Teacher, 63, dismissed after saying she is 'pro-life' takes Biddick Academy to tribunal
Anita Meston, 63, says Biddick Academy in Sunderland ended her contract after she told pupils she was 'pro-life'. She is taking discrimination action with Alliance Defending Freedom's backing. The school's side has not been reported.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Right · 2Anita Meston, 63, a teacher from Durham, is taking legal action for discrimination against her former employer, Biddick Academy, a secondary school in Washington, Sunderland, after her contract was ended. GB NewsR “Anita Meston, 63, had her contract terminated by Biddick Academy in Washington, Sunderland, after answering a student's question about abortion.” Read at GB News ↗ Daily ExpressR “Anita Meston, the 63-year-old teacher from Durham who will be taking her former employer to court for discrimination.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Right · 1According to Meston's account, a pupil asked whether she was "pro-abortion" and she replied that she was "pro-life". She also answered questions about her political views briefly, then returned to the lesson. GB NewsR “During her lesson, a student asked if she was "pro-abortion", to which she responded that she was "pro-life".”“Ms Meston was also questioned about her political views, to which she responded briefly before directing students back to the lesson topic.” Read at GB News ↗ Right · 1The Express piece, written by her supporters' lawyer, adds detail: she was covering a Year 8 history lesson on the bombing of Dresden and mentioned parallels with the Israel-Palestine conflict. A boy asked whether she was "pro-Israel" and she said she was. Asked to elaborate on her pro-life answer, she cited her Christian faith and women she knew who regretted abortions. When a pupil replied that she knew women who did not regret them, Meston said "fair enough". Daily ExpressR “One boy stood up and shouted that he was “pro-Israel”, and asked if Anita was too. She responded – briefly, honestly – that she was”“A student replied that she knew women who did not regret having an abortion, and Anita responded, “fair enough”.” Read at Daily Express ↗
Right · 2The next day the headteacher summoned her, said a complaint had been made about the lesson, told her she was not allowed to give personal views in the classroom, and said her contract would be terminated. GB NewsR “The headteacher revealed a complaint had been made about the lesson and Ms Meston was informed that she was not allowed to give her personal views in the classroom, and so her contract would be terminated.” Read at GB News ↗ Daily ExpressR “the following day, Anita was summoned to the headteacher’s office, told that she was not allowed to give her personal views in the classroom” Read at Daily Express ↗ Right · 2The outlets describe her job differently. GB News calls her a supply teacher working full-time for six months, with her contract renewed the previous week. The Express says she worked full-time for six months, had 28 years' experience and taught Modern Languages and a form group. GB NewsR “Ms Meston had been working full-time as a supply teacher at the secondary school for six months, and her contract with the school had been renewed the previous week.” Read at GB News ↗ Daily ExpressR “a teacher with 28 years’ experience, whose full-time contract had just been renewed” Read at Daily Express ↗ Right · 1Meston said she was "profoundly shocked" and called the decision "nothing short of censorship". She said she does not believe a teacher should impose beliefs unrelated to the lesson, and that she only gave truthful answers before redirecting pupils. GB NewsR “I am profoundly shocked by Biddick Academy’s decision to dismiss me for my faith-based pro-life beliefs and other mainstream personal and political views.”“What happened to me is nothing short of censorship, and this precedent cannot be allowed to stand.” Read at GB News ↗
Right · 2Alliance Defending Freedom, a legal advocacy group, is supporting her case. Its legal counsel, Jeremiah Igunnubole, says the law protects employees from discriminatory treatment and that employers cannot fire staff merely because they disagree with their Christian beliefs. He is also the author of the Express article. GB NewsR “The law protects all employees from discriminatory treatment. We are supporting Anita to ensure her rights as a Christian in the workplace are upheld” Read at GB News ↗ Daily ExpressR “Jeremiah Igunnubole (@JIgunnubole) is a barrister and former Senior Crown Prosecutor with the Crown Prosecution Service, who serves as Legal Counsel for Alliance Defending Freedom in London.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Right · 1A preliminary hearing is scheduled for 16 October 2026 at the Employment Tribunal. GB News said it had contacted Biddick Academy for comment, and no response from the school appears in the coverage, so the school's reasons are known only through Meston's account of the headteacher's remarks. GB NewsR “A preliminary hearing is scheduled for October 16, 2026 at the Employment Tribunal.”“Biddick Academy has been contacted by GB News for comment.” Read at GB News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets present the case as a Christian teacher punished for honest answers to pupils, and as part of a wider free-speech problem. The Express piece is an opinion column by an ADF lawyer. GB News reports the legal action largely through statements from Meston and ADF.
- Emphasis
- Meston's good faith, brief answers and 28 years' experience. The column also stresses a pattern of Christians facing consequences at work and the effect on pupils and other teachers.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither carries a response from the school or the content of the complaint beyond Meston's account. Neither gives the view of the pupil who complained.
- Charged language
- “Shocking case”“egregious offence”“blatant censorship”“nothing short of censorship”
- For example
-
“Such blatant censorship is particularly concerning in an educational environment” — Daily Express
“What happened to me is nothing short of censorship, and this precedent cannot be allowed to stand.” — GB News
What every side reports
- Anita Meston, 63, was dismissed by Biddick Academy in Sunderland after telling pupils she was pro-life.
- The headteacher told her the day after the lesson that she could not give personal views in class.
- She is taking discrimination action with Alliance Defending Freedom's support.
- She had worked at the school for six months.
Where accounts differ
-
Her employment status
- Right
- GB News calls her a supply teacher working full-time; the Express describes a full-time contract and 28 years' experience, and gives her home as Durham.
-
Why she was dismissed
- Right
- Meston and ADF say it was because of her Christian pro-life beliefs. The school's reasons are not reported beyond the headteacher's reported remark that personal views are not allowed in class.
Anita Meston person
Says she was dismissed for faith-based pro-life and other mainstream views after answering pupils' questions truthfully and briefly, and is suing for discrimination to stop others facing the same.
“I merely acknowledged my students’ questions and provided truthful answers before redirecting them back to the lesson at hand.” — GB News
Biddick Academy organisation
No statement from the school is reported. Per Meston, the headteacher said a complaint had been made and that teachers may not give personal views in class. GB News says it has asked the school for comment.
“Biddick Academy has been contacted by GB News for comment.” — GB News
Free speech topic
The Express column frames the case as part of a wider battle over freedom of thought and expression in Britain.
“it’s the latest front in the battle for freedom of thought and expression in this country.” — Daily Express
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right2 articles
-
Daily ExpressR · · Opinion
Shocking case of teacher, 63, dismissed for answering question should make us shudder
Alarmist Opinion by an ADF lawyer arguing the dismissal is censorship of Christian views and a warning for society.
-
GB NewsR ·
Teacher sacked after saying she is 'pro-life' sues school for discrimination
Sympathetic News report on the discrimination claim, built mainly on statements from Meston and ADF, with the school not yet heard.
- 12 Oct 16:08 First Daily ExpressR Shocking case of teacher, 63, dismissed for answering question should make us shudder Opinion
- 14 Oct 13:53 +45h 45m GB NewsR Teacher sacked after saying she is 'pro-life' sues school for discrimination
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…