Entertainment · Strictly Come Dancing season 23
Strictly: Appleton and Dowden out first; Brendan Cole's criticism of Dowden draws backlash
Chris Appleton and Amy Dowden were the first couple eliminated from Strictly 2026 on 4 October, after an Express report that the result had leaked. Coverage then turned to ex-professional Brendan Cole's criticism of Dowden and her widely praised social media reply.
Updated (version 3). New coverage since the last version from BBC News, Daily Mirror. Previously: “Strictly Come Dancing: Chris Appleton first to go after leak reports”.
1 / 7
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Hair stylist Chris Appleton, 43, and his professional partner Amy Dowden became the first couple eliminated from Strictly Come Dancing 2026 on the Sunday 4 October results show. The IndependentLC “Strictly Come Dancing has eliminated its first contestant from the 2026 series: celebrity hair stylist Chris Appleton.” Read at The Independent ↗ Daily ExpressR “Celebrity hairstylist Chris Appleton has become the first celebrity to be eliminated from Strictly Come Dancing.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Right · 1Earlier on Sunday, the Daily Express reported that the first elimination had been leaked on X and that fans were upset. It said it had chosen not to share the information, so the report did not say who had been named. Daily ExpressR “The information, which Express.co.uk has decided not to share, appeared on X, formerly known as Twitter, as fans shared their disappointment.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Right · 1That early report did not say whether the leaked result was accurate. It named Melanie Walters, Chris Appleton and Lawrence Robb as the celebrities 'most in danger' on the leaderboard. Daily ExpressR “The three celebrities most in danger this week were Melanie Walters with Aljaz Skorjanec, Chris Appleton and Dianne Buswell, and Lawrence Robb and Jowita Pryzstal, according to the leaderboard.” Read at Daily Express ↗
Left · 1Appleton and Dowden landed in the dance-off after Saturday's Movie Week show, the first with public voting. Viewers could vote for the first time this series, after a week without public voting. The IndependentLC “After a week without any public voting, everything changed on Saturday night (3 October) when viewers at home were allowed to pick up their phones and cast their votes for the first time this year.” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2The Evening Standard said judges' scores from both live shows were added to Saturday's public vote to decide the two lowest-scoring couples. The Daily Mail instead said Appleton and Winstone had the lowest number of public votes. Evening StandardN “were then combined with the results of Saturday night’s public vote to decide the two lowest-scoring couples who would face the dance-off.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “after it was revealed they both got the lowest number of public votes.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Left · 1They faced actor Jaime Winstone and her partner Carlos Gu. Both couples repeated their Cha Chas. Appleton and Dowden danced to a Baywatch song and Winstone and Gu danced to 'Oh, Pretty Woman'. The IndependentLC “Appleton and his partner performed their Cha Cha to “I’ll Be Ready” from Baywatch, while Winstone and Gu repeated their Cha Cha to Roy Orbison’s “Oh, Pretty Woman” from Pretty Woman.” Read at The Independent ↗
Mixed · 2Shirley Ballas, Motsi Mabuse and Anton Du Beke voted to save Winstone and Gu, so Craig Revel Horwood did not need to use his casting vote. He said he would have voted the same way. The Express reported that all four judges voted to save the pair. The IndependentLC “Head judge Shirley Ballas and judges Motsi Mabuse and Anton Du Beke all voted to save Winstone and Gu, meaning Craig Revel Horwood did not need to use his casting vote.” Read at The Independent ↗ Daily ExpressR “all four judges voted to save Jamie and Carlos as they delivered their final verdicts, ultimately sending the hairstylist home.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Right · 1On Saturday the judges gave Appleton and Dowden 17 points, while Winstone and Gu got 21 out of 40, according to the Express. Daily ExpressR “On Saturday night, the judges awarded them 17 points, but noted that they had made a stark improvement following their second performance.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Centre · 1The Daily Mail and Evening Standard both reported 17 points for Appleton and Dowden's cha cha. The Standard put their first-week tango score at 16 and Winstone and Gu's score at 21. Evening StandardN “He and Dowden had performed a tango on their first week of the contest – receiving a score of 16 from the judges.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Evening StandardN “Winstone and Gu received 21 points for their routine.” