Skip to content
Bramble

World

Teen missing six days on Victoria camping trip found alive

A 17-year-old named William, missing since Friday 6 November while camping at Walhalla East in Gippsland, was found alive on 12 November after a large police search. His mother said he had only scratches, but the ABC later reported dehydration and a night in intensive care.

16 outlets · 7L · 8C · 1R First reported Account updated

Updated (version 4). New coverage since the last version from Anadolu Agency, Breitbart.

Image: ABC News (Australia)
Image: BBC News
Image: Breitbart
Image: South China Morning Post
Image: Deutsche Welle
Image: Gulf News
Image: The Times of India
Image: France 24

1 / 8

The story, neutrally told

Left · 1A 17-year-old from the Latrobe Valley, named as William, went missing on Friday 6 November while camping at Walhalla East in Victoria's east, about 180 km east of Melbourne. Left · 1He was last seen at about 4pm near Stoney Creek Road and T2 Track, after walking a short distance to collect more camping gear. He failed to return. Police believed he became disoriented and walked in the wrong direction. Left · 1He was wearing only shorts and work boots, having taken his shirt off in warm weather. He left his phone, food and water at the camp. A cold snap brought snow to nearby ranges, and temperatures at Mount Baw Baw fell below zero on Saturday and Sunday.

Left · 1Police ran a large search with a command post at Cowwarr and a staging area at Cowwarr Recreational Reserve. Resources included helicopters, water police, the dog squad, mounted police, motorbikes and search and rescue officers. About 70 people searched on Sunday and about 80 on Monday. Left · 1Victoria Police Acting Inspector Jason Benbow said police were "throwing absolutely everything" at the search and had no plans to scale it back. He cited William's fitness as grounds for hope. Police also appealed to identify a bearded man and a woman in an older white ute who helped William's friend on Friday night. Left · 1On the fifth day, police widened the search perimeter and brought in police divers to search nearby rivers. Benbow said police were considering whether William had kept walking, taken shelter or been injured.

Mixed · 2William was found on the morning of Thursday 12 November and reunited with his family. The BBC reported that rescuers winched him to safety, gave him a doughnut and water, and took him to hospital for a check-up. Mixed · 2Police said an Air Wing helicopter crew on an aerial search near Stoney Creek first spotted a fishing tackle box, then saw William lying asleep on a flat rock in a dry creek bed. Acting Inspector Benbow said he woke to the sound of the helicopter and gave a thumbs up before being winched up, and that William was taken back to the command post to meet his mother. Left · 3Benbow said William had trekked for days over very steep terrain and then spent his last two days at the creek, trapped by the steep surroundings about 2 km from his camp site. DW reported that he fell down the side of a riverbed two days before being found; the Daily Mirror quoted his mother as saying he "fell off a bit of a cliff and couldn't move".

Centre · 1The Times of India, citing ABC News, said his mother Elizabeth Barkley explained that he first sheltered beneath bushes after losing his way, then fell down a steep riverbed embankment the next day, leaving him with scratches and sore legs. Citing 9 News, it said he drank creek water and rationed a family-sized packet of chicken-flavoured potato chips over about two days, and kept warm with two towels and a pillow. Left · 2AP reported that William's family said he has Level 2 autism, and that spring weather in the region had been mild with little rain. AP-based copy said video showed him shirtless and sunburned, in shorts and boots, with towels as blankets. The Independent said police were yet to establish how he survived six days without food, water or adequate clothing; the Daily Mirror said he survived on crisps and water. Centre · 1His mother said he had "only a few scratches" and was in perfect health. She said he "just stayed in one spot and waited to be rescued", and joked that he was "grounded for life". Benbow said officers were emotional to have found him alive.

Mixed · 2The Times of India, citing ABC News, said William was taken to Latrobe Regional Hospital, where chief executive Don McRae called his condition remarkable and said his fitness had helped him endure. His mother thanked the hundreds of volunteers and emergency workers. AP copy put the search at more than 100 emergency services personnel and volunteers. Left · 1William later told Channel Seven from his hospital bed in Traralgon that the nights were cold, that it rained a couple of times and that he got sunburnt, and said "I didn't think I'd make it six days." He said he sang John Denver's Country Roads, Take Me Home to keep his spirits up, and that his only food was a rationed packet of chicken-flavoured chips. Left · 1The ABC reported that William was moved to intensive care overnight after his blood pressure dropped due to dehydration, and that he was to be transferred to The Alfred in Melbourne for further testing. Hospital chief executive Don McRae said he was in a stable condition. A later ABC report said he was recovering with dehydration, a possibly damaged windpipe and low blood pressure, which qualifies earlier accounts that he had only scratches and sunburn.

Left · 1Search and rescue experts quoted by the ABC said he did well to stay warm and hydrated, ration his food and avoid pushing on through unfamiliar terrain. Simin Ngan of Bush Search and Rescue Victoria said this was "a key factor in his own survival". The ABC also reported that SES crews worked 120 shifts during the search, and that this was his first unsupervised camping trip. Mixed · 2Anadolu Agency, citing the ABC, repeated that police said he walked for days through rugged terrain before falling down a riverbed embankment. Breitbart, citing the Mirror, linked his calm to autism, saying that some autistic people do not panic in dangerous situations. It also noted that the helicopter found him about 1.2 miles from his campsite. Left · 3Reports differ on details. ABC articles describe his companion as "another teenager", "a friend" and, later, his step-brother. The BBC and others say a friend. The mother's surname is given as Barclay by the ABC and Barkley by the BBC, the Daily Mirror and Metro, while AP copy withholds it. The BBC and Metro say he was found on "Friday morning", while the ABC, AP and the publication dates indicate Thursday; the Independent dates the tackle-box sighting to Wednesday. Accounts of the mother's "stayed in one spot" line differ from police, who said he trekked for days before becoming trapped.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left7 outlets

Framing
ABC Australia followed the search daily, then moved to William's own account and expert praise for his survival choices. UK left-leaning outlets (Mirror, Independent, Metro) and CBC ran upbeat rescue pieces led by the mother's 'grounded for life' joke.
Emphasis
Mother's quotes, the helicopter rescue, William singing John Denver, rescue experts' praise, and (ABC only) dehydration and intensive care.
Leaves out or plays down
Metro and the Mirror leave out how police say he trekked before being trapped; most UK outlets omit his later hospital condition.
Charged language
“kept his wits”
For example
“Search and rescue experts are praising a 17-year-old boy who "kept his wits about him"” — ABC News (Australia)
“William told Channel Seven from his hospital bed in Traralgon” — ABC News (Australia)

Centre8 outlets

Framing
BBC, DW, France 24, Anadolu and AP copy carried by SCMP, Hindustan Times and Gulf News gave short outcome reports: found alive after six days, helicopter rescue, mother's joke; AP copy added autism and police detail on the terrain.
Emphasis
Relief and rescue; autism; police account of trekking then being trapped by steep terrain.
Leaves out or plays down
Daily search detail, his hospital condition and the dehydration; the BBC says Friday morning.
For example
“A police helicopter found him sleeping in a dry riverbed.” — Anadolu Agency

Right1 outlet

Framing
Breitbart ran one aggregated rescue piece, using it to discuss autism and wandering, and paired it with a Kentucky case.
Emphasis
Autism angle, viral footage, mother's 'grounded for life' quote.
Leaves out or plays down
Hospital details such as dehydration and intensive care.
For example
“Apparently with certain types of autism those who have it don’t panic because they don’t contemplate the potentially life-threatening situation in which they find themselves.” — Breitbart

Ask about this story

Loading…