Texas Children's Hospital opens clinic for detransitioning patients under settlement
Texas Children's Hospital has opened a clinic for patients up to age 21 seeking care after gender-transition treatment, as required by a settlement over billing allegations. Paxton calls it the nation's first; the Washington Examiner notes a Cleveland Clinic settlement also required detransition care.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Right · 2Texas Children's Hospital, described as the largest children's hospital in Texas, has opened a clinic for patients who previously underwent gender-transition treatment and now seek related medical care. Just the NewsRC “The largest children's hospital in Texas officially opened the first-ever detransition clinic on Monday” Read at Just the News ↗ Washington ExaminerR “Texas Children’s Hospital has opened a clinic for patients seeking medical care after undergoing gender-transition procedures” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ Right · 2Just the News reported the official opening on Monday, 26 October, while the Washington Examiner said Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton announced it on Tuesday, 27 October, writing on social media that "The nation’s first-ever Detransition Clinic is now open." Just the NewsRC “officially opened the first-ever detransition clinic on Monday” Read at Just the News ↗ Washington ExaminerR ““The nation’s first-ever Detransition Clinic is now open,” Paxton said Tuesday on social media” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ Right · 2The clinic serves patients through age 21, and the Washington Examiner says patients older than 21 can receive related obstetric and gynecological care; Just the News says it is now accepting booking requests. Washington ExaminerR “Patients older than 21 can receive related obstetric and gynecological care.” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ Just the NewsRC “The clinic is now accepting booking requests for appointments” Read at Just the News ↗
Right · 2Services include endocrinology, surgery, primary care, fertility counseling, psychiatry, psychology or psychotherapy, social work and speech pathology. Just the NewsRC “endocrinology, surgery, primary care, fertility counseling, psychiatry, psychology, social work/case management, and speech pathology” Read at Just the News ↗ Washington ExaminerR “endocrinology, surgery, primary care, fertility counseling, psychiatry, psychotherapy, social work, and speech pathology” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ Right · 2The clinic is a term of a settlement announced in May and finalized in July, which resolved allegations that the hospital improperly billed Medicaid and other payors for gender-transition procedures, including by using false diagnosis codes. Washington ExaminerR “The settlement, announced in May and finalized in July, resolved allegations that Texas Children’s improperly billed Texas Medicaid for gender-transition procedures, including by using false diagnosis codes.” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ Just the NewsRC “submitted false billings to public and private payors” Read at Just the News ↗ Right · 2The hospital agreed to pay about $10 million (Just the News says more than $10 million in damages and civil penalties) and to stop providing the procedures to minors; it must fund the clinic for its first five years so patients receive care at no cost. Washington ExaminerR “The hospital must fund the clinic’s services for its first five years, allowing patients to receive care at no cost” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ Just the NewsRC “an agreement to pay more than $10 million in damages and civil penalties” Read at Just the News ↗
Right · 1Texas Children's has denied wrongdoing, saying it settled to close the dispute and focus its resources on patient care. Washington ExaminerR “Texas Children’s has denied wrongdoing, saying it settled to bring the dispute to a close and focus its resources on patient care.” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ Right · 1Vanessa Sivadge, founder of Protect Texas Children and the case's whistleblower, thanked Paxton and her attorneys and hoped the clinic would be "the first of many." Just the NewsRC “That this clinic is not the exception, but the first of many.” Read at Just the News ↗ Right · 1The Washington Examiner notes that Paxton's "first" claim comes months after Cleveland Clinic settled with the Justice Department and Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost in June, agreeing to pay $308,000 and commit $2 million to restorative care for detransitioners. Washington ExaminerR “Under that agreement, Cleveland Clinic agreed to pay $308,000 to resolve allegations of improper billing for procedures performed on minors and commit $2 million toward restorative care for detransitioners” Read at Washington Examiner ↗
Right · 1Unlike the Texas settlement, the Cleveland agreement did not require a dedicated clinic but required services, publicity, a webpage, phone number and care coordinator; the Examiner said it asked Paxton's office to clarify the distinction. Washington ExaminerR “Unlike the Texas settlement, which explicitly requires the creation of a dedicated detransition clinic, the Cleveland Clinic agreement required the health system to provide detransition-related services”“The Washington Examiner asked Paxton’s office to clarify the distinction” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ Right · 1The announcement came nearly a week before the November midterms, in which Paxton is the Republican Senate candidate against Democrat James Talarico, who has a narrow lead in recent polling averages. Washington ExaminerR “Paxton will face Democratic Senate nominee James Talarico in what has become one of the most expensive and closely watched races in the country.” Read at Washington Examiner ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets present the clinic as a result of the Trump administration's and Paxton's enforcement against pediatric gender-transition care; Just the News leads with the 'first' opening and the whistleblower's praise, the Examiner adds scrutiny of the 'first' claim and the election timing.
- Emphasis
- Settlement terms, services offered, Paxton's and Sivadge's statements; the Examiner also covers the Cleveland Clinic precedent and the Paxton–Talarico race.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No outlet quotes the hospital on the clinic's opening or any medical or advocacy groups; Just the News omits the hospital's denial of wrongdoing and the Cleveland Clinic precedent.
- Charged language
- “so-called gender affirming care”“detransition clinic”
- For example
-
“minors who underwent so-called gender affirming care” — Just the News
“But the announcement comes months after Ohio’s Cleveland Clinic agreed to a separate settlement” — Washington Examiner
What every side reports
- Texas Children's Hospital opened a clinic for patients up to 21 who underwent gender-transition treatment.
- The clinic stems from a settlement of billing allegations with a payment of about $10 million.
- Services include endocrinology, surgery, primary care, fertility counseling, psychiatry and speech pathology.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether it is the nation's first such clinic
- Right
- Just the News calls it the first-ever; the Washington Examiner reports Paxton's 'first' claim but notes Cleveland Clinic's earlier settlement required detransition care, though not a dedicated clinic.
-
Settlement amount
- Right
- Just the News says more than $10 million in damages and civil penalties; the Washington Examiner says $10 million.
Ken Paxton person
Paxton announced the clinic as the nation's first and said he would ensure it provides care to patients he says were harmed by gender-transition interventions.
“adding that he would ensure the facility provides care and support to patients he said had been harmed by gender-transition interventions” — Washington Examiner
Texas Children's Hospital organisation
The hospital settled, denies wrongdoing, and says it did so to end the dispute and focus on patient care; it must fund the clinic for five years.
“Texas Children’s has denied wrongdoing, saying it settled to bring the dispute to a close and focus its resources on patient care.” — Washington Examiner
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right2 articles
-
Texas Children’s Hospital officially opens nation's first transgender detransition clinic
Celebratory Reports the opening as a milestone, featuring the whistleblower's thanks to Paxton and using 'so-called' for gender-affirming care.
-
Paxton touts ‘first’ detransition clinic opening in Texas after settlement with children’s hospital
Mixed Reports Paxton's announcement while questioning his 'first' claim via the Cleveland Clinic settlement and noting the midterm timing.
- 26 Oct 19:52 First Just the NewsRC Texas Children’s Hospital officially opens nation's first transgender detransition clinic
- 27 Oct 17:39 +21h 47m Washington ExaminerR Paxton touts ‘first’ detransition clinic opening in Texas after settlement with children’s hospital
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…