Simulation: one nuclear blast in orbit could disable about 98% of satellites within a week
A preprint simulation by researchers at the University of Wisconsin–Madison and Princeton finds a 1-megaton detonation 500 km above the South Atlantic would disable about 98% of satellites within a week. The effects would last for years.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Researchers at the University of Wisconsin–Madison and Princeton University have simulated a single 1-megaton nuclear detonation 500 km (310 miles) above the South Atlantic. They found it would disable about 98 per cent of satellites within one week. New ScientistN “modelled the effect of a 1 megaton explosion 500 kilometres above the South Atlantic” Read at New Scientist ↗ Daily MailR “scientists from the University of Wisconsin-Madison, and Princeton University carried out a simulation” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2The study, led by Zachary Petersen (spelled Peterson in the Daily Mail), is a preprint on arXiv. The Daily Mail says this means it has not yet been peer reviewed in a journal. Daily MailR “which is published as a pre-print on arXiv, the researchers, led by Zachary Peterson” Read at Daily Mail ↗ New ScientistN “Zachary Petersen at the University of Wisconsin–Madison and his colleagues” Read at New Scientist ↗ Mixed · 2The initial X-ray burst would be damaging, but the main cause of failures would be electrons released by radioactive fission products. These become trapped in Earth's magnetic field and form an artificial radiation belt that exposes satellites repeatedly. New ScientistN “electrons released by radioactive fission would become trapped in Earth’s magnetic field, exposing satellites to a kind of artificial radiation belt, over and over again” Read at New Scientist ↗ Daily MailR “electrons released by radioactive fission products can become trapped in Earth’s magnetic field, repeatedly exposing satellites as an artificial radiation belt” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Centre · 1New Scientist reports that when the team assumed satellites were three times more resistant to radiation, 97 per cent still failed within two weeks. New ScientistN “assume that satellites were three times more resilient to radiation damage, the effects were still disastrous, with 97 per cent still failing within two weeks” Read at New Scientist ↗ Mixed · 2The simulation also expects about 20 satellite collisions within two years as dead satellites drift. New Scientist links this to the risk of Kessler syndrome, a theoretical chain reaction of debris that could make orbit unusable for decades. Daily MailR “approximately 20 collisions expected within two years” Read at Daily Mail ↗ New ScientistN “a theoretical scenario in which debris hits other satellites, creating more debris and a chain reaction of destruction” Read at New Scientist ↗ Mixed · 2Replacement satellites would be launched into an environment still affected by radiation and debris, so recovery could take years. Daily MailR “Replacement satellites could remain exposed to radiation and debris for years.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ New ScientistN “restoring orbital infrastructure could take years” Read at New Scientist ↗
Mixed · 2Both outlets cite the 1962 Starfish Prime test as precedent. The US detonated a 1.4-megaton bomb about 400 km up over the Pacific. The Daily Mail says it also knocked out streetlights and disrupted telephones in Hawaii and created radiation belts that wrecked satellites. Far more satellites are in orbit now. Daily MailR “the 'Starfish Prime' nuclear test saw a 1.4-megaton warhead detonated 248 miles (400km) above Johnston Atoll in the Pacific” Read at Daily Mail ↗ New ScientistN “The US detonated a 1.4 megaton nuclear bomb at an altitude of 400 km in 1962.” Read at New Scientist ↗ Mixed · 2The research is set against concern over Russia. In 2024 the US said Russia was developing a nuclear anti-satellite capability. Russia denied plans to put nuclear weapons in orbit but vetoed a UN Security Council resolution reaffirming the Outer Space Treaty's ban. Daily MailR “Russia denied plans to place nuclear weapons in space but vetoed a UN Security Council resolution” Read at Daily Mail ↗ New ScientistN “The Outer Space Treaty now bans the launch of nuclear weapons into space, and all major spacefaring nations are party to it.” Read at New Scientist ↗ Mixed · 2Outside experts quoted by New Scientist say the consequences would be severe. Craig Underwood of the University of Surrey says low-Earth orbit mega-constellations such as Starlink would be particularly affected and that society is more vulnerable than in the Cold War. Chantal Cappelletti of the University of Nottingham says the result would be prolonged degradation of services, not an immediate collapse of society. The Daily Mail quotes James McKeon of Nuclear Philanthropy: "Very, very bad." New ScientistN “The result would not be an immediate collapse of modern society, but rather a prolonged degradation of many services”“The recent low-Earth orbit mega constellations [like Starlink] would be particularly affected” Read at New Scientist ↗ Daily MailR “It would be bad. Very bad. Very, very bad.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- A science report that leads with the finding and adds the robustness test and the Kessler-syndrome risk. It quotes two independent UK space academics.
- Emphasis
- Methodology, the three-times radiation-resilience test, long-term recovery and outside expert comment.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Starfish Prime's effects on the ground in Hawaii. Notes the study authors did not respond to a request for comment.
- Charged language
- “Worryingly”
- For example
-
“Worryingly, such explosions aren't without precedent.” — New Scientist
“Petersen and his colleagues didn't immediately respond to a request for comment” — New Scientist
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- A dramatic headline and a science-fiction-style opening. Its main quote is a reaction from a nuclear-policy figure. The piece ends with an unrelated list of personal nuclear-survival tips.
- Emphasis
- Catastrophe, everyday dependence on satellites, and the Starfish Prime effects in Hawaii.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not report the robustness test with more radiation-resistant satellites, and quotes no independent experts. Its headline figure of 99% differs from the 98% in its own text.
- Charged language
- “catastrophic impact”“very, very bad”“devastate”
- For example
-
“The catastrophic impact of a nuke in space: Simulation reveals how a single explosion could disable 99% of satellites within days” — Daily Mail
“the consequences would be enormous” — Daily Mail
What every side reports
- The simulation modelled a 1-megaton detonation about 500 km over the South Atlantic.
- About 98 per cent of satellites would be disabled within a week in the main scenario.
- About 20 collisions are expected within two years.
- The 1962 Starfish Prime test (1.4 megatons, about 400 km up) is the precedent.
- Recovery would take years because of lingering radiation and debris.
Where accounts differ
-
Share of satellites disabled
- Centre
- New Scientist gives 98 per cent within a week in its headline and text.
- Right
- The Daily Mail headline says 99% within days, but its text says about 98 per cent within one week.
-
Number of satellites in orbit
- Centre
- New Scientist says around 25,000 objects have been launched into space.
- Right
- The Daily Mail says more than 13,000 satellites operate in low-Earth orbit.
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre1 article
-
Nuclear bomb in space would disable 98 per cent of satellites within a week
Neutral A measured report of the study with robustness checks, historical precedent and independent expert comment.

Right1 article
-
Alarmist Sensational headline and blockbuster comparison, a study summary, then unrelated nuclear-attack survival advice.

- 13 Nov 10:30 First Daily MailR The catastrophic impact of a nuke in space: Simulation reveals how a single explosion could disable 99% of satellites within days
- 16 Nov 16:15 +77h 45m New ScientistN Nuclear bomb in space would disable 98 per cent of satellites within a week
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…