Super El Niño heat could cause about 857,000 extra deaths by March, tracker estimates
The University of Chicago's Climate Impact Lab launched an El Niño Heat Mortality Tracker estimating 484,500 heat deaths since June and about 372,900 more over six months. UK outlets differ on the headline total and on which countries rank among the top three.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2The Climate Impact Lab at the University of Chicago has published an El Niño Heat Mortality Tracker that maps where heat linked to the current Super El Niño is expected to kill the most people. Daily MailR “The tool, called the El Niño Heat Mortality Tracker, reveals that an extra 370,000 lives could be at risk over the next six months.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ The IndependentLC “The El Niño Heat Mortality Tracker, produced by the University of Chicago’s Climate Impact Lab, forecasts the human impact of the weather phenomenon.” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2Both outlets report that the tracker estimates 484,500 heat-related deaths already attributable to El Niño since June, plus roughly 370,000 more over the following six months. Daily MailR “It estimates that as many as 484,500 deaths have already occurred as the result of the weather phenomenon” Read at Daily Mail ↗ The IndependentLC “with around 372,900 more forecast for the next six months” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2The Daily Mail puts the combined total at 857,400 additional heat deaths between June 2026 and March 2027, while The Independent's headline rounds this to 870,000 and its text says nearly 900,000 over 10 months. The two figures in the Independent's text sum to about 857,000. Daily MailR “Scientists now estimate that El Niño will contribute to 857,400 additional heat-related deaths between June 2026 and March 2027.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ The IndependentLC “Super El Niño could lead to nearly 900,000 extra deaths worldwide over just 10 months” Read at The Independent ↗
Mixed · 2Nigeria is forecast to have the highest toll, about 56,000 deaths over the six-month forecast period. The Independent adds a further 55,000 in India and about 29,000 in Indonesia. Daily MailR “Nigeria is forecasted to experience the highest toll from El Niño's heat, with about 56,000 deaths projected spread across the six-month forecast period” Read at Daily Mail ↗ The IndependentLC “It forecasts a further 55,000 heat-related deaths in India, while Southeast Asia is also under threat with around 29,000 deaths predicted in Indonesia.” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2The Daily Mail names Nigeria, India and Brazil as accounting for more than a third of projected deaths by March, whereas The Independent names China, Nigeria and India for that share. Daily MailR “Nigeria, India and Brazil are forecast to bear the brunt of the crisis, accounting for more than a third of projected heat deaths by March.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ The IndependentLC “China, Nigeria and India alone are predicted to account for more than one third of deaths related to El Niño, according to the figures.” Read at The Independent ↗ Right · 1Of deaths since June, the Daily Mail reports more than 100,000 in India, 85,400 in China, 38,500 in Sudan and more than 20,000 in Indonesia. It also reports an estimated 820 UK deaths this summer, and extra deaths in Italy (7,200), France (4,800), Germany (2,500) and Spain (2,300). Daily MailR “The model also shows an extra 85,400 deaths have occurred in China since June, 38,500 in Sudan and more than 20,000 in Indonesia.”“the tool suggests there were an extra 7,200 heat-related deaths in Italy, 4,800 in France, 2,500 in Germany and 2,300 in Spain.”“an estimated 820 deaths already attributable to El Niño's heat this summer” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Mixed · 2The total is more than 350,000 higher than the researchers' estimate in September. They attribute the rise to August and September being much hotter than forecast; The Independent adds that August was the warmest on record and September the second warmest. Daily MailR “The grim toll is more than 350,000 higher than the researchers' initial estimate published only weeks ago.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ The IndependentLC ““August was the warmest August and September the second warmest September on record”” Read at The Independent ↗ Right · 1Michael Greenstone, a University of Chicago professor and co-founder of the Climate Impact Lab, said the tool lets decision-makers act before lives are lost. The researchers pointed to early warning systems, expanded healthcare access, water and cooling centres as proven responses. Daily MailR “It means we can identify where people face the greatest risks and give decision-makers a chance to act before lives are lost.”