Wyden opens inquiry into whether RFK Jr lied to Congress about 2019 Samoa trip
Democratic Sens. Ron Wyden and Angela Alsobrooks have written to Children's Health Defense seeking records as part of an investigation into whether Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr lied to Congress about his 2019 Samoa trip. HHS and Kennedy deny that the trip was about vaccines or that Kennedy lied.
Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from The Independent, Washington Examiner.
1 / 4
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon, who is due to chair the Senate finance committee, has opened an investigation into evidence that Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr "unlawfully lied" to Congress on multiple occasions, according to a letter sent on Wednesday 11 November to Children's Health Defense (CHD). The GuardianLC ““We are beginning an investigation into evidence that Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F Kennedy, Jr unlawfully lied to Congress on multiple occasions,” Wyden said in a letter to the group that was sent on Wednesday” Read at The Guardian ↗ The Times of IndiaN “On Wednesday, Democratic Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon, who is set to take over as chair of a powerful Senate committee, wrote to Children’s Health Defense (CHD)” Read at The Times of India ↗ Mixed · 2The letter was also signed by Angela Alsobrooks, a Democratic senator from Maryland, and cites reporting by the Guardian. The GuardianLC “The letter was also signed by Angela Alsobrooks, a Democratic senator from Maryland.” Read at The Guardian ↗ The Times of IndiaN “The letter was also signed by Angela Alsobrooks, a Democratic senator from Maryland.” Read at The Times of India ↗ Mixed · 2CHD is the anti-vaccine non-profit that Kennedy chaired before joining the Trump administration. The senators asked it for all documents on any travel to Samoa by Kennedy or other CHD employees or associates, and for communications with Samoan government officials. The GuardianLC “The Senate letter requested all documents related to any travel to Samoa by Kennedy or other employees or associates of CHD and any communications with Samoan government officials.” Read at The Guardian ↗ The Times of IndiaN “a non-profit organisation known for its anti-vaccine activism that Kennedy chaired before joining the Trump administration” Read at The Times of India ↗
Left · 1They also requested records on Kennedy's presidential campaign, his Senate confirmation process, his September speech to the CHD convention, and all communications between CHD and federal officials since 20 January 2025. CHD has until 4 December to respond. The GuardianLC “In addition, the senators requested records related to Kennedy’s speech to CHD’s September convention and all communications between CHD and federal government officials since 20 January 2025.”“CHD has a deadline of 4 December.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2In two confirmation hearings in January 2025, Kennedy told senators his Samoa visit had "nothing to do with vaccines". He was confirmed in February 2025 by 52 votes to 48. The GuardianLC “Kennedy told lawmakers who held the key to his confirmation that his visit to Samoa had “nothing to do with vaccines”.” Read at The Guardian ↗ The Times of IndiaN “Kennedy was confirmed as health secretary in February 2025, joining President Donald Trump’s second administration. The health secretary, a nephew of former US President John F Kennedy, secured 52 votes in favour and 48 against.” Read at The Times of India ↗ Mixed · 2Kennedy was not under oath at the confirmation hearings, but knowingly giving materially false testimony to Congress is a crime whether or not a witness is under oath, according to the Independent (AP reporting). The IndependentLC “Kennedy was not under oath during his confirmation hearing. Knowingly giving material false testimony to Congress is a crime carrying a potential prison sentence regardless of whether an individual is under oath, though it is rarely prosecuted.” Read at The Independent ↗ Washington ExaminerR “Kennedy was not under oath during his Senate confirmation hearings.” Read at Washington Examiner ↗