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Right · 1In his farewell Appleton said he had felt 'out of my comfort zone' and valued gaining a friend in Dowden. Dowden said she was 'heartbroken' but would gain a 'friend for life'. Daily ExpressR “Amy choked back tears as she reassured Chris that he has a "friend for life"” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2Appleton, whose clients have included Kim Kardashian, Jennifer Lopez and Katy Perry, said he was 'so grateful' to have met Dowden. The Daily Mail noted that Kardashian was the third contestant out of the US Dancing With The Stars in 2008. Evening StandardN “Appleton has worked with stars including Kim Kardashian, Jennifer Lopez, Sofia Vergara, Ariana Grande and Katy Perry.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “Kardashian was the third contestant to be eliminated from the US version of the show” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Left · 1The Independent noted that this is the second year running that Dowden has been in the first couple to leave. Her 2025 partner Thomas Skinner was voted off first. The IndependentLC “The elimination marks the second year that professional Amy Dowden has been in the first couple to leave the dance competition” Read at The Independent ↗
Left · 1The results show also featured a Devil Wears Prada routine from the professionals and a Matilda The Musical performance with composer Tim Minchin. Fourteen couples remain for next Saturday's show on 10 October. The IndependentLC “Next week, the remaining fourteen couples will take to the dance floor to fight to keep their place in the competition.” Read at The Independent ↗ Centre · 2Radio Times said Delta Goodrem led the combined leaderboard on 59, with Appleton on 33 and Melanie Walters on 30. The Evening Standard also reported that presenter Josh Widdicombe spent much of Saturday's show in the balcony area while Emma Willis fronted the floor, after viewer criticism of his debut. Radio TimesN “Delta Goodrem found herself at the top of the leaderboard after her scores from week 1 and week 2 were combined, with a spectacular 59 points.” Read at Radio Times ↗ Evening StandardN “Widdicombe spent much of Saturday's show in the Clauditorium-style balcony area, while Willis fronted the action downstairs.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Right · 1The two Express reports differ on Appleton's partner. The morning report paired him with Dianne Buswell and gave the Baywatch song as 'I’m Always Here'. The evening report and the Independent name Dowden and 'I'll Be Ready'. Daily ExpressR “Chris and Dianne performed the Cha Cha to I’m Always Here from Baywatch” Read at Daily Express ↗ Daily ExpressR “his dance partner, Amy Dowden” Read at Daily Express ↗
Centre · 1Some viewers accused producers of 'setting him up' by placing Appleton's dance at the start of the show and giving him a 'lame' song, according to the Evening Standard, which quoted posts on X such as 'The whole show is fixed'. Evening StandardN “Viewers shared their dismay over Appleton’s exit, with some accusing producers of “setting him up” by placing him at the start of the show and giving him a “lame” song.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Mixed · 2On It Takes Two, Dowden and Appleton became emotional; Dowden said she was 'gutted' and thought 'there was so much more to come'. The Daily Express reported that the couple's appearance together came after viewers complained that the companion show no longer interviewed pros and celebrities together. BBC NewsN “I honestly think there was so much more to come.” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily ExpressR “as the pair joined It Takes Two to discuss being the first couple to be voted off in the 2026 series.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2On Wednesday 7 October, former Strictly professional Brendan Cole (on the show 2004–2017) told Sky Vegas that Dowden 'has not been up to the challenge, in my opinion', adding: 'I don't think Amy's been doing a very good job for the last few years and she's been out first for the last few years. One can do the maths on that.' Daily MailR “'I don't think Amy's been doing a very good job for the last few years and she's been out first for the last few years. One can do the maths on that.'” Read at Daily Mail ↗ BBC NewsN “"To be a pro on Strictly is a big job and one has to be up to the challenge," Cole reportedly told Sky Vegas” Read at BBC News ↗
