Jailed suspect says Monaco bombing of Vadym Yermolayev was proposed by HUR-linked officer
Vitalii Zhykovych, jailed in Kyiv over the murder of the Monaco bombing suspect, told the BBC the June attack on Vadym Yermolayev was proposed by Vladyslav Reut, who he says cited approval from Ukrainian military intelligence (HUR). He denies planting the bomb or killing Anastasia Berezovska; Reut blames him for her killing.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 1Vitalii Zhykovych, a former Ukrainian security services officer held in a Kyiv prison, has given the BBC his first account of the June bomb attack in Monaco that targeted the Ukrainian-born businessman Vadym Yermolayev. BBC NewsN “In an exclusive interview with the BBC from prison in Kyiv, facilitated by his lawyer, Vitalii Zhykovych has given his own account of the attempted assassination for the first time.” Read at BBC News ↗ Mixed · 2Zhykovych says he believed the attack was ordered by senior members of HUR, Ukraine's military intelligence agency, and that Vladyslav Reut, an active-duty HUR officer whom he calls "The Boss", proposed the operation and told him it had been approved by Reut's superiors. BBC NewsN “"As Reut informed me, this operation […] had been authorised and approved by Reut's superiors, who served in the Main Intelligence Directorate of the Ministry of Defence [HUR]," he says.” Read at BBC News ↗ The IndependentLC “Mr Zhykovych told the BBC in an interview that Mr Reut, who was his “the boss”, had proposed the operation in Monaco against the oligarch.” Read at The Independent ↗ Centre · 1Yermolayev and his 13-year-old son were badly hurt in the blast and his partner suffered catastrophic injuries; surveillance video shows Berezovska leaving the device in a bag on the family's doorstep as they returned from a meal. BBC NewsN “Ukrainian-born businessman Vadym Yermolayev and his 13-year-old son were badly hurt in the blast and his partner suffered catastrophic injuries.”“A surveillance video shows Berezovska walking slightly in front of the group, then leaving the device in a bag on their doorstep.” Read at BBC News ↗
Centre · 1Anastasia Berezovska, the woman filmed planting the bomb, had her image circulated by Interpol on 2 July; a week after the bombing her body was found in woods west of Kyiv with gunshot wounds to the head. BBC NewsN “Berezovska was quickly identified as the suspected bomber and on 2 July her image, taken from CCTV footage, was circulated by Interpol.”“A week after the bombing, Berezovska's body was discovered in the woods west of Kyiv with gunshot wounds to the head.” Read at BBC News ↗ Mixed · 2Zhykovych and Reut were arrested and accused of her murder. Reut first confessed and led investigators to the grave, but later told a court that Zhykovych fired the shots; Zhykovych denies this, and each blames the other. BBC NewsN “Reut initially confessed to investigators, and led them to the shallow grave. But days later in court, he changed his testimony to blame Zhykovych.” Read at BBC News ↗ The IndependentLC ““Zhykovych fired the first shot at her in the back of the head. She fell down. He came up and fired another shot. I was standing a few metres away at that moment,” Mr Reut told the judge.” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2Zhykovych describes himself as a "freelancer" for the SBU and Berezovska as his "agent". He says Reut wanted to use her for the bombing, that he refused because she was not fully trained, and that Reut sent her on reconnaissance instead, then dealt with her directly and supplied the explosives. BBC NewsN “Zhykovych describes himself as a "freelancer" for Ukraine's SBU security service and says Anastasia Berezovska, the woman caught on camera planting the bomb in Monaco, was his "agent".” Read at BBC News ↗ The IndependentLC “Mr Zhykovych claimed that Mr Reut had wanted to use Berezovska to carry out the bombing but agreed to send her on a reconnaissance mission instead after he objected” Read at The Independent ↗
Mixed · 2He says Reut told him the bombing was retaliation for Yermolayev "funding the annexation of Crimea", which he took to mean taxes paid to Russia from businesses in occupied Crimea. Yermolayev has repeatedly denied any remaining business interests linked to Russia. BBC NewsN “He alleges that Reut told him the bombing was in retaliation for "funding the annexation of Crimea"” Read at BBC News ↗ The IndependentLC “Mr Yermolayev has denied business interests linked to Russia.” Read at The Independent ↗ Left · 1The Independent adds that Yermolayev, 58, renounced Ukrainian citizenship in 2017, is now solely Cypriot, and was sanctioned by Kyiv for alleged collaboration with Russia, which he denies; the SBU said he traded alcohol in occupied Crimea and paid millions in taxes to Russia. The IndependentLC “Mr Yermolayev, who was born and raised in the central Ukrainian city of Dnipro, renounced his Ukrainian citizenship in 2017 and is now solely a Cypriot citizen.”“Ukraine’s SBU security agency said he had been trading alcohol in Russian-occupied Crimea and had paid millions in taxes to the Russian treasury, leading to his assets being frozen.” Read at The Independent ↗ Centre · 1At a recent custody hearing Zhykovych said Reut had told him the Monaco attack was not "authorised" and that "someone had ordered this target from the civilian side", before the judge interrupted. He also said Reut originally spoke of two targets; the BBC says other sources suggest the second was a pro-Russian blogger convicted in absentia of treason. BBC NewsN “"Someone had ordered this target from the civilian side," Zhykovych said, without explaining.”“Other sources strongly suggest it was a pro-Russian blogger tried and convicted in absentia last year by Ukraine of treason.” Read at BBC News ↗
