Skip to content
Bramble

Climate

Study: US hyperscale data centers emit about as much CO2 as Denmark each year

A peer-reviewed Harvard-led study in Nature Sustainability estimates that 403 US hyperscale data centers emitted 25.7 million tonnes of CO2 in the year to April 2025, comparable to Denmark's annual emissions.

3 outlets · 1L · 1C · 1R First reported Account updated

Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from IJR.

Image: The Guardian
Image: CNA
Image: IJR

1 / 3

The story, neutrally told

Mixed · 2A peer-reviewed study published in Nature Sustainability on Monday 16 November found that the 403 hyperscale data centers operating in the US emitted about 25.7 million tonnes of carbon dioxide in a year, roughly what Denmark emits annually. Mixed · 2The study covers May 2024 to April 2025 and used federal government data; it was led by Gianluca Guidi, a Harvard researcher on AI and public health, with Harvard biostatistics professor Francesca Dominici as co-author. Mixed · 2The emissions are two to three times higher than a previous estimate for 2018, which CNA describes as the last peer-reviewed measurement of data center emissions.

Left · 1The Guardian reports that the facilities were responsible for about 1.8% of total US electricity consumption and used 68 to 99 terawatt-hours of electricity over the year. Mixed · 2Virginia, Oregon, Ohio and Iowa account for over half of the electricity use studied. According to the Guardian, more than half of the generation came from fossil fuels, while CNA says most of the data centers were powered by gas. Left · 1Dominici said the figure should be treated as a lower bound because many more data centers have been built since April 2025, and called for policymakers to consider how to proceed responsibly.

Right · 1IJR, which describes the study as Harvard-led, likewise calls the figures a conservative baseline and adds that limited public tracking and operator disclosures make data center energy use and emissions hard to monitor. Centre · 1Guidi said the aim is to bring transparency and data to the debate over data centers and AI, and that the team built a scientifically accepted methodology to build public trust. Left · 1Gina McCarthy, a former climate adviser to Joe Biden's administration, called the study an important step in assessing data center impacts and said she was not surprised that most hyperscale data centers rely on fossil fuels.

Centre · 1The findings come amid public backlash against data centers in the US. CNA says critics who campaigned for construction moratoria or tighter regulation were among the biggest winners of the Democrats' landslide victories in the 3 November midterm elections. Left · 1The Guardian adds that developers have defended the facilities' energy and water use as marginal compared with other industries and have pointed to jobs and local tax revenue, while Donald Trump has said opponents will end up "backwards and poor". It also cites local opposition to Elon Musk's Memphis-area facilities and to the planned Stratos project in Utah, where a separate NRDC-commissioned study estimated health costs of up to $690m a year if the dirtiest fuel option were used. Right · 1IJR closes by saying the findings raise concerns about grid strain, additional fossil-fuel generation and local environmental impacts, and notes a voluntary COP31 pledge calling for cleaner energy and greater transparency in the sector.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left1 outlet

Framing
Leads with the climate impact of a 'frantic buildout' of data centers, adds the researchers' view that the figure is a lower bound, and places the study within wider opposition to data centers, including Stratos in Utah and Musk's Memphis facilities.
Emphasis
Fossil-fuel dependence, gas plants built on site, health and air-pollution costs, and quotes from climate advocates and a former Biden adviser.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not mention the 3 November midterm election results or Guidi's remarks on transparency.
Charged language
“frantic buildout”“planet-heating”“dirtier sources of power”
For example
“The frantic buildout of “hyperscaler” datacenters in the US has collectively caused planet-heating emissions of about the same scale as Denmark emits in a year” — The Guardian

Centre1 outlet

Framing
Short, bulleted news report on the study, tied to the political backlash and the midterm elections.
Emphasis
The study's methodology and transparency aims, the regional concentration of electricity use, and the electoral success of data center critics.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not give the electricity totals, the 1.8% share of US consumption, the lower-bound caveat, or the reaction from climate figures and developers.
For example
“data center critics who ran on policies such as moratoria on construction or strengthening regulations were among the biggest winners of the Democrats' landslide victories.” — CNA

Right1 outlet

Framing
Brief, data-led summary of the study's headline numbers under a headline naming Harvard and the 25.7 million tonne figure, closing on grid strain and a voluntary COP31 pledge.
Emphasis
Electricity use (68–99 TWh, about 1.8% of national consumption, 'comparable to a major state'), the share from fossil fuels, the lower-bound caveat and weak public disclosure.
Leaves out or plays down
No quotes from named researchers or outside figures, no mention of the midterm backlash, developers' defences, Trump's remarks or specific local fights such as Stratos or Memphis.
Charged language
“conservative baseline”
For example
“about 1.8% of national consumption and comparable to the power use of a major state.” — IJR

Ask about this story

Loading…