Skip to content
Bramble

World

Saudi, Pakistani and Turkish officials go to Tehran for Makkah pact talks with Iran

Saudi Defence Minister Prince Khalid bin Salman, Pakistan's army chief and Turkey's intelligence chief are meeting Iranian officials in Tehran on 26 October. It is the first high-level contact between Iran and the three-nation Makkah pact since Houthi attacks on Saudi Arabia escalated.

12 outlets · 3L · 5C · 4R First reported Account updated
Image: Arab News
Image: The Times of India
Image: The Independent
Image: IJR
Image: The National
Image: Al Jazeera
Image: The Straits Times
Image: Geo News

1 / 8

The story, neutrally told

Mixed · 2Saudi Defence Minister Prince Khalid bin Salman is leading a delegation to Tehran on Monday 26 October for talks between countries party to the Makkah Agreement and Iran, according to a Saudi official. Mixed · 2Pakistan is represented by army chief Field Marshal Asim Munir and Turkey by intelligence chief Ibrahim Kalin. Iran's Supreme National Security Council deputy secretary Ali Bagheri Kani said they would meet council secretary Mohsen Rezaei, who leads the Iranian delegation. Mixed · 2Saudi deputy minister for public diplomacy Rayed Krimly confirmed the visit on X. He said it was part of efforts at de-escalation and at promoting dialogue and diplomatic solutions, in support of mediation by Qatar and Pakistan. Anadolu reported that Krimly also said the delegation would meet Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian.

Centre · 2Bagheri Kani told Iranian state television the meeting could be an important and effective step towards lasting regional security. Anadolu reported he also said Iran opposed intervention and influence by external powers in the region. Right · 1Reuters, citing two sources, reported the talks would be the first high-level contact between Iran and all three bloc members since Saudi Arabia came under escalating attacks from Yemen's Iran-aligned Houthis. Saudi Arabia intercepted another wave of missiles and drones on Sunday. Centre · 1The Times of India, citing Reuters, said the Houthis claimed on Monday to have attacked East-West crude pumping stations and Riyadh airport, which Saudi Arabia had not confirmed. It also reported that the Saudi-led coalition said it destroyed missile launchers and tunnels in Yemen.

Mixed · 2The Makkah (also spelled Mecca) Joint Defence Agreement was signed by Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Pakistan in August and treats an armed attack on one member as an attack on all. Pakistan approved it last week and ratification in Turkey's parliament is under way. Defence ministers held an emergency meeting in Riyadh this month and agreed to ensure the rapid deployment of forces and capabilities in Saudi Arabia. Mixed · 2The wider backdrop is the war that began in February when the US and Israel struck Iran. A Pakistan-brokered ceasefire in April was followed by an interim deal in June that quickly unravelled, and the US and Iran are contesting the Strait of Hormuz. Munir visited Tehran last week and met Pezeshkian, and Iranian media said Iranian officials told him there would be no talks with the US until Tehran's demands were met. Left · 1The Independent, carrying AP, says the talks aim to avert renewed fighting between Iran and Israel and the US ahead of Israel's election on Tuesday and the US election on 3 November. It cites regional officials saying the Yemen war and the Houthi strikes are also on the agenda, and Netanyahu warning of disproportionate blows.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left3 outlets

Framing
Al Jazeera and the Independent (AP copy) place the visit within the US-Israeli war on Iran and fears of renewed fighting around the elections, and give Iranian officials' views prominent space.
Emphasis
Iranian statements, the unravelled June deal, Houthi pressure on Saudi Arabia, and Israeli and US election-season threats.
Leaves out or plays down
Neither carries the Houthi claims of strikes on Saudi infrastructure or the Saudi-led coalition's strikes in Yemen.
Charged language
“complete surrender”“pressure point”
For example
“turning US ally Saudi Arabia into a pressure point” — Al Jazeera
“Trump and U.S. officials repeatedly use the phrase “complete surrender,” which Baghaei said no Iranian accepts.” — The Independent

Centre5 outlets

Framing
Mostly short, factual reports of a security-focused visit, relying on Saudi, Iranian and Turkish official statements and on Reuters and AFP.
Emphasis
Delegation membership, Krimly's de-escalation message, Bagheri Kani's remarks, and the Houthi and coalition exchanges in Yemen (Times of India).
Leaves out or plays down
The National and Anadolu give little of the war context, and the Times of India gives little of the Iranian war context.
Charged language
“third imposed war”
For example
“aimed at de-escalation and finding diplomatic solutions to the current crises in the region” — The National
“successful experience in building national security during the third imposed war (US-Iran conflict)” — The Times of India

Right4 outlets

Framing
Reuters copy (IJR, Jerusalem Post, Straits Times) leads with anonymous sources and the Houthi escalation against Saudi Arabia, while Arab News relays the Saudi line of easing tensions.
Emphasis
The defence-pact's mutual-defence clause, the Riyadh emergency meeting and the Houthi missile and drone waves.
Leaves out or plays down
The Reuters-based pieces carry no Iranian or Saudi on-record statements, and the Arab News item is only a single sentence.
Charged language
“pressure point”“unabated”
For example
“turning US ally Saudi Arabia into a pressure point in the wider war” — The Jerusalem Post
“as part of efforts to ease regional tensions, a Saudi Foreign Ministry official told Al Arabiya” — Arab News

Ask about this story

Loading…