Three Russian gymnasts denied Dutch visas for Rotterdam world championships
Dutch authorities denied visas to Russian gymnasts Angelina Melnikova, Viktoria Listunova and Anna Kalmykova ahead of the Rotterdam world championships. Russia's gymnastics federation and sports minister are asking the IOC and World Gymnastics to act.
1 / 1
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2Three Russian artistic gymnasts, Angelina Melnikova, Viktoria Listunova and Anna Kalmykova, were denied visas to enter the Netherlands for the world championships in Rotterdam, according to the Russian Gymnastics Federation. CBC NewsLC “The Russian Gymnastics Federation says Olympic champions Angelina Melnikova and Viktoria Listunova are among three athletes denied visas to enter the Netherlands” Read at CBC News ↗ MeduzaLC “Dutch authorities denied visas to Russian artistic gymnasts Angelina Melnikova, Viktoria Listunova, and Anna Kalmykova” Read at Meduza ↗ Left · 2The championships run from 17 to 25 October and are the first stage of team qualification for the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics; the top three men's and top three women's teams will earn Olympic quota spots. MeduzaLC “The world artistic gymnastics championships will take place in Rotterdam from October 17–25, marking the first stage of team qualification for the 2028 Olympics in Los Angeles.” Read at Meduza ↗ CBC NewsLC “the weeklong worlds that are a team qualifying event for the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics” Read at CBC News ↗ Left · 1Melnikova and Listunova were gold medallists in the team event at the 2021 Tokyo Olympics, and Melnikova would have been the defending women's all-around champion in Rotterdam; Kalmykova is 18. CBC NewsLC “Melnikova and Listunova were gold medalists in the team event at the 2021 Tokyo Olympics”“Melnikova would have been the defending champion in the women's all-around in Rotterdam”“18-year-old Anna Kalmykova” Read at CBC News ↗
Left · 1The federation said the refusal came because "one or several Schengen Area member states consider the athletes a threat to their international relations," and called it "a deliberate elimination of the strongest gymnasts from contention for world championship medals and Olympic quota spots." MeduzaLC ““one or several Schengen Area member states consider the athletes a threat to their international relations.””““a deliberate elimination of the strongest gymnasts from contention for world championship medals and Olympic quota spots.”” Read at Meduza ↗ Left · 2Russian sports minister Mikhail Degtyaryov wrote on social media on Tuesday that Russian officials will ask the International Olympic Committee and World Gymnastics to strip the championships of its status as a Los Angeles qualifier; Meduza says the federation plans to appeal to both bodies to assess the impact on equal conditions for Olympic qualification. CBC NewsLC “Russian officials will ask the International Olympic Committee and World Gymnastics to strip the championships of its status as a Los Angeles qualifier, sports minister Mikhail Degtyaryov wrote on social media on Tuesday.” Read at CBC News ↗ MeduzaLC “The federation said it plans to appeal to the International Olympic Committee (IOC) and World Gymnastics” Read at Meduza ↗ Left · 2Other Russian gymnasts were admitted: CBC, citing Russian media, says four others were allowed in, while Meduza names five (Ilya Zaika, Saveliy Syedin, Lyudmila Roshchina, Milana Kayumova and Elizaveta Us) and says the federation reported visas for 47 of the 61 members of the Russian delegation. CBC NewsLC “Four other Russian gymnasts were allowed into the country, Russian media reported.” Read at CBC News ↗ MeduzaLC “Five other Russian athletes received visas: Ilya Zaika, Saveliy Syedin, Lyudmila Roshchina, Milana Kayumova, and Elizaveta Us.”“Dutch authorities issued visas to 47 of the 61 members of the Russian delegation.” Read at Meduza ↗
Left · 1World Gymnastics cleared Russian gymnasts in May of restrictions on competing internationally, after years of bans or neutral-status vetting during the full-scale invasion of Ukraine, but host countries keep the right to deny visas for political or security reasons. CBC NewsLC “Russian gymnasts were cleared in May of restrictions to competing internationally by World Gymnastics”“Countries hosting sports events still retain the right to deny visas for political or security reasons.” Read at CBC News ↗ Left · 1In August 2026, Russian gymnasts competed internationally for the first time in five years, at the European Championships in Zagreb, under neutral status; Melnikova won the all-around and vault gold and Kalmykova took all-around silver. Croatia initially denied visas to the Russians but reversed the decision a few days before the competition. MeduzaLC “In August 2026, Russian gymnasts competed in international competitions for the first time in five years — at the European Championships in Zagreb, Croatia.”“Croatia did not issue visas to the Russian athletes on the first attempt — they were initially denied, but the decision was reversed a few days before the competition.” Read at Meduza ↗ Left · 1The coverage here does not include a Dutch government statement explaining the refusals or any response from the IOC or World Gymnastics. MeduzaLC “Dutch authorities denied visas to Russian artistic gymnasts Angelina Melnikova, Viktoria Listunova, and Anna Kalmykova” Read at Meduza ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets report the denials as sports news built on the Russian federation's and sports minister's statements, with context on Russia's return to competition.
