Synchron pauses trials of second-generation brain implant, says issue is not safety-related
Brooklyn-based Synchron has paused enrollment in trials of its second-generation wireless Stentrode brain implant after a performance issue with a cable. The company says it is not a safety problem and it is restructuring.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Synchron, a Brooklyn-based brain-computer interface startup, has paused enrollment in clinical trials of its second-generation Stentrode implant. WiredLC “Those sites have recently paused enrollment, however, because the device is not working as intended” Read at Wired ↗ STATN “Synchron has paused clinical trials of its second-generation brain-computer interface.” Read at STAT ↗ Left · 1Wired, citing anonymous sources familiar with the trials, reported that the device was not working as intended; Synchron told Wired it voluntarily paused enrollment after identifying a performance issue involving the lead, the cable that carries signals from the Stentrode to the implanted electronics. WiredLC “after identifying a performance issue involving the lead, the cable that carries signals from the Stentrode to the implanted electronics.” Read at Wired ↗ Mixed · 2The company said the issue does not involve the Stentrode itself, that no device safety issues have been identified, and that the pause was a company decision, not an FDA-directed action. WiredLC “The pause was a company decision, not an FDA-directed action,” Read at Wired ↗ STATN “The pause is not safety related, leaders said.” Read at STAT ↗
Left · 1Synchron says it has brought lead design and manufacturing in-house, and rather than fixing the lead alone it is upgrading the whole Stentrode system and will resume enrollment once the hardware upgrades are complete. WiredLC “Instead of fixing the lead alone, Synchron says it is upgrading the whole Stentrode system and will resume trial enrollment once the hardware upgrades are complete.” Read at Wired ↗ Left · 1Two of the five US trial sites Wired could reach confirmed recruitment is on hold; a coordinator at one said the pause was not safety-related and was because Synchron was checking that the device delivers the readouts it wants. WiredLC “Two of the five US trial sites that WIRED was able to reach confirmed that recruitment is on hold at those locations.” Read at Wired ↗ Left · 1The second-generation device has fewer electrodes and is fully wireless via Bluetooth; the multisite US trial, with sister sites in Australia and Canada, began this spring and some participants have already been implanted. Synchron says it will keep supporting participants with Stentrode devices across their lifetime. WiredLC “Synchron’s second-generation device has fewer electrodes and is fully wireless, using Bluetooth to connect.”“We will continue to support participants with Stentrode devices across their lifetime.” Read at Wired ↗
Left · 1The trials are a step toward a larger pivotal trial needed for FDA marketing approval, and CEO Tom Oxley said the company still has strong confidence the Stentrode could be a first-line therapy. WiredLC ““We still have strong confidence that it has the potential to be a first-line therapy,” CEO Tom Oxley says of the Stentrode.” Read at Wired ↗ Mixed · 2Synchron is also restructuring: it is eliminating jobs and scaling back in New York while building a San Diego team to design and manufacture the upgraded lead and Stentrode and a separate, not yet revealed device. WiredLC “is also undergoing a restructuring, which includes eliminating jobs and scaling back its footprint in New York” Read at Wired ↗ STATN “Synchron will also eliminate jobs in New York City and is working to develop a new device, WIRED reported.” Read at STAT ↗ Centre · 1STAT called it the first major hiccup for Synchron and linked it to a comment Oxley made on a New York panel last week, that "it just takes a delayed one to slow down your submission to the FDA" and that the company was caught up on one particular component. STATN ““There are hundreds of components in our system, and it just takes a delayed one to slow down your submission to the FDA,”” Read at STAT ↗
Left · 1The first-generation Stentrode, which used an external wire on the chest, was implanted in ten volunteers in the US and Australia, who used it to send emails, browse and bank online with their thoughts. Synchron, valued at nearly $1 billion after a $200 million round last fall, is backed by Khosla Ventures and the venture firms of Bill Gates and Jeff Bezos. WiredLC “Ten volunteers across the US and Australia received that device”“Synchron was estimated to have a nearly $1 billion valuation after closing a $200 million funding round last fall.” Read at Wired ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Leads with the device failing to perform, built on anonymous sources plus company statement, and presents the pause as a setback for the field.
- Emphasis
- Technical detail of the lead, site confirmations, restructuring, competitor Neuralink's earlier problems and field valuations.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Oxley's recent panel remark about a delayed component.
- Charged language
- “failed to perform”“setback”
- For example
-
“Synchron’s setback shows just how far the field still has to go before these systems are commercially available for patients.” — Wired
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- A short newsletter item relaying Wired's reporting, stressing the pause is not safety related and is a 'hiccup'.
- Emphasis
- Reassurance on safety and Oxley's earlier cryptic comment about a delayed component.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the lead cable detail, anonymous sources' claim the device was not working as intended, and the in-house manufacturing change.
- Charged language
- “hiccup”
- For example
-
“It’s the first major hiccup for Synchron, one of the leading companies in a fast-growing industry” — STAT
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Synchron has paused trials of its second-generation wireless brain implant.
- Synchron says the pause is not safety-related.
- Synchron is cutting jobs in New York and developing a new device.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether the implant 'failed' or the pause is merely a component delay
- Left
- Wired says the device 'is not working as intended' per anonymous sources and calls it a 'setback'; the company cites a lead performance issue.
- Centre
- STAT says the pause is not safety related and ties it to a delayed component slowing the FDA submission, calling it a 'hiccup'.
Synchron organisation
Says it voluntarily paused enrollment over a lead performance issue, not a safety or Stentrode issue, will upgrade the system and resume, and remains committed to participants.
“The issue does not involve the Stentrode itself and no safety issues related to the device have been identified.” — Wired
Left1 article
-
WiredLC ·
Synchron Pauses Trials of Its Brain Implant Due to Performance Issues
Mixed Investigative report on a device not performing, balancing company statements with anonymous sources and field context.

Centre1 article
-
STATN ·
Brain implant startup pauses trials
Neutral Brief newsletter summary emphasising the pause is not safety related and giving context from the CEO's earlier remark.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 12 Nov 15:58 First WiredLC Synchron Pauses Trials of Its Brain Implant Due to Performance Issues
- 13 Nov 14:40 +22h 42m STATN Brain implant startup pauses trials
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…