Skip to content
Bramble

World

South Korea to recall ambassador from Ukraine over North Korean POW transfer row

South Korea said on 8 October it will recall its ambassador to Ukraine amid a diplomatic dispute over the transfer of North Korean prisoners of war to Seoul. Ukraine's foreign minister has called the affair a "diplomatic misunderstanding".

4 outlets · 0L · 4C · 0R First reported Account updated

Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from BBC News, Deutsche Welle.

Image: CNA
Image: South China Morning Post
Image: BBC News
Image: Deutsche Welle

1 / 4

The story, neutrally told

Centre · 2South Korea said on Thursday 8 October that it will recall its ambassador to Ukraine, in response to a deepening diplomatic row over the transfer of North Korean prisoners of war to Seoul. Centre · 2The foreign ministry said in a statement: "The government has decided to recall its ambassador to Ukraine." Centre · 2The ministry added that Seoul hopes all outstanding issues between the two countries will be resolved amicably and will continue consultations with the Ukrainian side to that end.

Centre · 2The countries have been at loggerheads since Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky angered Seoul by disclosing the transfer of the prisoners, who were captured on the battlefield early last year. Centre · 2Zelensky revealed the transfer of two captured North Korean soldiers in a speech at the UN General Assembly in September, saying they had not been "easy to capture alive". Centre · 2Seoul says Ukraine agreed to keep the transfer confidential and broke that agreement; Zelensky's office maintains there was no non-disclosure agreement.

Centre · 2Seoul has summoned Kyiv's ambassador and threatened unspecified "further measures", while President Lee Jae Myung has demanded an official apology over concerns that the disclosure could put the POWs' families at risk. Centre · 1Lee's office said the transfer had been kept confidential partly to protect the North Koreans' families, and that Ukraine had indicated the soldiers would be mentioned in the address but not the fact of their transfer; Lee called the disclosure "greatly disappointing" and a "highly sensitive issue" for national security. Centre · 1Seoul later demanded Ukraine apologise for "announcing a falsehood", and the opposition at home accused Lee of wanting to cover up the transfer to appease Pyongyang, which his office rejected.

Centre · 2Ukraine's Foreign Minister Andriy Sybiga has referred to the incident as a "diplomatic misunderstanding". Centre · 1Foreign Minister Cho Hyun said earlier this week he had received an apology from his Ukrainian counterpart that fell short of Seoul's expectations, but on Wednesday Ukrainian foreign ministry spokesperson Heorhii Tykhyi said Sybiha had not apologised, according to Ukrainian site Liga. Centre · 2The recall also follows a report this week alleging that more than 176,000 tonnes of fuel, mostly diesel, were shipped from South Korea to Russia in July and August, prompting accusations that Seoul was helping alleviate Russian fuel shortages; DW attributes the report to an investigative piece in The Guardian that says the fuel travelled via sanctioned tankers, and the coverage does not say whether the claim has been verified.

Centre · 2South Korea has given Ukraine humanitarian and non-lethal aid, including a $100 million package announced in July, but has refused to provide lethal weapons to countries at war while keeping cordial ties with Russia, which has warned it would retaliate if Seoul armed Ukraine.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left0 outlets

No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Centre4 outlets

Framing
Breaking-news reports leading with Seoul's recall decision. CNA and SCMP carry short AFP copy; BBC and DW add background on the disputed confidentiality agreement, the apology dispute and Seoul's wider policy on Ukraine and Russia.
Emphasis
The foreign ministry statement, Lee Jae Myung's apology demand, the disagreement over whether a confidentiality agreement existed, and the fuel-shipment report.
Leaves out or plays down
None of the four gives Ukraine's response to the recall itself, and none provides evidence for the fuel-shipment allegation. The short AFP copy omits the confidentiality dispute.
Charged language
“diplomatic misunderstanding”“announcing a falsehood”
For example
“Seoul says Ukraine broke an agreement to keep the transfer a secret but Zelensky's office maintains that there was no non-disclosure agreement in place.” — BBC News
“Kyiv, meanwhile, has said no such agreement existed” — Deutsche Welle
“It also follows a report this week alleging that more than 176,000 tonnes of fuel” — South China Morning Post

Right0 outlets

No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.