Ukrainian couple face legal action in Oman over video of sea turtle
Two Ukrainian tourists filmed themselves on a sea turtle in Oman. The video went viral and Omani authorities have taken legal action over alleged breaches of wildlife protection law.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
A viral video and photos show two Ukrainian tourists on a sea turtle on a beach in Oman. Al JazeeraLC “Viral video and photos of two Ukrainian tourists riding a sea turtle on a beach in Oman” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ Al Jazeera reports that this has resulted in legal action against them for alleged breaches of the country's wildlife protection laws. Al JazeeraLC “has resulted in legal action against them, for alleged breaches of the country’s wildlife protection laws” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ Fox News names the pair as Vadym Oleynik, 32, and his fiancée Olena Kravchenko, and says they filmed the encounter at the Ras Al Jinz Turtle Reserve. Fox NewsR “Vadym Oleynik, 32, and Olena Kravchenko, his fiancée, filmed themselves sitting on the turtle”“The couple filmed the encounter at the Ras Al Jinz Turtle Reserve in Oman.” Read at Fox News ↗
According to Fox News, the turtle was trying to lay eggs at the time, and the couple were also seen holding her hatchlings and posing for photos. Fox NewsR “both Oleynik and Kravchenko are seen holding the turtle's hatchlings, posing for photos and smiling” Read at Fox News ↗ Fox News says Oman's Environment Authority has apparently opened an investigation, calling the incident a violation of Omani laws and saying it has taken "necessary legal action against the individual." Fox NewsR “Oman's Environment Authority has apparently opened an investigation into the incident” Read at Fox News ↗ Oleynik deleted the video and, after heavy criticism on social media, apologised publicly, calling his actions "a mistake" and saying he never meant to harm the turtle. Fox NewsR “Oleynik issued a public apology, saying he never intended to cause harm to the turtle and calling his actions "a mistake."” Read at Fox News ↗
Fox News says it is unclear what the legal consequences will be. Fox NewsR “There's no telling what the ramifications for this will be in a legal sense” Read at Fox News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Brief, straight news item: viral video leads to legal action for alleged wildlife-law breaches.
- Emphasis
- The legal consequences and the alleged breach of wildlife protection laws.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No names, location of the reserve, nesting detail, official statement or apology.
- For example
-
“has resulted in legal action against them, for alleged breaches of the country’s wildlife protection laws” — Al Jazeera
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Opinionated, outrage-driven blog-style piece that condemns the couple and dwells on the distress of the turtle and the online backlash.
- Emphasis
- The turtle's suffering, the hatchlings, the influencers' names and online backlash, and the apology.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Says the legal outcome is unknown and describes Oman's response as only apparent; gives no detail of the specific laws alleged to be breached.
- Charged language
- “Finding Nemo" nightmare”“Perhaps the most sickening part”“weird photo op”“court of public opinion”
What every side reports
- The couple are Ukrainian and the incident took place in Oman.
- A video of them with a sea turtle went viral.
- They face legal action over the incident.
Where accounts differ
-
What the pair did to the turtle
- Left
- Al Jazeera says the tourists were "riding" a sea turtle on a beach.
- Right
- Fox News says they were sitting on a nesting turtle as she tried to lay eggs, and also held hatchlings.
Oman place
Per Fox News, Oman's Environment Authority calls the incident a violation of Omani laws and says it has taken legal action; Al Jazeera cites alleged breaches of wildlife protection laws.
“calling it a violation of Omani laws and saying they have taken "necessary legal action against the individual."” — Fox News
“alleged breaches of the country’s wildlife protection laws” — Al Jazeera
Left1 article
-
Tourists face legal action over turtle-riding video in Oman
Neutral Short factual report focused on legal action following the viral video.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Ukrainian influencers filmed themselves sitting on top of sea turtle while it tries to lay eggs
Critical Commentary-style piece that condemns the influencers, stresses the turtle's distress and the online backlash, and notes their apology.
- 29 Sep 14:26 First Al JazeeraLC Tourists face legal action over turtle-riding video in Oman
- 29 Sep 23:27 +9h 1m Fox NewsR Ukrainian influencers filmed themselves sitting on top of sea turtle while it tries to lay eggs
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.