Centre · 1Berezovska's husband told the BBC that Zhykovych's claim she was a double-agent was "nonsense" and that he believes she was unwittingly dragged in. Zhykovych says she told him Reut had promised her $50,000. BBC NewsN “Berezovska's husband has told the BBC that the allegation was "nonsense". He believes she was dragged, unwittingly, into the whole affair.”“"$50,000 doesn't just lie on the streets," she supposedly explained.” Read at BBC News ↗ Mixed · 2HUR did not comment on the latest claims but has said it is "committed to a full investigation"; the SBU has described Zhykovych only as a "former law enforcement officer". Zhykovych's lawyer told CNN in August that his client believed he was on a secret intelligence mission, which Ukrainian officials denied. BBC NewsN “The SBU has described Zhykovych in a statement only as a "former law enforcement officer".” Read at BBC News ↗ The IndependentLC “Mr Zhykovych’s lawyer Anatoliy Ivanov told CNN in August his client believed he was working on a secret mission for the Ukrainian intelligence services. Ukrainian officials have denied the claim.” Read at The Independent ↗ Centre · 1Whether the attack was state-ordered, a rogue operation or criminal score-settling remains unresolved; Yermolayev has dismissed theories including a link to Ukrainian scam call-centres, where his son Artur was convicted in Estonia of fraud. BBC NewsN “whether this could have been a state-ordered assassination attempt, a rogue operation or some kind of criminal score-settling.”“Earlier this year, a court in Estonia convicted Yermolayev's son, Artur, of defrauding its citizens out of millions of euros through such "offisy"” Read at BBC News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Follow-up summarising the BBC interview, headlined on the suspect revealing who proposed the bombing, with added background.
- Emphasis
- Reut's court testimony on the shooting, Yermolayev's sanctions and SBU allegations, and the lawyer's earlier CNN claim.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Leaves out the custody-hearing 'civilian side' remark, the second target, Berezovska's husband's response and the scam call-centre theory.
- Charged language
- “oligarch”“cold-blooded murder”
- For example
-
“Suspect in Kyiv jail reveals who proposed bombing of oligarch in Monaco” — The Independent
“Mr Reut has told the court that Mr Zhykovych was responsible for the cold-blooded murder of the woman” — The Independent
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Exclusive interview led by the BBC's own reporting, presenting Zhykovych's account alongside rebuttals and unresolved questions.
- Emphasis
- Zhykovych's allegations against Reut and HUR, the murky motives, his court remark about a civilian-side order, and the Berezovska family's doubts.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not give Yermolayev's age or the SBU's sanctions allegations against him.
- Charged language
- “breaks silence”“murkier”
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Zhykovych told the BBC from a Kyiv prison that Reut proposed the Monaco operation and cited approval from HUR superiors.
- Zhykovych denies planting the bomb or killing Berezovska; Reut blames Zhykovych for her shooting.
- HUR says it is committed to a full investigation and has not commented on the latest claims.
- Yermolayev denies business interests linked to Russia.
Where accounts differ
-
Who shot Anastasia Berezovska
- Left
- The Independent quotes Reut telling the court Zhykovych fired both shots; Zhykovych denies killing her.
- Centre
- BBC: each of Reut and Zhykovych blames the other.
-
Attack's origin and whether Berezovska was a willing agent
- Left
- The Independent reports Zhykovych's HUR-authorisation claim and notes Ukrainian officials denied his lawyer's earlier claim of a secret mission.
- Centre
- BBC: Zhykovych says HUR superiors approved it but later told a court it was not 'authorised' and was ordered 'from the civilian side'; her husband calls the double-agent claim 'nonsense'.
Vitalii Zhykovych person
Says he was a freelancer for the SBU, that Reut proposed and supplied the bombing with claimed HUR approval, and that he neither sent Berezovska to kill nor killed her.
“But Zhykovych insists he did not send her to kill, and nor did he kill her.” — BBC News
Vadym Yermolayev person
Calls survival a miracle, says serving HUR officers were linked to the attack, demands justice, and denies Russia-linked business interests.
“He called for "the truth, protection, and justice".” — BBC News
“Mr Yermolayev has denied business interests linked to Russia.” — The Independent
Left1 article
-
Suspect in Kyiv jail reveals who proposed bombing of oligarch in Monaco
Neutral Condensed follow-up on the BBC interview, adding Reut's testimony and Yermolayev's background.
Centre1 article
-
Suspect linked to Monaco bomb attack on millionaire breaks silence to BBC
Neutral Exclusive interview reporting that sets out Zhykovych's claims alongside counter-voices and open questions.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 9 Oct 00:11 First BBC NewsN Suspect linked to Monaco bomb attack on millionaire breaks silence to BBC
- 9 Oct 12:03 +11h 52m The IndependentLC Suspect in Kyiv jail reveals who proposed bombing of oligarch in Monaco
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.