Entertainment · Strictly Come Dancing season 23
Strictly's first three-way dance-off sends Lawrence Robb home; fans criticise twist
Strictly Come Dancing held its first three-couple dance-off, with judges choosing who to eliminate rather than save, and Lawrence Robb left. Viewers criticised the format on social media, and the Daily Express reported the result had been spoiled online beforehand.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Strictly Come Dancing held the first three-couple dance-off in its history on its Sunday 1 November results show, following a Halloween-themed live show on Saturday 31 October. The IndependentLC “the dance competition culminated on Sunday in the show’s first ever three-way dance-off.” Read at The Independent ↗ Daily ExpressR “For the first time in Strictly's history, there will be three couples in the dance-off.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2Under the new format the three couples danced again and the judges voted for the couple they wanted to eliminate, rather than the one they wanted to save. The IndependentLC “the judges voted for the couple they wanted to send packing, rather than save.” Read at The Independent ↗ Daily ExpressR “the judges will be choosing who they want to eliminate rather than save” Read at Daily Express ↗ Left · 1Bethany Antonia, Jaime Winstone and Lawrence Robb were in the bottom three, and Emmerdale actor Robb, who dances with Jowita Przystał, was sent home. The Independent reports that all four judges noted his mistakes, while Antonia and Winstone had improved on Saturday. The IndependentLC “Actors Bethany Antonia, Jaime Winstone and Lawrence Robb all found themselves in the bottom three, with Emmerdale star Robb being sent home as all four judges noted how he’d made mistakes” Read at The Independent ↗
Left · 1The Independent says it was Winstone and Carlos Gu's third dance-off, Antonia and Nancy Xu's second, and Robb and Przystał's first. The IndependentLC “The bottom three marked Winstone and her partner Carlos Gu’s third time in the dance-off, while Antonia and Nancy Xu have now been in the dance-off twice.” Read at The Independent ↗ Right · 1The Daily Express reported that the result is pre-recorded the day before broadcast and that a member of the Saturday audience had reportedly revealed it on social media; the Express did not name the source. The Express article does not name the eliminated couple. Daily ExpressR “The result is broadcast on Sunday nights, but it is pre-recorded the day before, following the live episode. A source from the Strictly audience has now reportedly confirmed the spoiler on social media, but Express.co.uk has chosen not to name them.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Right · 1Presenters Emma Willis, Josh Widdicombe and Johannes Radebe announced the change during Saturday's broadcast, with Willis saying there was "a three way dance off on the horizon and you're vote has never mattered more". Daily ExpressR “"There is a three way dance off on the horizon and you're vote has never mattered more."” Read at Daily Express ↗
Mixed · 2Viewers on social media criticised the twist as "ridiculous", "nonsensical", "pointless" and "brutal". Some compared it to The X Factor's elimination style, and one said it did not suit Strictly's historically gentler tone. Others asked what the point was, or suggested two couples should have gone home. Daily ExpressR “Those who waited for the spoiler to be revealed on social media were quick to call out the "ridiculous" new format online.” Read at Daily Express ↗ The IndependentLC “Other viewers pointed out that the twist mirrored the ways The X Factor used to eliminate contestants” Read at The Independent ↗ Daily ExpressR “"Why exactly do we need three couples in the dance off? Let's stop the X Factor-style twists shall we?"” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2Some commenters quoted by the Express said Robb would not have been in the dance-off under the old rules and suggested the twist was designed for that purpose. The Independent notes that viewers called it harsh on Robb and Przystał, who had not been in the bottom two before. The Independent also says Robb, once considered a "ringer" and frontrunner, had been criticised by judges in recent weeks but praised on Saturday. It contacted the BBC for comment. Daily ExpressR “"They would not have been in the dance-off under the normal rules. Likely the twist was designed specifically for this purpose."” Read at Daily Express ↗ The IndependentLC “Robb, who was considered a “ringer” and frontrunner before the series started, had been on the receiving end of criticism from the judges in recent weeks, but had earned their praise on Saturday.”“The Independent has contacted the BBC for comment.” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2The Express's two reports give different numbers of remaining couples (12 in one, 11 in the other) and describe the elimination as the fifth of the series. The show returns on Saturday 7 November at 6.30pm on BBC One. Daily ExpressR “the remaining 12 couples returned to the glamorous ballroom.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Daily ExpressR “the remaining 11 contestants took to the dancefloor once again” Read at Daily Express ↗ The IndependentLC “Strictly Come Dancing continues Saturday 7 November at 6.30pm on BBC One.” Read at The Independent ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- The Independent reports the results-show outcome and viewer reaction, leading with the "brutal" three-way dance-off and its effect on Lawrence Robb and Jowita Przystał.
- Emphasis
- Names the eliminated couple, the judges' reasons, the bottom-three history and the comparison to The X Factor. Says it asked the BBC for comment.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the reported spoiler or that results are pre-recorded.
- Charged language
- “brutal”“nonsensical”“harsh”
- For example
-
“Strictly Come Dancing viewers have hit out at the show over a “harsh” new twist in Sunday (1 November) night’s results show.” — The Independent
“fans shared their frustrations with this “nonsensical” twist” — The Independent
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- The Daily Express runs fan-reaction pieces: one built on a reported leak of the result and viewers calling the twist "ridiculous", and one on the backlash when the format change was announced on Saturday.
- Emphasis
- Social media quotes, the pre-recording and leak, the Halloween routines and music choices, and Sir Ian McKellen's cameo.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not name the eliminated couple, and does not report the judges' reasoning or a BBC response.
- Charged language
- “ridiculous”“slam”“fumed”“spooktacular”
- For example
-
“Strictly Come Dancing fans have branded the fifth elimination of the series "ridiculous" following the dramatic three-couple dance-off.” — Daily Express
“Strictly Come Dancing viewers have reacted with frustration after hosts Emma Willis, Josh Widdicombe and Johannes Radebe announced a major format change.” — Daily Express
What every side reports
- Sunday 1 November's results show had the first three-couple dance-off in Strictly's history.
- Judges chose which couple to eliminate rather than which to save.
- Viewers criticised the format change on social media.
Where accounts differ
-
Number of couples remaining before the dance-off
- Left
- The Independent does not give a count.
- Right
- One Express article says 12 couples returned on Saturday; another says 11 contestants danced.
Left2 articles
-
Strictly Come Dancing fans slam ‘brutal’ three-way dance off twist
Critical Reports the first three-way dance-off result, Robb's exit and viewer criticism of the twist as harsh and X Factor-like.

-

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right2 articles
-
Strictly Come Dancing exit leaked as fans slam 'ridiculous' dance-off twist
Mixed Reports a social media spoiler of the result and amplifies viewer anger at the new dance-off format without naming the couple.

-
Strictly Come Dancing twist faces backlash as fans reel 'what's the point?'
Mixed Covers the on-air announcement of the three-way dance-off and fan frustration, with a routine rundown and a celebrity cameo.

- 1 Nov 08:21 First Daily ExpressR Strictly Come Dancing exit leaked as fans slam 'ridiculous' dance-off twist
- 1 Nov 19:20 +10h 59m Daily ExpressR Strictly Come Dancing twist faces backlash as fans reel 'what's the point?'
- 2 Nov 09:40 +25h 19m The IndependentLC Strictly Come Dancing fans slam ‘brutal’ three-way dance off twist
- 2 Nov 13:18 +28h 57m The IndependentLC Strictly star fires back at viewer over Graeme Hall criticism after he dodges dance off
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…