Mixed · 2Cole also said he could see Dowden 'counting in' her celebrity partners, which he took as a sign that 'the job has not been done'. The Daily Mail noted that the comments came despite Dowden returning to the show after her breast cancer treatment. BBC NewsN “He also claimed he could see Dowden "counting in" her partners, a sign to him that the "job has not been done".” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily MailR “despite bravely returning to the show after her battle with cancer.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2Dowden did not reply directly. On Saturday 10 October, shortly before the live show, she posted an Instagram video of herself blowing a kiss and miming the opening line of Mariah Carey's 'Obsessed' ('Why are you so obsessed with me?'), captioned 'If you know, you know' with the hashtag #bekind. The IndependentLC “The dancer shared a video on Instagram in which she blew a kiss to the camera and lip synced to the opening lines of Mariah Carey’s 2009 track “Obsessed”” Read at The Independent ↗ BBC NewsN “"If you know, you know", a cryptic caption read, along with hashtags reading "be kind"” Read at BBC News ↗ Mixed · 2The post was widely praised by fans and by current and former Strictly figures, including Aljaž Škorjanec, Dianne Buswell, Kevin Clifton, Carlos Gu, Bethany Antonia and Sarah Hadland. Appleton commented 'Love you'. BBC NewsN “Current and former Strictly stars also showed their support, including Aljaž Škorjanec, Dianne Buswell, Kevin Clifton and Carlos Gu, while Appleton added: "Love you."” Read at BBC News ↗ The IndependentLC “Strictly 2026 contestant and House of the Dragon star Bethany Antonia wrote: “You’re incredible. This is iconic and we all ❤️ you.”” Read at The Independent ↗
Right · 1On Sunday 11 October the Daily Mail reported that Dowden and Appleton had reunited on Instagram to recreate the Dirty Dancing lift, with Appleton writing 'Amy I’ve had the time of my life'. Daily MailR “He then captioned the post: 'Couldn’t hang up my dancing shoes without attempting THAT lift. Amy I’ve had the time of my life.'” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Centre · 1Strictly returns on BBC One and iPlayer at 18:15 BST on Saturday 17 October. BBC NewsN “Strictly Come Dancing returns to iPlayer and BBC One from 18:15 BST on Saturday 17 October.” Read at BBC News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- The Independent ran the results straight, then a supportive follow-up on Dowden's 'perfect' reply to Cole.
- Emphasis
- Dowden's repeat first exit, her reply to Cole and the praise from Strictly colleagues and fans.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the pre-broadcast leak report.
- For example
-
“Dowden, however, didn’t seem bothered by Cole’s comments as she shared a cheerful clapback on social media” — The Independent
Centre3 outlets
- Framing
- Radio Times, the Evening Standard and BBC News gave factual results coverage, then reported the Cole row and Dowden's reply.
- Emphasis
- Scores, judges' quotes, viewer 'set-up' claims, Dowden's reply and her cancer history.
- Leaves out or plays down
- None mentions the pre-broadcast leak; BBC says Cole 'reportedly' made the remarks.
- For example
-
“Amy Dowden praised for 'iconic' clapback at ex-Strictly professional dancer” — BBC News
“Viewers shared their dismay over Appleton’s exit” — Evening Standard
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Daily Mail and Express ran many follow-ups: fan reaction, Cole's criticism set against Dowden's cancer history, and the reunion posts.
- Emphasis
- Cancer battle, fan outrage at Cole, Instagram posts, format complaints.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The Mail does not mention the leak report.
- Charged language
- “bitter man”“hated Strictly Come Dancing format change”
- For example
-
“Brendan's comments will no doubt cause controversy” — Daily Mail
“BBC makes hated Strictly Come Dancing format change after Amy Dowden exit” — Daily Express
What every side reports
- Chris Appleton, 43, was the first celebrity eliminated from Strictly 2026.
- He lost a dance-off against Jaime Winstone and Carlos Gu.
- Appleton's partner was Amy Dowden.
- The results show aired on Sunday 4 October.
Where accounts differ
-
Appleton's partner and Baywatch song in the Express's early leak report
- Left
- The Independent named Amy Dowden and 'I’ll Be Ready' and did not mention a leak.
- Right
- The Express's morning report named Dianne Buswell as Appleton's partner and the song as 'I’m Always Here'. Its evening report named Amy Dowden and 'I'll Be Ready'.
-
Chris Appleton and Amy Dowden were eliminated first from Strictly 2026 after losing the dance-off to Jaime Winstone and Carlos Gu.
Reported- Reports 3
- Evening Standard, Radio Times, Daily Mail
-
The judges voted three to nil to save Winstone and Gu, so Revel Horwood's casting vote was not needed.
Reported- Reports 3
- Evening Standard, Radio Times, Daily Mail
-
Amy Dowden has not been up to the challenge of being a Strictly professional.
Reported- Reports 3
- The Independent, BBC News, Daily Mail
-
Amy Dowden answered Brendan Cole's criticism indirectly, with an Instagram video miming Mariah Carey's 'Obsessed', and was praised for it.
Reported- Reports 3
- The Independent, BBC News, Daily Mail
Left5 articles
-
First celebrity eliminated from Strictly Come Dancing 2026
Neutral Factual results report with judges' votes, entertainment and background on Appleton and Dowden.

