone who posts blackface does not. Another student, Sedenya, said there is "hardly any acknowledgment or punishment" of racism. NewsweekN “"If someone who has tardies gets lunch detention, but someone who posts blackface doesn't. You are clearly promoting racism."”“There is hardly any acknowledgment or punishment, and we have spoken up about this before.” Read at Newsweek ↗
Mixed · 2Maile Schoonover of the Santa Barbara Fund cited other reported incidents, including allegations that a Black student was physically assaulted, racial slurs and monkey noises in hallways, and the N-word written in a Black educator's classroom. The New York Post, citing the Santa Barbara Independent, reported that a substitute teacher read the N-word aloud during "Of Mice and Men" last year after being told not to, and was removed from campus. NewsweekN “She raised allegations of a Black student being physically assaulted, a substitute teacher using the N-word in class, racial slurs and monkey noises in school hallways, and a Black educator finding the N-word written in a classroom.” Read at Newsweek ↗ New York PostR “The substitute was then removed from campus.” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1The New York Post reported that the local NAACP had previously criticised the district for failing to establish protocols to respond to racist incidents. NAACP Santa Barbara President Connie Alexander wrote that principals need "clear guidance". New York PostR “The local NAACP previously criticized the school for failing to establish protocols to respond to incidents of racism.” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1The photo was taken in an African American studies classroom. Ethnic studies teacher Abel Gonzalez said, "When black students are harmed, every student is harmed." New York PostR “The girls posed for the picture in an African American studies classroom.”““When black students are harmed, every student is harmed,”” Read at New York Post ↗
Centre · 1The board gave no official responses that night because of the number of speakers. Members pledged to discuss the issue at a further meeting, and speakers said they wanted a response that addressed the wider pattern as well as the blackface incident. Newsweek said it had contacted the district for comment. NewsweekN “Board members pledged to discuss the issue at a further meeting as speakers said they wanted to see a response that addressed not only the blackface incident but what they described as a recurring pattern of racism in the district.”“Newsweek reached out to the Santa Barbara Unified School District via email for comment.” Read at Newsweek ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Newsweek reports the walkout and board meeting as a community challenge to the district. It includes the superintendent's response and national context on racism in schools.
- Emphasis
- Student and community speakers, the superintendent's statement that the incident was racist, and CDC and GAO figures.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The NAACP criticism and the notification-delay complaint are absent. The girls' discipline is not detailed.
- Charged language
- “Promoting Racism”
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- The New York Post leads with parental outrage and the girls' appearance, and describes the district as showing "willful ignorance". It presents the incident as part of a pattern of earlier racist incidents.
- Emphasis
- Parent anger, the delayed notification, the ninja emoji's alleged reference to the N-word, the NAACP criticism and the earlier substitute-teacher incident.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The superintendent's statement and the board's pledge to hold a further discussion are not reported. The second article reuses much of the first article's text.
- Charged language
- “go ballistic”“blonde girls”“spirals out of control”“stormed out”“willful ignorance”
- For example
-
“Santa Barbara parents are aghast at the appearance of willful ignorance from a local school district” — New York Post
“California high school students walked out of class Tuesday to demand accountability from the Santa Barbara Unified School District” — New York Post
What every side reports
- Four San Marcos High School students posted a TikTok in blackface mimicking an AI-generated image of Black children.
- Principal Dare Holdren said the school "instituted consequences".
- Students from San Marcos and Dos Pueblos high schools walked out on Tuesday, 13 October, and speakers criticised the district at that evening's board meeting.
- Speakers described the incident as part of a wider pattern of racism in the district.
Where accounts differ
-
How the incident is characterised
- Centre
- Newsweek describes "ongoing controversy" and gives the superintendent's response and wider national statistics.
- Right
- The New York Post calls it a "scandal" that "spirals out of control", says parents "go ballistic", and stresses that the girls are "blonde".
-
Timing of notification
- Centre
- Newsweek says students and staff voiced frustration "over a week after the incident" and does not report the notification delay.
- Right
- The New York Post says parents wondered why it took two weeks to notify them.
Santa Barbara Unified School District organisation
Superintendent Hilda Maldonado called the incident racist and harmful and said she is committed to listening. The board said it would discuss the issue further and gave no official responses on the night.
“I recognize that this reaches beyond one incident and touches deeper experiences of racism and exclusion. I am committed to listening.” — Newsweek
“it was explained that there would be no official responses on the night due to the volume of speakers” — Newsweek
San Marcos High School organisation
Principal Dare Holdren said the school "instituted consequences" for the students who "portrayed blackface". Parents questioned why notifying them took two weeks.
“San Marcos High School Principal Dare Holdren previously said the students “portrayed blackface” in the post” — New York Post
“Parents wondered why it took Holdren two weeks to notify them of the incident.” — New York Post
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre1 article
-
California Students Walk Out, Accusing School Board Of ‘Promoting Racism’
Neutral Reports the walkout and board meeting with quotes from the superintendent, students and community members, and adds national statistics.

Right2 articles
-
Alarmist Leads with parental fury and the girls' hair colour, and presents the district as willfully ignorant of a pattern of racism.

-
Alarmist Recasts the first article around the student walkout and calls it a "scandal" spiralling out of control, repeating much of the earlier text.

- 14 Oct 15:31 First New York PostR Parents go ballistic at California school after four blonde girls shared blackface picture — as other shocking incidents emerge
- 15 Oct 17:23 +25h 53m New York PostR California high school blackface scandal spirals out of control as kids storm out of class over four blonde girls’ photo
- 16 Oct 10:53 +43h 22m NewsweekN California Students Walk Out, Accusing School Board Of ‘Promoting Racism’
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…