Six Flags permanently closes X2 coaster at Magic Mountain after brain-injury claims
Six Flags Magic Mountain said on Tuesday 29 September it will not reopen the X2 roller coaster, shut since July, after lawsuits and a CNN report alleging riders suffered brain injuries. The park says the ride passed safety tests.
Updated (version 5). New coverage since the last version from CNA, Gulf News.
1 / 8
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 2Six Flags Magic Mountain in California announced on Tuesday that it is permanently closing its X2 roller coaster, which has been shut since July. CNAN “The ride has been closed since shortly after the second incident, but on Tuesday park managers said they were shuttering it for good.” Read at CNA ↗ NewsweekN “Six Flags has permanently closed its X2 roller coaster, citing guest confidence concerns after years of safety scrutiny.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Centre · 1Park president Brian Oerding said X2 consistently passed safety tests but was closed because "it's the right thing to do" and because guest confidence was affected. CNAN “While X2 consistently passed a multitude of safety tests, we have decided to close the ride because we believe it's the right thing to do.” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 2Attorneys at Dordick Law, which represents Naomi Greer-Wilkinson, said more than 100 people had contacted them saying they were injured; these are allegations, not findings in court. Gulf NewsN “Attorneys at Dordick Law, who are acting for Greer-Wilkinson, said they had been contacted by more than 100 people who say they were injured by the roller coaster.” Read at Gulf News ↗ BBC NewsN “The announcement comes after multiple lawsuits alleged that hundreds of riders suffered brain injuries from X2, a ride with seats that spin 360 degrees.” Read at BBC News ↗
Centre · 1A CNN investigation reported that Pamela Guillen, 40, was injured on 5 July and Greer-Wilkinson, 25, less than a week later; Greer-Wilkinson's parents say she was in a coma for weeks. CNAN “Less than a week later, Naomi Greer-Wilkinson of Los Angeles, 25, lost consciousness after riding X2 and underwent emergency brain surgery, CNN reported.” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1Dordick attorney Christopher Bulone said the ride's design "makes it inherently dangerous"; Six Flags says it does not comment on pending litigation. CNAN “Theme park operator Six Flags, which has properties throughout North America, says it does not comment on pending litigation.” Read at CNA ↗ Right · 1In August Six Flags and manufacturer S&S Worldwide settled with the family of Christopher Hawley, 22, who died after riding X2 in 2022; another suit, by Sheila Katerelos, is scheduled for next year. The Straits TimesRC “In August, the company and ride manufacturer S&S Worldwide Inc. reached a settlement with the family of 22-year-old Christopher Hawley, who died after riding X2 in 2022.” Read at The Straits Times ↗
Right · 1X opened in 2002 and became X2 in 2008; Six Flags says it has welcomed more than 16 million guests. The Straits TimesRC “Since X2 opened in 2008, it has welcomed more than 16 million guests and earned a passionate following among ride enthusiasts,” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Right · 1Some UK outlets say the ride will be demolished, a claim Newsweek disputes; the closure announcement itself does not mention what happens to the structure. Daily ExpressR “Six Flags has said its X2 rollercoaster, enjoyed by more than 16 million people, is to be demolished after a report into deaths, comas and injuries” Read at Daily Express ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left3 outlets
- Framing
- The Independent leads with severe injuries and victims; the Mirror calls the ride 'notorious' and stresses deaths and demolition; the A.V. Club is sardonic, citing CNN's August report.
- Emphasis
- Victim detail, deaths, injuries and corporate responsibility.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The Mirror leaves out plaintiffs' figures; none stress the park's safety-test defence as much as the lawsuits.
- Charged language
- “notorious”
- For example
-
“Six Flags Magic Mountain has announced the closure of the notorious X2 rollercoaster after being linked to deaths and numerous injuries over the past two decades” — Daily Mirror
“The move comes after a CNN report in August that tied several brain injuries to the amusement park ride.” — The A.V. Club
Centre5 outlets
- Framing
