SNP invites PM Burnham to Aberdeen conference as Scotland visit is reported
The SNP has invited Prime Minister Andy Burnham to its Aberdeen conference after reports of a Friday visit to Scotland. Coverage centres on the independence dispute and whether the visit will overshadow the event.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 1The SNP invited Prime Minister Andy Burnham to its party conference at P&J Live in Aberdeen after newspapers reported on Tuesday 13 October that Burnham would visit Scotland on Friday. Evening StandardN “The SNP has invited Andy Burnham to the party’s conference amid reports he will visit Scotland on Friday.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1The Evening Standard reported that the visit is tied to a call for Holyrood to devolve powers to councils, an idea the Labour leader has previously backed. Evening StandardN “the Prime Minister will travel north of the border as part of a call for Holyrood to devolve powers to councils.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1SNP depute leader Keith Brown issued the invitation. He said the Prime Minister had agreed it is for the people of Scotland to decide their own future, and called the conference the natural place for Burnham to set out "an agreed legal process". Evening StandardN “SNP conference is the perfect and natural place for Andy Burnham to set out the logical extension of his words – an agreed legal process.”” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Mixed · 2Burnham has ruled out another independence referendum and said last month there was "no clear consensus" for one. According to the Standard, Burnham walked back Commons comments suggesting Scotland could have another vote, reaffirming that independence is "off limits" and refusing to budge because of the so-called Cardiff Agreement between pro-independence party leaders in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland. First Minister John Swinney had said on Monday that the push for independence had "turned a corner". Evening StandardN “Mr Burnham walked his position back, reaffirming his view that Scottish independence is “off limits”” Read at Evening Standard ↗ The GuardianLC “Burnham has already said there is “no clear consensus” for another vote.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 1The Guardian said Burnham's Friday visit falls in the middle of the conference and is a "thinly veiled attempt to overshadow" it. Burnham would be at a different venue, it said, and would be making the case for the union on Scottish soil. The GuardianLC “Burnham is expected to visit Scotland on Friday – the middle of the event – in a thinly veiled attempt to overshadow the SNP gathering.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2Swinney is due to address members on Saturday afternoon to renew the case for a second referendum, and has said he wants a new vote before 2031. This is the SNP's first conference since it won the most seats at the Holyrood election in May, though only enough for a minority government. The GuardianLC “Swinney has said he wants a new vote before 2031.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Evening StandardN “is the first since John Swinney’s party won the most seats at the Holyrood election in May.” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Mixed · 2Burnham spoke of Swinney in the Labour conference speech last month. Swinney had predicted Burnham would be the last UK prime minister, and said it on the day Burnham's father died. Burnham said they were not seeking sympathy or criticising Swinney but were "utterly determined to prove him wrong". The GuardianLC ““I quote that not to seek sympathy,” Burnham said, holding back tears.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Evening StandardN ““I relay it because I want you to know how it made me feel. Utterly determined to prove him wrong.”” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Left · 1The Guardian cited polling that suggests Burnham is a harder opponent for the SNP than recent Westminster governments. PF Global found 46% of Scots view Burnham favourably, and Ipsos found 42% would be happy about the SNP-led Scottish government working with London. The GuardianLC “Polling by PF Global found that 46% of Scots have a favourable view of Burnham”“42% of Scots would feel happy about the SNP-led Scottish government working with London” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 1SNP MP Lara Bird said Burnham was opening up the question of revisiting referendum results, in reference to the EU, while denying Scotland the same democratic principle, and called the idea that the union can continue in its current form "absolutely farcical". The GuardianLC ““The idea that the union can continue to exist in its current form is absolutely farcical.”” Read at The Guardian ↗
Left · 1The Guardian also set out the party's wider difficulties. These include the fraud conviction of former chair Peter Murrell, who is serving a five-year sentence, Reform matching Labour on 17 MSPs, a record 15 Scottish Green seats, and a Conservative win over the SNP in Aberdeen South in June. The GuardianLC “Reform has as many MSPs as Labour in Holyrood with 17, while the Scottish Greens won a record 15 seats.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- The Guardian treats the story as a political contest: a popular prime minister challenging the SNP on its home ground and potentially overshadowing its conference.
- Emphasis
- Polling on Burnham's popularity, the SNP's recent troubles and electoral challengers, and Burnham's personal exchange with Swinney.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Keith Brown's formal invitation or the Cardiff Agreement dispute.
- Charged language
- “thinly veiled attempt to overshadow”“separatist”
- For example
-
“in a thinly veiled attempt to overshadow the SNP gathering” — The Guardian
“The separatists have grown used to facing off against rightwing, pro-Brexit governments in London” — The Guardian
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- The Evening Standard reports the invitation as a news item, quoting the SNP's case for a legal route to a referendum and setting it against Burnham's refusal.
- Emphasis
- Keith Brown's invitation, Burnham's walk-back on a second vote, and the Cardiff Agreement.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Gives no polling or analysis of the SNP's wider position.
- Charged language
- “leader of Unionism”
- For example
-
“there is no better time for the leader of Unionism and the leader of Scottish independence” — Evening Standard
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- The SNP conference is in Aberdeen this weekend, the first since the May Holyrood election.
- Burnham is expected to visit Scotland on Friday.
- Burnham has said there is no clear consensus for a second independence referendum.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether a second independence vote is possible
- Left
- The Guardian reports Burnham ruling out a second vote while SNP figures say the union cannot continue in its present form.
- Centre
- The Standard reports Swinney saying Burnham's Commons comments show the case has moved on, and Burnham walking this back within hours.
Andy Burnham person
Rules out another independence referendum, citing no clear consensus. He reaffirmed that independence is "off limits" after comments in the Commons, and is expected to visit Scotland on Friday.
“Mr Burnham has previously ruled out another referendum on Scottish independence.” — Evening Standard
Scottish National Party party
Invites Burnham to the conference and argues the independence question should be settled by an agreed legal process. It says the case has "turned a corner" and that the union cannot continue in its current form.
“The SNP would like to invite Andy Burnham to SNP conference as part of his visit to Scotland.” — Evening Standard
““The idea that the union can continue to exist in its current form is absolutely farcical.”” — The Guardian
John Swinney person
Says the independence push has turned a corner, points to Burnham's Commons comments and the agreement among pro-independence leaders, and wants a new vote before 2031.
“the First Minister said the push for independence had “turned a corner”.” — Evening Standard
“Swinney has said he wants a new vote before 2031.” — The Guardian
Left1 article
-
Burnham v Swinney: will the UK PM overshadow the SNP’s conference?
Mixed Analysis presenting Burnham as a new kind of challenge to the SNP, supported by polling and an account of the party's difficulties.
Centre1 article
-
SNP invites Burnham to party conference amid Scotland visit reports
Neutral Straight news report of the SNP invitation, with Brown's quotes balanced against Burnham's position on a referendum.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 13 Oct 10:32 First Evening StandardN SNP invites Burnham to party conference amid Scotland visit reports
- 15 Oct 07:00 +44h 28m The GuardianLC Burnham v Swinney: will the UK PM overshadow the SNP’s conference?
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…