Tafoya and Flanagan clash over fraud and abortion in Minnesota Senate debate
In the only scheduled debate of Minnesota's open U.S. Senate race, Republican Michele Tafoya pressed Democratic Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan on state fraud, while Flanagan challenged Tafoya's abortion position. The two outlets covering it each highlight a different exchange.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Republican nominee Michele Tafoya, a former broadcaster, and Democratic Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan debated on Friday 16 October for Minnesota's open U.S. Senate seat. Fox NewsR “Michele Tafoya, the Republican nominee for U.S. Senate in Minnesota and a former broadcaster” Read at Fox News ↗ Raw StoryL “Republican nominee Michele Tafoya faced Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan (D-MN) on Friday in a debate for Minnesota’s open U.S. Senate seat.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1According to MPR News, as cited by Raw Story, it was the race's only scheduled debate; MPR News politics editor Brian Bakst moderated the hourlong broadcast. Raw StoryL “It was the race’s only scheduled debate, according to MPR News, whose politics editor, Brian Bakst, moderated the hourlong broadcast.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Right · 1On fraud, Tafoya cited Flanagan's eight years as lieutenant governor and said the state had "massive fraud, historic fraud," lower test scores, rising crime and a surplus turned into a deficit. Fox NewsR “My opponent has been second in command in this state for eight years, drawing a taxpayer-funded paycheck.” Read at Fox News ↗
Right · 1Fox News reports that local and federal investigators have uncovered fraud schemes involving daycare centers, food programs and health clinics, accused of defrauding the state of up to $9 billion. Fox NewsR “accused of defrauding the state of up to $9 billion” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1Asked whether she had "any ownership over the fraud," Flanagan said Gov. Tim Walz had been clear that "the buck stops with him" and that he had oversight, and pointed to her own work on paid family leave, a child tax credit and school meals. Fox NewsR “"The governor has been very clear that the buck stops with him," Flanagan said.” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1When Flanagan turned to criticism of President Donald Trump, Tafoya replied that Trump was not on the ballot and accused Flanagan of pointing at Walz after having demanded to be in the room; Flanagan said Trump had endorsed Tafoya because she passed his litmus test. Fox NewsR “Peggy, Donald Trump isn't on the ballot.”“Michele Tafoya passed his litmus test with flying colors” Read at Fox News ↗
Right · 1Tafoya proposed that noncitizens who defraud Americans must leave with no path back, mandatory prison minimums for American fraudsters, and questioned why the federal government would send money to states that cannot keep their finances in order. Fox NewsR “if you're a guest of this country, and you defraud Americans, you must leave.” Read at Fox News ↗ Left · 1On abortion, Bakst asked Tafoya to define the "reasonable access" in the first three months of pregnancy that she says she supports. Tafoya called herself a pro-choice Republican, said Minnesota law is settled and that she has no desire to change it from the Senate, then paused for several seconds, stammered and laughed before saying "reasonable access is reasonable access." Raw StoryL ““I am a pro-choice Republican,” Tafoya replied. “I have said that from the very beginning.””“Tafoya opened her mouth to respond, but no sound came for several seconds.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1Flanagan said voters were getting "two different versions of Michele Tafoya," citing a letter Tafoya signed saying she was completely aligned with Trump on abortion, and said one cannot be both that and pro-choice. Raw StoryL ““You cannot call yourself completely aligned with Donald Trump on abortion and then somehow call yourself pro-choice,” Flanagan said.” Read at Raw Story ↗
Left · 1A Planned Parenthood of Minnesota political action fund chair wrote in a Star Tribune op-ed that the letter vanished from Tafoya's campaign website within days of her nomination. Tafoya told a conservative radio show earlier this year, "I'm in line with President Trump on this," while also calling Minnesota's abortion laws too extreme. Raw StoryL “A letter containing that language disappeared from Tafoya’s campaign website within days of her winning the Republican nomination”““I’m in line with President Trump on this,” Tafoya said earlier this year on the conservative radio show Political Pitchforks.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Mixed · 2A Minnesota Star Tribune/KARE 11 poll published Monday showed Flanagan leading Tafoya 47% to 43%, with about 9% undecided; the general election is on 3 November. Raw StoryL “A Minnesota Star Tribune/KARE 11 poll published Monday showed Flanagan leading Tafoya 47% to 43%, with about 9% undecided” Read at Raw Story ↗ Fox NewsR “Flanagan and Tafoya will face off in the state’s Nov. 3 general election.” Read at Fox News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Raw Story leads with Tafoya freezing and laughing when asked to define "reasonable access" to abortion, presenting the debate as a stumble for a Trump-endorsed candidate.
- Emphasis
- Abortion, Tafoya's alignment with Trump, the vanished website letter and Flanagan's poll lead.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the fraud exchanges that dominated the other outlet's account.
- Charged language
- “Debate disaster”“Trump Senate pick”“freezes”
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Fox News frames Flanagan as dodging responsibility for Minnesota's fraud scandal and Tafoya as exposing a contradiction.
- Emphasis
- The $9 billion fraud, Flanagan's eight years as lieutenant governor, Tafoya's fraud proposals.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the abortion exchange or the poll showing Flanagan ahead.
- Charged language
- “ducks Minnesota fraud blame”“glaring contradiction”“fraud scandal”“let $9 billion walk out the door”
What every side reports
- Tafoya and Flanagan debated on Friday 16 October for Minnesota's open U.S. Senate seat.
- Trump has endorsed Tafoya.
- The general election is on 3 November.
Where accounts differ
-
Who bears responsibility for Minnesota's fraud
- Left
- Not addressed.
- Right
- Fox presents Tafoya as showing Flanagan, as lieutenant governor, cannot shift blame to Walz; Flanagan says Walz had oversight.
-
Whether Tafoya's abortion stance is coherent
- Left
- Raw Story presents her pause and Flanagan's 'two different versions' charge as exposing inconsistency.
- Right
- Not addressed.
Michele Tafoya person
Presents Flanagan as responsible for fraud as second in command and offers tougher penalties; says she is a pro-choice Republican who won't change Minnesota's abortion law.
“This election is about Peggy Flanagan.” — Fox News
“And I have no desire from the United States Senate to change that law.” — Raw Story
Peggy Flanagan person
Says Walz had oversight of the fraud and she led on family leave, child tax credit and school meals; says Tafoya gives conflicting accounts on abortion and is aligned with Trump.
“He was the one who had oversight here.” — Fox News
“This is yet another place where we are getting two different versions of Michele Tafoya” — Raw Story
Left1 article
-
Debate disaster as Trump Senate pick freezes on hot-button issue: ‘I am … eh …’
Critical Portrays Tafoya's abortion answer as a debate stumble and highlights her Trump ties.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Critical Portrays Tafoya as forceful and Flanagan as evading fraud accountability.

- 16 Oct 19:53 First Fox NewsR ‘Buck’ stops at Walz: Flanagan ducks Minnesota fraud blame as GOP rival exposes glaring contradiction
- 16 Oct 20:30 +37m Raw StoryL Debate disaster as Trump Senate pick freezes on hot-button issue: ‘I am … eh …’
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…