Skip to content
Bramble

World

Settlers block Israeli forces from returning Palestinian family to Jalud homes

Settlers attacked the West Bank village of Jalud on Monday night, stopping Israeli forces from returning the Tubasi family to their homes under a court order. The homes were set on fire; outlets differ on numbers and emphasis.

7 outlets · 3L · 2C · 2R First reported Account updated

Updated (version 4). New coverage since the last version from Anadolu Agency, The Guardian, The Jerusalem Post. Previously: “Settlers stop military effort to return Palestinian family to Jalud homes”.

Image: The Straits Times
Image: Anadolu Agency
Image: NBC News
Image: The Jerusalem Post
Image: The Guardian

1 / 5

The story, neutrally told

Israeli settlers attacked the village of Jalud in the occupied West Bank on Monday night and stopped Israeli forces from returning a Palestinian family to its homes. The BBC and Reuters (via the Straits Times) put the number of settlers at more than 100, while NBC News said dozens. The family had left in the summer after a siege by settlers, and the attempted return followed an Israeli High Court order.

Two houses were set on fire. The military said three officers were injured and that "due to the violence, the mission to return the family to their homes was not completed." Mahmoud Tubasi said security forces shielded the family and drove them away but took no action against the settlers. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said he strongly condemned the violence and urged prosecution of those responsible.

Arrest figures differ: Israeli police said three people were arrested, while the military said it arrested two settlers. Rights groups say authorities fail to act; Yesh Din says fewer than three per cent of police investigations into settler violence over two decades led to a conviction. It is unclear when another attempt to return the family will be made, and the homes are badly damaged.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.

Left3 outlets

Framing
Centres on the family's ordeal and the failure of security forces and Israeli leaders to stop settler violence; NBC also notes the family was attacked a month earlier along with an NBC crew.
Emphasis
Family testimony, the earlier attack on an NBC crew, international embarrassment for Israeli leaders, and the court order.
Leaves out or plays down
Gives no arrest figures and uses a lower settler count (dozens) than other outlets.
Charged language
“growing international embarrassment”“thugs”
For example
“It is the second time that Tubassi and his wife, Aida Ahmed Abdullah, 51, have suffered at the hands of Jewish settlers in just over a month.” — NBC News
“with the authorities accused of not doing enough to stop them” — The New York Times

Centre2 outlets

Framing
Detailed account combining the family's testimony, IDF statements, the court ruling and UN and rights-group data on settler violence.
Emphasis
Family account, the court's strong wording, Yesh Din's conviction rate, UN figures, and Netanyahu's earlier UN remarks.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not mention the separate Al Mughayyir incident reported by Reuters.
Charged language
“Extremist settlers”“illegal outpost”
For example
“Human rights groups say the events show how Israeli authorities are failing to take effective action against settler violence.” — BBC News

Right2 outlets

Framing
Short wire report (Reuters) built on witnesses and military statements, with an added line on the military's failure to rein in settlers.
Emphasis
Witness accounts, damage to the homes, military statement and arrests, and other settler attacks the same day.
Leaves out or plays down
Omits the High Court order, and gives little on the family's account of security forces' conduct or on rights-group statistics.
Charged language
“emboldened by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's far-right government”
For example
“The incident highlights the Israeli military's failure to rein in settlers emboldened by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's far-right government” — The Straits Times