Right · 1At the hearings Kennedy told Wyden "I went there, nothing to do with vaccines", saying he went to introduce a medical informatics system to digitalize records in Samoa, and repeated to Sen. Edward Markey that his purpose "had nothing to do with vaccines", the Washington Examiner reported. Washington ExaminerR ““I went there, nothing to do with vaccines,” Kennedy replied. “I went there to introduce a medical informatics system that would digitalize records in Samoa and make health delivery much more efficient.”” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ Mixed · 2Letters obtained by the Guardian and the Associated Press through an open records lawsuit brought by the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contradicted that testimony, according to the Guardian. In a January 2019 letter to Samoa's prime minister, Kennedy said he wanted to study the MMR vaccine there and used the word "vaccine" or "vaccination" eight times. The prime minister replied a month later, saying Samoa could benefit from CHD's assessment and inviting him to visit. The GuardianLC “letters obtained by the Guardian and the Associated Press through an open records lawsuit brought by the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contradicted that testimony.”“The prime minister responded a month later, saying Samoa could benefit from CHD’s assessment of MMR vaccines and inviting him to come.” Read at The Guardian ↗ The Times of IndiaN “Kennedy had sent a letter to Samoa’s prime minister on official CHD letterhead, in which he mentioned “vaccine” or “vaccination” eight times.” Read at The Times of India ↗ Right · 1The State Department released the January 2019 letter in August in response to a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit filed by Reporters Committee attorneys for the Associated Press and reporter Michelle Smith. In it Kennedy proposed that his team conduct a health informatics assessment of what happened with Samoa's MMR vaccines, and suggested recent deaths associated with the MMR vaccine may have reflected lot-specific effects. Washington ExaminerR “The State Department released the letter in August in response to a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press attorneys filed on behalf of the Associated Press and reporter Michelle Smith.”“I would propose my team conduct detailed health informatics assessment in Samoa of what happened with your MMR vaccines.” Read at Washington Examiner ↗
Mixed · 2The trip, made as CHD chair and chief legal counsel, came just months before a measles outbreak that killed 83 people in Samoa, mostly children under five. Critics, including Samoan officials, say Kennedy's presence emboldened anti-vaccine activists and worsened a vaccination crisis; Kennedy has denied this, saying he never made a public statement about vaccines or discouraged vaccination in Samoa. The GuardianLC “Kennedy has denied the allegations, saying he never gave any public statement about vaccines or discouraged Samoans from getting vaccinated.” Read at The Guardian ↗ The Times of IndiaN “a measles outbreak killed 83 people in the Pacific island nation, most of them children under the age of five” Read at The Times of India ↗ Left · 1HHS previously said the visit was "unrelated to vaccines" and that any claim Kennedy lied under oath or to Congress was "not only false but outright defamatory". According to the Guardian, it has not explained why his testimony differs from his letter to the Samoan prime minister, and it did not immediately comment on the new inquiry; CHD did not respond to requests for comment. The GuardianLC “Any claim or insinuation based on these letters that Secretary Kennedy lied under oath or to Congress is not only false but outright defamatory.””“Children’s Health Defense did not respond to requests for comment, and the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) did not immediately comment.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 1The letter is not a subpoena, but Tim Stretton of the nonpartisan Project on Government Oversight said ignoring it would be unwise; the committee chair could issue subpoenas if CHD does not cooperate. The GuardianLC “The letter does not go as far as the legal force of a subpoena.”“If they don’t, he said, the committee or chair could issue subpoenas to demand the information they are seeking.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Mixed · 2Wyden had earlier called for a criminal investigation, saying in August he would press Republican colleagues for a criminal referral to the Justice Department. Democrats are set to take control of the Senate after the 3 November midterms, and Wyden posted "Subpoenas" on election night. The GuardianLC “He said in August he would be pressing Republican colleagues to issue a criminal referral of Kennedy to the Department of Justice for a criminal investigation.”““Subpoenas,” he wrote, in the one-word post.” Read at The Guardian ↗ The Times of IndiaN “Democrats are set to regain control of Congress in January next year following their victory in the November 3 midterm elections.” Read at The Times of India ↗ Left · 1The Independent (AP) adds that the probe is among many investigations Democrats plan into the Trump administration after regaining control of Congress, that Wyden is slated to chair the Finance Committee, which oversees HHS, from January, that Alsobrooks sits on the Senate health committee, and that the same senators on Wednesday announced a separate inquiry into hundreds of thousands of dollars in gifts reportedly given to Kennedy last year by a donor and former employee. The IndependentLC “The same senators on Wednesday announced a separate inquiry into hundreds of thousands of dollars in gifts reportedly given to Kennedy last year by a donor and former employee.”