Skip to content
Bramble

US

Senate HELP Committee advances Saphier surgeon general nomination 12-11

The Senate HELP Committee voted along party lines on Wednesday to send Nicole Saphier's surgeon general nomination to the full Senate. Coverage differs in emphasis: CBS stresses her vaccine testimony and background, The Hill the path to a floor vote.

5 outlets · 2L · 1C · 2R First reported Account updated
Image: CBS News
Image: The Hill
Image: Just the News
Image: Scientific American
Image: Washington Examiner

1 / 5

The story, neutrally told

The Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee advanced President Trump's nominee for surgeon general, Nicole Saphier, on Wednesday 30 September. The vote was 12-11 along party lines, according to The Hill. CBS News reports her nomination moved forward as part of a group of nominees in a party-line vote.

The Hill says the vote sets up a path to a floor vote and confirmation, and notes this is the Senate's final week in session. Trump nominated Saphier in April. She is a radiologist who directs breast imaging at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center Monmouth and was a Fox News medical contributor until her nomination. She replaced Casey Means, whose nomination Trump pulled after it stalled for months; Trump blamed committee chairman Sen. Bill Cassidy, calling him "a very disloyal person".

At her hearing earlier this month, Saphier testified that the MMR vaccine is not lethal and that she does not believe childhood vaccines cause autism. Cassidy said those statements earned her his vote.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.

Left2 outlets

Framing
CBS News (lean left) reports the vote briefly, then gives background on Saphier, the withdrawn Means nomination, Trump's clash with Cassidy and her vaccine testimony.
Emphasis
Vaccine statements at the hearing, including a contrast with the president's suggestions, and Cassidy's rationale for supporting her.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not give the 12-11 tally or mention the Senate's limited remaining session time.
For example
“Saphier testified that the MMR vaccine is not lethal, despite what the president has suggested.” — CBS News
“known for her criticism of how public health authorities handled the COVID-19 pandemic” — CBS News

Centre1 outlet

Framing
The Hill (centre) treats it as a procedural step and looks ahead to a floor vote and confirmation, with the Senate calendar as context.
Emphasis
The exact 12-11 party-line tally and the timing of a floor vote in the Senate's final week in session.
Leaves out or plays down
Its available text does not cover her background, vaccine testimony or the Means withdrawal.
Charged language
“glide path”
For example
“setting up a glide path to a floor vote and confirmation” — The Hill
“voted to advance Nicole Saphier along party lines, 12-11” — The Hill

Right2 outlets

No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.