Skip to content
Bramble

US

Trump leaves open Zacharia's exit as press secretary; White House then confirms she is out

After five days as White House press secretary, Katie Zacharia is leaving. Trump said he told her to "reconsider", and an official later confirmed she was "transitioning out". Coverage also says Trump backed chief of staff Susie Wiles.

34 outlets · 14L · 11C · 9R First reported Account updated
Image: Washington Examiner
Image: France 24
Image: Raw Story
Image: Just the News
Image: Newsweek
Image: Daily Mirror
Image: The Times of India
Image: CBS News

1 / 8

The story, neutrally told

Centre · 2White House Press Secretary Katie Zacharia is leaving the job after five days. Trump told reporters on Friday 16 October that he had told her to reconsider, and a White House official then confirmed she was "transitioning out". Centre · 3Trump said: "I said, 'Katie, you don't have to do this' ... I said to her, 'Honestly if I were you I'd reconsider.'" He added that the media had treated her "very badly" and that "we're talking about doing something", which suggests she could be moved to another White House role. Left · 3Outlets word the departure differently: a White House official told Reuters she was "let go", AFP said she was "pushed out", and the New York Times, as relayed by The Hollywood Reporter, reported she was out.

Right · 1The Washington Examiner reported that Trump made two personnel moves on Friday: he opened the door to Zacharia's departure and backed chief of staff Susie Wiles. Mixed · 2Zacharia succeeded Karoline Leavitt and started on Monday. Her first briefing, on Tuesday 13 October, lasted under 15 minutes and took only three questions. Left · 3Scrutiny then turned to her claims to be a lawyer. She had described herself as a lawyer and listed herself as general counsel of a California nonprofit. She acknowledged on Thursday that she had failed the bar exam, and in a Fox News interview with Sean Hannity said she had not retaken it. Trump's own announcement of her appointment had called her an attorney.

Mixed · 2In other interviews she said she had been "distracted and overwhelmed" by plans to move to China when she registered for the exam. She also drew criticism for saying China lacked "proper toilets", and China's Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Mao Ning replied that she should "visit China more often". Centre · 1On Fox and Friends on Friday she sidestepped a question about whether she had the president's confidence, saying she hoped "to build the trust and confidence of everyone around me". Right · 1A GOP strategist with ties to the administration told the Washington Examiner she "was becoming a distraction" and "wasn't forthcoming behind closed doors". Unnamed insiders said the Hannity interview was the final blow. The same report said Trump was a "big fan" and that Zacharia's family would have dinner with Vice President JD Vance on Friday night. The White House declined to say what role she might move to.

Centre · 3The episode comes as Trump campaigns for Republicans before the 3 November midterms, with polls predicting heavy losses. Coverage says she is the shortest-serving press secretary in the White House's history, shorter than Anthony Scaramucci's 10 days as communications director. Scaramucci said he took "no pleasure in other people's pain".

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left14 outlets

Framing
Frames it as a firing after a disastrous debut, with some colour and commentary. Hollywood Reporter compares it to Scaramucci; Raw Story runs opinion pieces and a Trump-Hannity theory.
Emphasis
The failed bar exam and her 'lawyer' claims, the mocked briefing, Trump's own part in the exit.
Leaves out or plays down
Little on Trump's backing for Wiles; the Vance dinner and 'big fan' details come from right-leaning reporting.
Charged language
“Half a Scaramucci”“Ousted”“disastrous debut”
For example
“Half a Scaramucci: White House Press Secretary Katie Zacharia Ousted After One Briefing” — The Hollywood Reporter
“White House Press Secretary Katie Zacharia ‘let go’ just days into role” — The Hindu

Centre11 outlets

Framing
Mostly wire-style reporting that she looks set to go and has since been confirmed out. Newsweek adds a timeline of Trump's press secretaries and a look at possible successors.
Emphasis
Trump's 'reconsider' remark, the 'transitioning out' confirmation, her record-short tenure, the China remarks.
Leaves out or plays down
Few insider accounts of why the White House moved; Wiles barely appears.
Charged language
“shaky performance”
For example
“The US president told the new White House press secretary Katie Zacharia to “reconsider” her job just days after her first press briefing faced criticism.” — CNA
“Trump says he told Zacharia to 'reconsider' staying in role, and that she had been 'treated very badly' by media” — Anadolu Agency

Right9 outlets

Framing
Split. AFP copy carried by the Straits Times calls it a push-out after 'a series of blunders'. The Washington Examiner gives an insider account of how she became 'a distraction' and notes Trump kept Wiles; New York Post and Just the News use Scaramucci's reaction.
Emphasis
Insider explanations, the Hannity interview as the turning point, Trump's continued support for Wiles.
Leaves out or plays down
Less on the wider questions over her credentials, with more on White House process.
Charged language
“blunders”“distraction”“fastest-ever fired flack”
For example
““She was becoming a distraction’: How Katie Zacharia lost the White House press secretary job in four days” — Washington Examiner
“Trump leaves door open for Katie Zacharia to quit a week into press secretary job — but will keep Susie Wiles” — Washington Examiner

Ask about this story

Loading…