“It is among a vast array of investigations planned into the Trump administration after Democrats regained control of the House and Senate in the midterm elections.” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2Knowingly giving materially false testimony to Congress is a crime punishable by imprisonment, though rarely prosecuted. Legal experts say the Justice Department under Trump is unlikely to prosecute, but Kennedy's statements could ground hearings, an impeachment inquiry or other challenges to the administration. The GuardianLC “Knowingly giving material false testimony to Congress is a crime that carries a possible prison sentence, though it is rarely prosecuted.” Read at The Guardian ↗ The Times of IndiaN “legal experts say the justice department under Trump is unlikely to prosecute Kennedy” Read at The Times of India ↗
Left · 1The Guardian adds that Alsobrooks has repeatedly called for Kennedy to resign or be fired, that Bernie Sanders, incoming chair of the health committee, is open to impeachment, and that Kennedy has hired former CHD staff at HHS, including Lyn Redwood, who made early outreach to Samoa on his behalf. The GuardianLC “Alsobrooks, a member of the Senate committee on health, education, labor and pensions, has repeatedly called on Kennedy to resign or be fired.”“Bernie Sanders, incoming chair of the Senate committee on health, education, labor and pensions, said he is open to impeachment.”“including Lyn Redwood, a former CHD president who made early outreach on his behalf to Samoa” Read at The Guardian ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Guardian exclusive and Independent (AP) report lead with the senators' investigation and the letter contradicting Kennedy's testimony, with the Guardian tying it to its own earlier reporting and Kennedy's CHD network.
- Emphasis
- The senators' accountability language, the eight uses of 'vaccine', Democrats' incoming Senate power, calls for resignation or impeachment, and a separate gifts inquiry (Independent).
- Leaves out or plays down
- Give little room to Kennedy's own defence beyond HHS's earlier statement; the Independent omits the Samoa measles death toll.
- Charged language
- “unlawfully lied”“political machine”“grave harm”
- For example
-
“By requesting documents from CHD, Wyden is aiming at the heart of Kennedy’s political machine.” — The Guardian
“It is among a vast array of investigations planned into the Trump administration after Democrats regained control of the House and Senate in the midterm elections.” — The Independent
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Times of India summary of the Guardian and AP reporting, framed as a probe into whether Kennedy lied and into 'anti-vaccine' activism.
- Emphasis
- The controversy background, the 52-48 confirmation vote, Kennedy's and HHS's denials, and what may come next.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the CHD deadline, the records requested beyond Samoa and the Reporters Committee lawsuit, and the Guardian's detail on Kennedy's ties to CHD staff.
- For example
-
“Two Democratic senators are launching an investigation into whether US health secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr “lied” to Congress” — The Times of India
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Washington Examiner reports the probe as a Democratic accusation, quoting Kennedy's testimony and letter at length and noting he was not under oath.
- Emphasis
- Kennedy's own hearing answers (medical informatics system), the letter text, HHS's denial, and that Kennedy was not under oath; the letter 'appears to indicate' a vaccine link.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the measles outbreak deaths in Samoa, Democrats' incoming Senate control, and criminal-penalty context.
- Charged language
- “alleged lies”
- For example
-
“The two Democrats accused the HHS secretary of failing to tell the truth about a 2019 trip he took to Samoa with Children’s Health Defense.” — Washington Examiner
“A January 2019 letter Kennedy wrote to Samoan officials ahead of the trip appears to indicate his travels would be related to vaccines.” — Washington Examiner
What every side reports
- Wyden and Alsobrooks wrote to Children's Health Defense on Wednesday seeking documents about Kennedy's 2019 Samoa trip.
- Kennedy told his January 2025 confirmation hearings the trip had 'nothing to do with vaccines'.
- A 2019 measles outbreak in Samoa killed 83 people, mostly children under five, months after the trip.