- Newsweek, BBC and Anadolu report the closure and lawsuits plainly; Gulf News (AFP) and CNA run AFP's account of the two July victims, lawyers and Hawley settlement.
- Emphasis
- Company statement, lawsuit claims and lawyer reactions.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Newsweek omits lawsuit figures and victims; the AFP-based pieces leave out the CNN-reported deaths count and any regulator inquiry.
- Charged language
- “brain damage claims”
Right4 outlets
- Framing
- The Post stresses 'catastrophic' injuries; the Express says a report 'exposed' injuries and deaths; GB News puts 'brain injury' in quotes; the Straits Times runs brief reports, one an AFP copy.
- Emphasis
- Graphic injuries, the ride's fame and lawyers' quotes.
- Leaves out or plays down
- GB News and the first Straits Times piece leave out victims' detail; the Straits Times's own copy is AFP's wording.
- Charged language
- “catastrophic brain injuries”“exposed”“Behemoth”
- For example
-
“Six Flags Magic Mountain permanently shuts down X2 after series of catastrophic brain injuries” — New York Post
“Behemoth theme park shuts down iconic rollercoaster over 'brain injury' allegations” — GB News
What every side reports
- X2 is permanently closed and has been shut since July.
- Park president Brian Oerding said the ride consistently passed safety tests but guest confidence was affected.
- Riders allege brain injuries in lawsuits; Dordick Law says it has heard from more than 100 people.
- Christopher Hawley's family settled in August after his 2022 death.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether X2 is being demolished
- Left
- The Mirror says it is 'to be demolished'; The Independent relays it.
- Centre
- Newsweek disputes demolition; other centre outlets report only permanent closure.
- Right
- The Express says it is 'demolished' or to be demolished; GB News says only that it will close.
-
How many deaths are tied to the ride
- Left
- The Mirror says deaths, plural, over two decades; The Independent and A.V. Club cite two deaths.
- Centre
- BBC and Anadolu cite two deaths; AFP-based copy mentions only Hawley's.
- Right
- The Post and GB News cite two; the Express disputes the figure.
-
X2 consistently passed safety tests but was closed permanently because guest confidence was affected.
Reported- Reports 12
- Daily Mirror, The A.V. Club, The Independent, Anadolu Agency, BBC News, CNA, Gulf News, Newsweek, Daily Express, GB News, New York Post, The Straits Times
-
At least 100 riders allege brain injuries from X2, with some lawyers citing hundreds.
Reported- Reports 11
- The A.V. Club, The Independent, Anadolu Agency, BBC News, CNA, Gulf News, Newsweek, Daily Express, GB News, New York Post, The Straits Times
-
X2 is being demolished.
Supported- Supports 2
- Daily Mirror, Daily Express
- Reports 1
- The Independent
- Earlier 1
- Newsweek
-
Two deaths are linked to X2 (Hilda Farias 2010, Christopher Hawley 2022).
Reported- Disputes 1
- Daily Express
- Reports 7
- Daily Mirror, The A.V. Club, The Independent, Anadolu Agency, BBC News, GB News, New York Post
Six Flags Magic Mountain organisation
The park says the ride passed safety tests but is being retired because guest confidence was affected, and does not comment on pending litigation.
“Ride safety is a cornerstone of our business, and when we see guest confidence affected, we take it seriously.” — CNA
Brian Oerding person
As park president, he announced the retirement and called it the right thing to do.
“After almost 20 years, we have decided to permanently retire X2,” — CNA
S&S Worldwide organisation
The seat manufacturer is named alongside Six Flags in the Hawley settlement; AFP-based copy gives no statement from it.
“the company and ride manufacturer S&S Worldwide Inc. reached a settlement” — The Straits Times
UK and Ireland5 outlets
UK outlets are most vivid, with the Mirror and Express stressing deaths and demolition and GB News using scare quotes.
“linked to deaths and numerous injuries over the past two decades” — Daily Mirror
The Independent, BBC News, Daily Mirror, Daily Express, GB News
East and Southeast Asia2 outlets
The Straits Times and CNA run short, neutral pieces, with AFP's account.
“The X2 roller coaster has been the subject of lawsuits alleging that the ride caused brain injuries.” — The Straits Times
The Straits Times, CNA
Left3 articles
-
Six Flags officially closes X2 roller coaster after multiple severe brain injuries were reported
Critical Detailed account of lawsuits, victims and the company's silence.
-
Six Flags' X2 rollercoaster linked to brain injuries, comas and deaths to be demolished
Alarmist Emphasises deaths and demolition with the ride's reputation.

