Skip to content
Bramble

World

Spanish train drivers strike over rail safety after two deadly crashes this year

Spanish train drivers struck on 10 November, disrupting services nationwide, to demand safety commitments after crashes in January (46 dead) and October (69 dead). The government approved a decree on drivers' right to stop trains in danger.

3 outlets · 1L · 1C · 1R First reported Account updated

Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from The Independent.

Image: The Straits Times
Image: Anadolu Agency
Image: The Independent

1 / 3

The story, neutrally told

Mixed · 2Spanish train drivers went on strike on Tuesday 10 November to demand more investment in rail maintenance and safety, causing widespread disruption across the country. Right · 1Renfe said about 40% of long- and medium-distance services were cancelled, affecting 4,042 passengers; Reuters reported that 90% of services in Madrid's commuter network and 50% of Barcelona's local service were also cancelled. Left · 1Candida Hiciano, 60, described the scene at Madrid's Atocha station as "chaos" but said she would try to get to work regardless; commuters in Leganes, near Madrid, had to take buses.

Centre · 1Anadolu reported that Madrid's Cercanias suspended six lines, with occasional trains on two others, while Catalonia's Rodalies said none of its lines was running as scheduled. Cancellations also hit the Madrid-Barcelona high-speed line and Madrid-Valladolid services, and Renfe offered free ticket changes or cancellations but warned few seats were available. Left · 1Rodalies blamed delays in Catalonia on non-compliance with minimum-service requirements, but Semaf said its drivers were respecting the government's minimum service quotas and that delays were caused by poor management of the programmed trains. The Independent put the Madrid commuter figures at least five lines not operating and three with partial service, according to Cercanias. Mixed · 2The strike follows the 28 October crash near Urda, in Toledo province, which killed 69 people, and a January crash at Adamuz that killed 46. Reuters said both crashes were on the Madrid-Seville high-speed line and killed 115 people in total.

Mixed · 2According to Transport Minister Oscar Puente, as cited by Reuters, the October collision occurred after a controller ordered a Renfe train to continue following a signal failure even though a stationary Iryo-operated train was ahead on the same line. Anadolu linked the crash to a failure of the automatic train protection system. Mixed · 2The drivers' union Semaf says safety talks with the government that began after the January crash were abandoned in April. Anadolu reported the union had already scheduled a walkout for 29 October over unfulfilled commitments made after two January incidents, the Adamuz crash and a derailment in Catalonia that killed a driver. Centre · 1The drivers are demanding clear rules for operating in severe weather and a ban on trains resuming normal speeds after an automatic train protection failure.

Mixed · 2Oscar Puente resigned as Transport Minister over the crashes, and Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez appointed his deputy, Carlos Cuerpo, to run the ministry provisionally. Cuerpo met union representatives twice in under a week; Semaf acknowledged progress but kept the strike, with further stoppages planned for Thursday during the morning and evening rush hours and late at night. Centre · 1The government approved a decree on Tuesday recognising drivers' right to stop or refuse to start a train in serious and imminent danger and allowing rail workers to report safety risks confidentially, RTVE reported, according to Anadolu. Left · 1The Independent reported the government's package on Tuesday also clarified how drivers' operating time is calculated and created an ombudsman position for victims of public transport accidents.

Mixed · 2Elsewhere, King Felipe VI and Queen Letizia were due to join victims' relatives at a funeral in Toledo's cathedral, and the strike comes a day before Spain's largest unions hold a nationwide general strike over housing and low wages, the country's first since 2012.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left1 outlet

Framing
The Independent leads on the scale of the toll (115 killed) and the disruption, combining Reuters-style figures with commuter voices and the government's safety package.
Emphasis
Human impact (a commuter quote, buses in Leganes), the 115 death toll in the headline, Semaf's rebuttal that delays stem from poor management, and the fuller list of government measures including the victims' ombudsman.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not mention the planned Thursday stoppages, the specific driver demands or the next day's general strike.
Charged language
“This is chaos”
For example
“Train drivers strike in Spain after 115 killed in two crashes this year” — The Independent
“The union added that delays were caused by poor management of the programmed trains.” — The Independent

Centre1 outlet

Framing
Anadolu leads on the disruption and the drivers' safety demands, and gives the most detail on those demands, the government's decree and further planned stoppages.
Emphasis
Union demands, the government's concessions (decree, talks with Cuerpo) and the planned general strike.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not give Renfe's cancellation percentages or mention Puente's resignation or the cause of the crash as stated by Puente.
For example
“Semaf acknowledged progress in the talks but maintained the strike, with further stoppages planned for Thursday” — Anadolu Agency

Right1 outlet

Framing
Reuters copy carried by the Straits Times leads on the strike and the political fallout, including Puente's resignation, with cancellation figures and the funeral in Toledo.
Emphasis
Cancellation numbers, the minister's resignation, the union's claim that talks were abandoned in April, and the royal attendance at the funeral.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not mention the government decree, the specific driver demands or further planned stoppages.
For example
“Talks with the government to improve safety on Spain's high-speed network, Europe's most extensive, began after a crash in southern Spain in January that killed 46 people, but were abandoned in April, according to the train drivers union.” — The Straits Times

Ask about this story

Loading…