-

-

-
Strictly Come Dancing’s Amy Dowden praised for ‘perfect’ response to Brendan Cole’s criticism
Sympathetic The Independent presents Dowden's response as cheerful and well received.

Centre7 articles
-
Who left Strictly 2026? First celebrity to be voted out revealed
Neutral Spoiler-flagged results explainer with leaderboard and schedule details.

-
Who was axed in the first Strictly dance off?
Neutral Results report with judges' verbatim reasons and hosting side-note.

-
First couple eliminated from Strictly Come Dancing
Sympathetic Detailed results report centred on farewell quotes and Dowden's tribute.

-
Chris Appleton breaks silence on Strictly Come Dancing exit after 'set-up' claims
Neutral Evening Standard covers viewer 'set-up' claims alongside the results, scores and farewell quotes.

Show 3 moreShow fewer
-

-
-
Amy Dowden praised for 'iconic' clapback at ex-Strictly professional dancer
Sympathetic BBC News reports Dowden's 'iconic' reply to Cole, with colleagues' support and her cancer background.

Right17 articles
-
Strictly Come Dancing's first axe leaked and fans are devastated
Alarmist Reports a leaked elimination result through fans' upset posts on X, without naming who was leaked.

-
First Strictly Come Dancing 2026 couple axed in tearful farewell speech
Sympathetic Emotional account of the elimination built around the farewell speeches and fan sympathy for Dowden.

-
Mixed Celebrity-led report with puns and focus on Dowden's misfortune alongside judges' critique.

-

Show 13 moreShow fewer
-

-

-

-
BBC makes hated Strictly Come Dancing format change after Amy Dowden exit
Mixed Daily Express ties the exit to viewer complaints about It Takes Two's format.

-

-
Mixed Daily Mail relays Cole's remarks while stressing Dowden's cancer recovery and predicting controversy.

-

-

-

-
Sympathetic Daily Mail shows Appleton backing Dowden with a Dirty Dancing reunion after Cole's criticism.