- Emphasis
- CBC stresses the athletes' Olympic pedigree, the minister's call to strip qualifier status, and hosts' right to deny visas. Meduza stresses the federation's wording, the delegation visa numbers and the earlier Croatian visa reversal.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither gives a Dutch official's explanation or a response from the IOC or World Gymnastics. CBC leaves out the delegation figures and Croatia precedent; Meduza leaves out the minister's demand and hosts' visa rights.
- Charged language
- “a deliberate elimination of the strongest gymnasts”
- For example
-
“Countries hosting sports events still retain the right to deny visas for political or security reasons.” — CBC News
“The federation said it viewed the Dutch authorities’ actions as “a deliberate elimination of the strongest gymnasts from contention for world championship medals and Olympic quota spots.”” — Meduza
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Melnikova, Listunova and Kalmykova were denied visas for the Rotterdam world championships.
- The championships are a qualifying event for the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics.
- Russia plans to take its complaint to the IOC and World Gymnastics.
- Other Russian gymnasts received visas.
Where accounts differ
-
How many other Russian gymnasts were admitted
- Left
- CBC, citing Russian media, says four other gymnasts were allowed in; Meduza lists five other athletes who received visas.
-
Reason for the refusals
- Left
- The Russian federation, as reported by Meduza, says Schengen states view the athletes as a threat to international relations; CBC notes hosts may deny visas for political or security reasons. No Dutch explanation is reported.
Russian Gymnastics Federation organisation
Says the denial reflects some Schengen states seeing the athletes as a threat to international relations, calls it a deliberate elimination of its strongest gymnasts, and will appeal to the IOC and World Gymnastics.
“The federation said it plans to appeal to the International Olympic Committee (IOC) and World Gymnastics” — Meduza
““one or several Schengen Area member states consider the athletes a threat to their international relations.”” — Meduza
Angelina Melnikova person
Defending world all-around champion who would have competed in Rotterdam; denied a visa. Meduza notes she won all-around gold in Zagreb in August.
“Melnikova would have been the defending champion in the women's all-around in Rotterdam” — CBC News
“Melnikova won gold in the vault and became the all-around champion for the first time in her career.” — Meduza
Viktoria Listunova person
2021 Tokyo team gold medallist, named among the three athletes denied visas.
“Melnikova and Listunova were gold medalists in the team event at the 2021 Tokyo Olympics” — CBC News
Left2 articles
-
Olympic champions among 3 Russian gymnasts denied visas for upcoming world championships
Neutral Short news report led by the federation's claim and the minister's call to strip qualifier status, with background on Russia's reinstatement and hosts' visa rights.
-
MeduzaLC ·
Neutral Report relaying the federation's accusation and delegation visa figures, with context on the Zagreb return and Croatia's reversed visa denial.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 13 Oct 16:39 First CBC NewsLC Olympic champions among 3 Russian gymnasts denied visas for upcoming world championships
- 14 Oct 08:14 +15h 35m MeduzaLC Netherlands denies visas to three Russian gymnasts for world championships, including Olympic champion Angelina Melnikova
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…