Skip to content
Bramble

Climate

Sea off Thailand's Ko Lan turns green in Noctiluca plankton bloom

A plankton bloom has turned the sea off Thailand's Ko Lan island bright green, keeping some tourists out of the water. Scientists say the larger worry is falling oxygen in the Gulf of Thailand, and that this year's monsoon and El Niño may be intensifying it.

2 outlets · 2L · 0C · 0R First reported Account updated
Image: The Independent
Image: Al Jazeera

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Heavy rains and floods helped spark a plankton bloom off Ko Lan, a popular tourist island in the northern Gulf of Thailand, turning the sea a bright, pungent green this week. Thick patches extended along sections of the coast, with jet skis floating in discoloured water, while other stretches of shoreline were unaffected. Arvut Munhapon, a senior researcher at the Institute of Marine Science, Burapha University, said the colour comes from a plankton called Noctiluca. His team of four was collecting water samples and measuring water quality to build a database of species.

Researchers said plankton blooms are a natural, recurring phenomenon but have worsened worldwide as climate change has warmed seas, and that fertiliser runoff and nutrient-rich wastewater feed rapid plankton growth. Blooms typically last two to three days. Anukul Buranapratheprat, the institute's deputy director, said the mass die-off afterwards consumes oxygen and can create hypoxic conditions, an "aquatic dead zone" too low in oxygen to support marine life. Anukul said, based on his own research, that hypoxia in the inner Gulf of Thailand has become more severe, and his biggest concern was a wide hypoxic zone formed this year that is too low in oxygen for bottom-dwelling marine life.

This year's monsoons and El Niño may be intensifying both the bloom and the hypoxia, since warmer water holds less dissolved oxygen, but Anukul said more research was needed to confirm the connection. Significant flooding has hit Thailand in recent weeks, including in central provinces and Bangkok, adding to the freshwater reaching the Gulf. Food vendors said customer numbers had thinned since the green water appeared, and some visitors moved to unaffected areas. Latipeya Thantibhapat, a 29-year-old tourist from Chiang Mai, told Reuters she did not go in because she feared a rash.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.

Left2 outlets

Framing
Both outlets present a visual, tourist-facing story that moves to the less visible concern of oxygen depletion. The Independent gives the fuller account, including the monsoon and El Niño link; Al Jazeera runs a short video item.
Emphasis
Tourism impact, the Noctiluca bloom, and hypoxia as the bigger concern.
Leaves out or plays down
Al Jazeera's brief item leaves out the monsoon and El Niño link, the nutrient runoff and the researchers' caveat that more research is needed. The Independent's account, which cites Reuters, does not name any official response.
Charged language
“bright smelly green”“aquatic dead zone”
For example
“Sea around popular tourist island turned a bright smelly green” — The Independent
“But scientists say the bigger concern may be what’s happening beneath the surface, where oxygen levels are falling.” — Al Jazeera

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right0 outlets

No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.