Harvard-Dartmouth study: school phone bans modestly improve learning
A Harvard, Dartmouth and NWEA study of 3.3 million US students found in-school phone bans modestly improve learning. Researcher Tom Kane wants to use Meta's settlement to study out-of-school phone use.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2A new nationwide US study found that in-school cellphone bans can lead to modest improvements in learning. The VergeLC “A new nationwide study found that in-school cellphone bans can lead to modest improvements in learning.” Read at The Verge ↗ CBS NewsLC “Cellphone bans in schools help academic performance, a Harvard University study shows.” Read at CBS News ↗ Left · 1The study was carried out by researchers from Harvard University and Dartmouth College in partnership with the assessment group NWEA. It analysed testing data from 3.3 million students across 4,600 schools between the 2021–22 and 2025–26 school years, including schools with and without bans. The VergeLC “carried out by researchers from Harvard University and Dartmouth College in partnership with academic assessment group NWEA”“analyzed testing data from 3.3 million students across 4,600 schools between the 2021–22 school year and 2025–26” Read at The Verge ↗ Left · 1The effect of a ban is equivalent to adding one to two weeks of school to the academic year, which accounts for about half of the learning loss US students experienced between 2013 and the 2020 covid-19 pandemic. The VergeLC “has the equivalent effect of adding one to two weeks of school to the academic year, accounting for about half of the learning loss students experienced in the US between 2013 and the 2020 covid-19 pandemic” Read at The Verge ↗
Left · 1Earlier studies, many of them outside the US, also found positive effects, and a previous nationwide US study used school-level averages. This one used student-level data, which the researchers said let them control for more factors and observe effects on students with the most and least learning loss. The VergeLC “many of them examined schools outside the US. An earlier nationwide US study looked at academic outcomes based on averages within schools, whereas this latest study looked at student-level data” Read at The Verge ↗ Left · 1The researchers found bans to be cost-effective: lockable pouches for a class of 17 students would cost an estimated $425 per teacher, against $2,080 to pay an average teacher's salary for an extra week. The VergeLC “purchasing lockable pouches for a class of 17 students would cost an estimated $425 per teacher, the researchers found, paying an average teacher’s salary for an extra week would be $2,080.” Read at The Verge ↗ Left · 1Tom Kane, faculty director of Harvard's Center for Education Policy Research, said he was surprised that bans had similar effects across age groups and found no big difference across achievement levels. He said he had earlier blamed learning loss on a de-emphasis of test-based accountability, but changed his mind after seeing similar losses outside the US. The VergeLC “the in-school bans had similar effects on learning gains for students across different age groups”“he changed his mind after seeing that kids outside the US were also experiencing learning loss” Read at The Verge ↗
Left · 1Kane suggests out-of-school phone use may explain some of the remaining learning loss, but testing that is hard because no equivalent ban exists. He sees a chance in Meta's $17.1 billion settlement with nearly every US state, under which Meta agreed to restrict users under 18, including default time limits, with many restrictions expected to take effect within months. The VergeLC “as part of a $17.1 billion settlement with nearly every US state, Meta agreed to implement sweeping restrictions on users under 18”“out-of-school phone use could account for some of the remaining learning loss across the board” Read at The Verge ↗ Left · 1Kane noted limitations: the settlement gives no easy way to tell whether teens use Meta's platforms less or have shifted to other apps, and researchers would need to link restrictions to school achievement. He suggested similar deals with TikTok and YouTube, which have so far declined, and de-identified, aggregated data from platforms could help. The VergeLC “The settlement doesn’t offer an easy way to tell whether teens are in fact using Meta’s platforms less”“TikTok and YouTube, which so far have declined to implement such restrictions” Read at The Verge ↗ Left · 1CBS News ran a segment in which Kane explained the study's key takeaways. CBS NewsLC “Tom Kane, the study's co-author, explains key takeaways from his data.” Read at CBS News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets present the study as evidence that bans help; The Verge adds a policy angle on using Meta's settlement to study out-of-school phone use.
- Emphasis
- Effect size, cost-effectiveness, and Kane's call for further research.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither outlet quotes independent critics or discusses limits of the observational design.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- A Harvard-led study found school cellphone bans improve learning.
- Tom Kane is a co-author of the study.
Left2 articles
-
Banning phones really does help kids learn, researchers say
Sympathetic Presents the findings and Kane's views largely on his terms, with the headline stating bans 'really' help.

-
School cellphone bans improve learning, Harvard study finds
Neutral Short video segment headline presenting the Harvard finding with Kane explaining takeaways.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 17 Nov 16:13 First The VergeLC Banning phones really does help kids learn, researchers say
- 18 Nov 14:55 +22h 43m CBS NewsLC School cellphone bans improve learning, Harvard study finds
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…