-
Six Flags "permanently retiring" its X2 roller coaster
Critical Sardonic take mocking Six Flags' safety language and doubting accountability.

Centre5 articles
-
Six Flags Shutters X2: Roller Coaster Closed Over Safety Concerns
Neutral Short breaking report on the closure as a safety and perception issue.

-
Six Flags shuts down X2 rollercoaster after hundreds allege brain injuries
Neutral Balances the company statement with plaintiffs' and Hawley family lawyers' reactions.
-
US amusement park retires famous roller coaster amid reports of brain injuries
Neutral Concise report leading with the park's statement, the CNN findings and three lawsuits.

-
Gulf NewsN · · via AFP
California roller coaster shut after brain damage claims
Neutral AFP copy carried by Gulf News leads with the permanent shutdown after claims of brain damage and the two July victims.

Show 1 moreShow fewer
-
CNAN ·
California roller coaster shut after brain damage claims
Neutral CNA runs the AFP account with its own lede about a 'cloud of safety-related legal complaints'.

Right5 articles
-
Six Flags Magic Mountain permanently shuts down X2 after series of catastrophic brain injuries
Alarmist Leads with graphic injuries and named victims.

-
Six Flags X2 rollercoaster demolished after report exposed brain injuries and deaths
Mixed Credits a CNN investigation, then adds fan reactions and the regulator's statement.

-
Six Flags shuts California roller coaster at centre of lawsuits
Neutral Brief wire report with the share-price reaction.
-
GB NewsR ·
Behemoth theme park shuts down iconic rollercoaster over 'brain injury' allegations
Neutral Leads on the closure and puts 'brain injury' in quotes, then gives Dordick's and Wisner's reactions.

Show 1 moreShow fewer
-
The Straits TimesRC · · via AFP
California roller coaster at Six Flags Magic Mountain shut after brain damage claims
Neutral AFP copy carried by the Straits Times, same account with metric speed units.
- 29 Sep 19:24 First NewsweekN Six Flags Shutters X2: Roller Coaster Closed Over Safety Concerns
- 29 Sep 20:12 +48m New York PostR Six Flags Magic Mountain permanently shuts down X2 after series of catastrophic brain injuries
- 29 Sep 21:43 +2h 19m The IndependentLC Six Flags officially closes X2 roller coaster after multiple severe brain injuries were reported
- 29 Sep 23:33 +4h 9m BBC NewsN Six Flags shuts down X2 rollercoaster after hundreds allege brain injuries
- 30 Sep 00:15 +4h 51m Daily MirrorL Six Flags' X2 rollercoaster linked to brain injuries, comas and deaths to be demolished
- 30 Sep 00:52 +5h 27m Daily ExpressR Six Flags X2 rollercoaster demolished after report exposed brain injuries and deaths
- 30 Sep 10:35 +15h 10m The Straits TimesRC Six Flags shuts California roller coaster at centre of lawsuits
- 30 Sep 17:07 +21h 43m Anadolu AgencyN US amusement park retires famous roller coaster amid reports of brain injuries
- 30 Sep 18:12 +22h 48m The A.V. ClubLC Six Flags "permanently retiring" its X2 roller coaster
- 30 Sep 18:48 +23h 24m GB NewsR Behemoth theme park shuts down iconic rollercoaster over 'brain injury' allegations
- 1 Oct 01:11 +29h 47m Gulf NewsN California roller coaster shut after brain damage claims via AFP
- 1 Oct 01:30 +30h 5m The Straits TimesRC California roller coaster at Six Flags Magic Mountain shut after brain damage claims via AFP
- 1 Oct 02:17 +30h 52m CNAN California roller coaster shut after brain damage claims
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…