“such as early warning systems that inform expansion of healthcare access, and the provision of water and cooling centres” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Left · 1The Independent notes experts say the record summer heat resulted from climate change rather than El Niño itself, whose strongest effects typically arrive from late autumn into winter. It also cites a Science study finding El Niños are more than 36 per cent stronger than before the industrial age, and a Lancet Countdown report of a record 710,000 heat deaths in 2023. The IndependentLC “experts says this was as a result of climate change and global warming, rather than El Niño which typically produces its strongest impacts from late autumn into winter.”“El Niños are more than 36 per cent stronger than they were before the industrial age began in the mid 1800s”“extreme heat contributed to a record 710,000 fatalities in 2023” Read at The Independent ↗
Right · 1The Daily Mail adds that the World Meteorological Organisation warned last week El Niño is becoming 'unprecedented in strength', and that experts say El Niño could bring a stormy UK winter. Daily MailR “Last week, the World Meteorological Organisation (WMO) warned El Niño – which is characterised by unusually warm waters in the equatorial Pacific – is becoming 'unprecedented in strength'.”“Yesterday experts warned Britain could be in for a winter of chaos supercharged by El Niño.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- The Independent leads on the combined global toll as an 'alarming new prediction', with climate-change context.
- Emphasis
- Total deaths, country breakdown, the link between human-caused warming and stronger El Niños, and the Lancet heat-death report.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Gives no European or UK country figures or per-country deaths since June beyond the top forecasts.
- Charged language
- “alarming new prediction”
- For example
-
“Super El Niño could lead to nearly 900,000 extra deaths worldwide over just 10 months, climate scientists have warned in an alarming new prediction.” — The Independent
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- The Daily Mail leads on an 'ominous map' and the forecast 370,000 at-risk lives, with a UK and European angle.
- Emphasis
- Country-by-country figures including UK and European deaths, plus a stormy UK winter.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not say experts attribute record summer heat to climate change rather than El Niño; the 857,400 total appears only in the body, not the headline.
- Charged language
- “Ominous map”“grim toll”“winter of chaos”
- For example
-
“An ominous map shows where Super El Niño's deadly heat could kill the most people, as the phenomenon continues to ramp up in the Pacific Ocean.” — Daily Mail
“The grim toll is more than 350,000 higher than the researchers' initial estimate published only weeks ago.” — Daily Mail
What every side reports
- The tracker was produced by the University of Chicago's Climate Impact Lab and quotes co-founder Michael Greenstone.
- It estimates 484,500 heat deaths since June attributable to El Niño.
- It forecasts roughly 370,000 more deaths over the next six months, with Nigeria highest at about 56,000.
- The higher total than September's estimate reflects a hotter-than-forecast August and September.
Where accounts differ
-
Which countries make up the top three accounting for over a third of projected deaths
- Left
- The Independent: China, Nigeria and India.
- Right
- The Daily Mail: Nigeria, India and Brazil.
-
Headline death figure
- Left
- The Independent headlines 870,000 and says nearly 900,000 over 10 months.
- Right
- The Daily Mail headlines 370,000 at risk, with a text total of 857,400.
El Niño topic
The tracker's authors say El Niño is a deadly heat risk that can be anticipated, so governments and aid agencies can target early warning, healthcare access and cooling.
“The tracker provides this information for the Super El Niño we're living through today.” — Daily Mail
““The Tracker provides this information for the Super El Niño we’re living through today.”” — The Independent
Left1 article
-
Super El Niño could kill 870,000 people around the world, warn climate scientists
Critical Presents the forecast as an alarming global warning and places it within climate-change research.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Alarmist Map-led, dramatic account stressing country death tolls, UK and European figures and a looming stormy winter.
- 28 Oct 10:37 First Daily MailR Super El Niño's biggest victims: Ominous map reveals where deadly heat could kill the most people - as scientists warn 370,000 lives are at risk
- 29 Oct 16:17 +29h 39m The IndependentLC Super El Niño could kill 870,000 people around the world, warn climate scientists
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…