ASCL head teachers' union calls for pause to graded Ofsted inspections, raising strike ballot
The Association of School and College Leaders has passed a no-confidence motion in Ofsted's leadership and urged the government to pause graded inspections in England. It follows similar concerns from the NAHT, and Ofsted says its own survey shows it is "on the right track".
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2The Association of School and College Leaders (ASCL), the second head teachers' union to raise the issue, has called for a halt to graded Ofsted inspections in England, saying it is "increasingly concerned about the welfare and morale" of its members. BBC NewsN “A second head teachers' union has called for a halt to graded Ofsted inspections in England, saying it is "increasingly concerned about the welfare and morale" of its members.” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “urged the government to pause inspections to stop teachers leaving the profession” Read at The Guardian ↗ Centre · 1ASCL's executive passed a motion of no confidence in "the ability of Ofsted's leadership to address the damage being done by the new inspection system". BBC NewsN “ASCL said it had passed a motion of no confidence in "the ability of Ofsted's leadership to address the damage being done by the new inspection system"” Read at BBC News ↗ Mixed · 2General secretary Pepe Di'Iasio said the union did not take the step lightly, that negotiation had "hit a brick wall", and that the system is "not fit for purpose" and an "overbearing mess" that urgently needs review. BBC NewsN “"The current system is not fit for purpose. It is an overbearing mess and urgently needs to be reviewed," he said.” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “Our repeated attempts to resolve our concerns through discussion and negotiation have hit a brick wall” Read at The Guardian ↗
Mixed · 2ASCL asked the government to pause inspections and review the system; it said it would survey members on whether to hold an informal (indicative) ballot on industrial action if nothing changes. BBC NewsN “said it would survey members on whether to hold an informal ballot on industrial action if there was no change” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “if change is not forthcoming" the union would seek to hold an indicative ballot on industrial action” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2The move follows the National Association of Head Teachers (NAHT), which last month said some leaders faced "intolerable" pressure and warned of a "risk to life" without change. NAHT's general secretary Paul Whiteman said its executive meets at the end of next week and he expects the debate to include industrial action. BBC NewsN “It warned the system could pose a "risk to life" if changes were not forthcoming.” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “We fully expect that debate to include the option of pursuing industrial action.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2Ofsted introduced report cards grading schools on several areas, replacing one- or two-word judgements, last November. The change followed the death of head teacher Ruth Perry, after an inquest ruled in 2023 that an Ofsted inspection contributed to her death. BBC NewsN “England's schools inspectorate introduced the report card system to replace its previous one or two-word judgements last November” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “In 2023 a coroner found that an Ofsted inspection contributed to Perry's mental health deterioration and her death.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Centre · 1Ofsted's chief inspector Sir Martyn Oliver said an independent interim report it commissioned showed the inspectorate was "on the right track". That report found leaders were "generally positive" about inspections, which were seen as more collaborative, but also that staff mental wellbeing was negatively affected. BBC NewsN “The data published today shows that we are on the right track.”“concluded this week that leaders were "generally positive" about their inspection experience” Read at BBC News ↗ Mixed · 2The outlets give different figures for the wellbeing finding: the BBC says 48% of school leaders responding said staff mental wellbeing was affected "a fair amount" or "a lot", based on nearly 700 responses, while the Guardian says 88% of schools reported a negative effect. BBC NewsN “nearly half (48%) of school leaders who responded to its survey said their staff's mental wellbeing had been negatively affected” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “88% of schools reported that recent inspections had negatively affected staff wellbeing” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2Ofsted said it had worked hard to reduce inspection pressure but knows workload and wellbeing remain a challenge. The Department for Education said ministers are working with Ofsted and school leaders to make accountability fair and proportionate. The Guardian reported that education secretary Lucy Powell wants Ofsted to "go back to the drawing board" and overhaul the framework. The GuardianLC “we know workload and wellbeing remain a challenge”“Lucy Powell, the education secretary, wants Ofsted to “go back to the drawing board”” Read at The Guardian ↗ BBC NewsN “working with Ofsted and school leaders to ensure accountability is fair, proportionate and focused on helping every school get better” Read at BBC News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- The Guardian frames a developing 'crisis' between heads and Ofsted, with unions threatening strike ballots.
- Emphasis
- Strike threat from both unions, the 88% wellbeing figure, and the education secretary's reported demand for an overhaul.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not report Sir Martyn Oliver's 'on the right track' response or the survey's positive findings on collaboration.
- Charged language
- “crisis”“combative moves”“overbearing mess”
- For example
-
“Tensions between England’s headteachers and Ofsted are developing into a crisis after school leadership unions said they had no confidence in the watchdog” — The Guardian
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- BBC reports the ASCL call as a fresh escalation after NAHT, setting it alongside Ofsted's claim that its own survey shows it is on the right track.
- Emphasis
- Balance of union criticism, Ofsted's survey findings (including positive views of collaboration), and background on Ruth Perry.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention that the NAHT will discuss industrial action next week or Lucy Powell's reported wish for an overhaul.
- Charged language
- “overbearing mess”“fresh calls”
- For example
-
“On Friday, Ofsted's chief inspector Sir Martyn Oliver said an independent survey of education providers showed it was "on the right track" with inspections.” — BBC News
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- ASCL passed a no-confidence motion in Ofsted's leadership and called for inspections to be paused and reviewed.
- ASCL described the system as an "overbearing mess" and raised possible industrial action via a ballot.
- Ofsted and the DfE responded that they are working together on wellbeing and fairness of inspections.
- The report card framework followed the death of Ruth Perry.
Where accounts differ
-
Share of respondents reporting negative wellbeing effects in Ofsted's survey
- Left
- Guardian: 88% of schools reported recent inspections had negatively affected staff wellbeing.
- Centre
- BBC: 48% of school leaders said staff mental wellbeing was affected 'a fair amount' or 'a lot'.
-
What the survey shows about Ofsted's approach
- Left
- Guardian cites the survey only as evidence of harm to wellbeing and describes tensions developing into 'a crisis'.
- Centre
- BBC reports Sir Martyn Oliver saying the data shows Ofsted is 'on the right track' and that leaders were 'generally positive'.
Ofsted organisation
Says it has worked to reduce inspection pressure, acknowledges workload and wellbeing remain challenges, and will keep listening; chief inspector Sir Martyn Oliver says its survey data shows it is on the right track.
“The data published today shows that we are on the right track.” — BBC News
“We are working with the Department for Education on this and we will keep listening to feedback from professionals” — The Guardian
Left1 article
-
Headteachers threaten strike ballots after losing confidence in Ofsted
Critical Presents a deepening crisis between heads and Ofsted, stressing strike threats and government pressure for an overhaul.
Centre1 article
-
Ofsted faces fresh calls to halt graded school inspections in England
Neutral Even-handed report of the ASCL call, giving Ofsted's survey and response alongside union concerns.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 9 Oct 15:01 First BBC NewsN Ofsted faces fresh calls to halt graded school inspections in England
- 10 Oct 00:01 +9h The GuardianLC Headteachers threaten strike ballots after losing confidence in Ofsted
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.