-

-

-

- 4 Oct 08:49 First Daily ExpressR Strictly Come Dancing's first axe leaked and fans are devastated
- 4 Oct 19:55 +11h 6m Daily ExpressR First Strictly Come Dancing 2026 couple axed in tearful farewell speech
- 4 Oct 20:00 +11h 11m The IndependentLC First celebrity eliminated from Strictly Come Dancing 2026
- 4 Oct 20:00 +11h 12m Radio TimesN Who left Strictly 2026? First celebrity to be voted out revealed
- 4 Oct 20:07 +11h 18m Evening StandardN Who was axed in the first Strictly dance off?
- 4 Oct 20:13 +11h 24m Evening StandardN First couple eliminated from Strictly Come Dancing
- 4 Oct 20:30 +11h 41m Daily MailR Strictly 2026 first elimination: Chris Appleton crushes Amy Dowden's comeback hopes and falls short of pal Kim Kardashian's Dancing With The Stars success as he loses dance off
- 4 Oct 21:26 +12h 37m Daily MirrorL Strictly's Amy Dowden says 'I know heartbreak only too well' in sad post after Chris Appleton axe
- 5 Oct 08:51 +24h 2m Daily ExpressR Do you agree with the Strictly elimination result?
- 5 Oct 10:39 +25h 51m Daily MailR Strictly pro Amy Dowden says she's 'heartbroken' as she and Chris Appleton become the first pair to be voted off
- 5 Oct 11:30 +26h 41m Evening StandardN Chris Appleton breaks silence on Strictly Come Dancing exit after 'set-up' claims
- 5 Oct 14:10 +29h 21m Daily ExpressR 'I spotted Chris Appleton mistake which saw him become first Strictly star axed'
- 5 Oct 14:49 +30h Daily ExpressR Strictly fans concerned for Amy Dowden after axe and say she 'deserves better'
- 6 Oct 10:05 +49h 17m The IndependentLC Strictly pro Amy Dowden says she’s ‘gutted’ after becoming the first to be eliminated
- 6 Oct 12:30 +51h 41m Daily ExpressR BBC makes hated Strictly Come Dancing format change after Amy Dowden exit
- 7 Oct 08:52 +72h 3m Daily ExpressR Strictly pro gives blunt response to Amy Dowden and Chris Appleton after emotional exit
- 7 Oct 09:40 +72h 52m Daily MailR Ex Strictly pro Brendan Cole claims Amy Dowden 'hasn't been doing a very good job' after returning to the show following cancer battle
- 7 Oct 10:11 +73h 23m Evening StandardN 'Not doing a good job': Ex-Strictly dancer delivers brutal critique of Amy Dowden
- 7 Oct 16:43 +79h 54m Daily MailR Strictly pro Amy Dowden posts cryptic quote after Brendan Cole claimed she 'hasn't been doing a very good job' on show post-cancer battle
- 8 Oct 11:50 +99h 1m Daily ExpressR Strictly fans vote for who really should have left 'Such an easy first celeb to go'
- 8 Oct 15:45 +102h 56m Evening StandardN Chris Appleton says Strictly was ‘never about winning’ and gave him ‘a whole new lease of life’
- 11 Oct 08:50 +168h 1m Daily MailR Amy Dowden praised for 'iconic' response to Brendan Cole's criticism of her Strictly skills following her cancer battle
- 11 Oct 10:43 +169h 55m The IndependentLC Strictly Come Dancing’s Amy Dowden praised for ‘perfect’ response to Brendan Cole’s criticism
- 11 Oct 20:58 +180h 9m Daily MailR Amy Dowden is supported by her Strictly partner Chris Appleton as they reunite to recreate iconic Dirty Dancing lift after she hit back at Brendan Cole's criticism of her Strictly skills
- 12 Oct 12:27 +195h 39m BBC NewsN Amy Dowden praised for 'iconic' clapback at ex-Strictly professional dancer
- 14 Oct 12:56 +244h 7m Daily ExpressR Strictly Come Dancing's Amy Dowden fires back at 'unkind' criticism after major exit
- 17 Oct 10:00 +313h 11m Daily MirrorL Strictly's Amy Dowden gives unexpected response to Brendan Cole's brutal criticism of her
- 17 Oct 11:00 +314h 11m Daily ExpressR Strictly's Amy Dowden speaks out on ‘brutal’ remark from colleague during cancer battle
- 17 Oct 11:18 +314h 30m Daily MailR Ex Strictly pro Brendan Cole 'gutted' by backlash to his critique of Amy Dowden's skills: 'He's quite upset about the whole thing':
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…