- Kennedy's letter to Samoa's prime minister used 'vaccine' or 'vaccination' eight times.
- Legal experts think the Trump Justice Department is unlikely to prosecute.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether Kennedy lied to Congress about the purpose of the Samoa trip
- Left
- The Guardian says letters contradicted his testimony and that HHS has not explained the discrepancy; HHS calls the claim 'outright defamatory'.
- Centre
- The Times of India says the senators are investigating whether he 'lied', and notes Kennedy and HHS maintain the visit was 'unrelated to vaccines'.
-
Kennedy's January 2019 pre-trip letter to Samoa's prime minister contradicts his confirmation testimony that the trip had nothing to do with vaccines.
Reported- Supports 1
- The Guardian
- Reports 3
- The Independent, The Times of India, Washington Examiner
-
Kennedy did not lie to Congress; the Samoa trip was unrelated to vaccines (HHS position).
Reported- Reports 4
- The Guardian, The Independent, The Times of India, Washington Examiner
-
Kennedy was not under oath during his confirmation hearing.
Supported- Supports 2
- The Independent, Washington Examiner
- Reports 1
- The Guardian
Ron Wyden person
Wyden, with Alsobrooks, says there is evidence Kennedy unlawfully lied to Congress and intends to hold Kennedy accountable for false statements and for harm to children.
“We also intend to hold him accountable for any false statements made to Congress, a crime that undermines the Senate’s ability to fulfill its constitutional duties.”” — The Guardian
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. person
Kennedy denies lying and says he never made public statements about vaccines in Samoa; he told Congress the trip had nothing to do with vaccines.
“Kennedy has denied the allegations, saying he never gave any public statement about vaccines or discouraged Samoans from getting vaccinated.” — The Guardian
“He has denied lying during his confirmation hearing.” — The Times of India
Samoa place
Samoan officials are cited as critics who say Kennedy's presence emboldened anti-vaccine activists; Samoa's prime minister replied to his 2019 letter inviting him to visit.
“Critics, including Samoan officials, have said Kennedy’s presence emboldened anti-vaccine activists in Samoa, worsening a vaccination crisis.” — The Guardian
UK and Ireland2 outlets
The Guardian presents the inquiry as an exclusive stemming from its own reporting.
“Exclusive: Ron Wyden, citing Guardian report, is launching inquiry” — The Guardian
The Guardian, The Independent
South Asia1 outlet
The Times of India recounts the story second-hand, crediting the Guardian and AP.
“(With AP inputs)” — The Times of India
The Times of India
Left2 articles
-
Senator opens investigation into evidence RFK Jr ‘unlawfully lied’ to Congress
Critical Exclusive presenting the inquiry as following from its own reporting, with detailed evidence against Kennedy's testimony.

-
RFK Jr faces Senate probe over ‘lies’ to Congress about Samoa trip
Neutral AP copy in the Independent presents the inquiry as part of wider Democratic oversight, with the letter's contradiction, HHS denial, and not-under-oath context.

Centre1 article
-
RFK Jr faces probe over 'anti-vaccine' activism during 2019 Samoa visit
Neutral Concise explainer relaying the Guardian and AP reporting, with both the senators' claims and Kennedy's denials.

Right1 article
-
Senators launch investigation into RFK Jr. over alleged lies in confirmation testimony
Neutral Frames the story as Democratic senators' accusations, giving Kennedy's testimony and the letter side by side with HHS's denial.

- 12 Nov 15:05 First The GuardianLC Senator opens investigation into evidence RFK Jr ‘unlawfully lied’ to Congress
- 12 Nov 17:01 +1h 56m The Times of IndiaN RFK Jr faces probe over 'anti-vaccine' activism during 2019 Samoa visit
- 12 Nov 17:44 +2h 39m The IndependentLC RFK Jr faces Senate probe over ‘lies’ to Congress about Samoa trip
- 12 Nov 20:40 +5h 35m Washington ExaminerR Senators launch investigation into RFK Jr. over alleged lies in confirmation testimony
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…