Three men found guilty of murdering Australian brothers Jake and Callum Robinson in Mexico
A Mexican court in Baja California found three men guilty of murdering Australian brothers Jake and Callum Robinson and their American friend Carter Rhoad during a 2024 surfing trip.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Three men have been found guilty of murdering Australian brothers Jake and Callum Robinson and their American friend Carter Rhoad during a surfing trip in Mexico in 2024. BBC NewsN “Three men have been found guilty of murdering Australian brothers, Jake and Callum Robinson, and their American friend Carter Rhoad during a surfing trip in Mexico in 2024.” Read at BBC News ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “Three men accused of killing Australian brothers Jake and Callum Robinson in Mexico have been found guilty of the murders.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Mixed · 2The verdict was handed down on Friday in the Mexican state of Baja California, and a judge found all three guilty of aggravated homicide and several related offences. BBC NewsN “The verdict was handed down on Friday in the Mexican state of Baja California.” Read at BBC News ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “A judge found all three men guilty of aggravated homicide and several related offences.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Mixed · 2The defendants are Jesús Gerardo, known as "El Kekas", Irineo Francisco and Ángel Jesús; ABC News says their full names have been withheld for legal reasons, and the BBC describes Gerardo as the alleged ringleader. ABC News (Australia)LC “Jesús Gerardo, known as "El Kekas", Irineo Francisco and Ángel Jesús — whose full names have been withheld for legal reasons — have been on trial in a Mexican court.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ BBC NewsN “the girlfriend of the alleged ringleader, Jesús "El Kekas" Gerardo” Read at BBC News ↗
Mixed · 2The prosecution told the trial the victims were killed in a robbery gone wrong, and the court heard it was an apparent botched robbery of their truck in a secluded beach area; the defence argued there was not enough evidence to prove the case. ABC News (Australia)LC “The prosecution told the trial that the men were murdered during a robbery gone wrong.”“The defence had attempted to argue there was not enough evidence to prove the case.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ BBC NewsN “the court heard the tourists were killed in an apparent botched robbery of their truck in a secluded beach area” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 1The BBC reports that the men's bodies had gunshot wounds to the head and were dumped down a well; they were found about a week after the killings, which happened roughly 36 hours after the group crossed into Mexico from the US. BBC NewsN “Their bodies were later found with gunshot wounds to their heads, dumped down a well.”“Their killings took place barely 36 hours after they crossed into Mexico from the US.” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 1During the month-long trial in Ensenada, prosecutors sought 150 years in prison for each defendant; the sentences had not been reported in the coverage. BBC NewsN “During the month-long trial, the prosecution had sought 150 years in prison for each of the three defendants.” Read at BBC News ↗
Centre · 1The brothers' parents, Martin and Debra Robinson, attended the trial throughout and gave emotional testimony in closing arguments, while Rhoad's family joined by video link. BBC NewsN “The parents of the two Australian brothers, Martin and Debra Robinson, have been at the court in the coastal town of Ensenada throughout the trial”“Family members of Rhoad joined the trial by video link.” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 1In November last year, the girlfriend of the alleged ringleader was sentenced in a separate trial to twenty years in prison after admitting involvement in the robbery. BBC NewsN “In November last year, the girlfriend of the alleged ringleader, Jesús "El Kekas" Gerardo, was sentenced in a separate trial to twenty years in prison. She had admitted to involvement in the robbery.” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 1The killings shocked Australia and Ensenada, which is usually safe from the violence seen elsewhere in Mexico; local surfers called for greater security, and Baja California governor Marina del Pilar Ávila said the state would continue to be safe for tourism. BBC NewsN “The murders sent shockwaves around the world, particularly in Australia, as the coastal area is usually safe from the violence in other parts of Mexico.”“"Baja California is and will continue to be a state with safe tourism for the thousands of people who visit us from the rest of the country and the world"” Read at BBC News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- ABC News (Australia) ran a short breaking-news report focused on the verdict, the defendants' names and the charges.
- Emphasis
- The guilty verdict, aggravated homicide charges, and the defence argument of insufficient evidence.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the bodies' discovery, the prosecution's sentencing request, the co-accused's earlier sentence or official reaction.
- Charged language
- “robbery gone wrong”
- For example
-
“A judge found all three men guilty of aggravated homicide and several related offences.” — ABC News (Australia)
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- BBC News gave a fuller account placing the verdict in the context of the crime, trial and its effect on Ensenada and Mexico's security image.
- Emphasis
- The victims' families, the circumstances of the killings, local surfer reaction and the governor's tourism reassurance.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not report the specific charges or the defence's argument.
- Charged language
- “chilling murders”“wrong place at the wrong time”
- For example
-
“The beach town has a reputation as a welcoming spot for surfers and the chilling murders revealed much about how commonplace such extreme violence remains in Mexico.” — BBC News
Right1 outlet
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Three men were found guilty of murdering Jake and Callum Robinson in Mexico.
- The victims were on a surfing trip in Baja California in 2024 with American friend Carter Rhoad.
- Prosecutors presented the killings as a robbery gone wrong.
Where accounts differ
-
Role of Jesús Gerardo
- Left
- ABC lists him among three men found guilty, without a ringleader label.
- Centre
- BBC calls him the "alleged ringleader".
Jake Robinson person
The Robinson brothers' father Martin said it is hard for a parent to lose a son and that they lost two.
“"It's hard for a parent to lose a son, and we lost two sons," said their father, Martin.” — BBC News
Left1 article
-
Breaking: Mexican men guilty of murdering brothers Jake and Callum Robinson
Neutral Brief breaking-news report of the verdict with charges and defence argument.
Centre1 article
-
Three men found guilty of murdering two Australian surfer brothers and US friend
Sympathetic Detailed report centred on the victims, their families and the shock to the surfing community and Ensenada.

Right1 article
- 9 Oct 21:42 First ABC News (Australia)LC Breaking: Mexican men guilty of murdering brothers Jake and Callum Robinson
- 9 Oct 22:04 +23m BBC NewsN Three men found guilty of murdering two Australian surfer brothers and US friend
- 9 Oct 22:54 +1h 13m The Straits TimesRC Mexican court finds three men guilty of 2024 killing of Australian, US surfers via Reuters
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.