Trump's $500 health-cost checks reach mailboxes weeks before midterms; critics call them a stunt
Treasury checks of $500 for some Healthcare.gov enrollees, with letters from President Trump, are arriving weeks before the midterms. Critics, including an ethics expert, call them electioneering; the White House calls the criticism out-of-touch.
1 / 1
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2Checks from the U.S. Treasury, mailed with letters from President Donald Trump, are arriving in Americans' mailboxes weeks before the midterm elections. Raw StoryL “Checks from the U.S. Treasury, mailed with letters from President Donald Trump, are landing in Americans' mailboxes weeks before the midterms” Read at Raw Story ↗ NPRLC “As checks from President Trump for health costs hit millions of mailboxes” Read at NPR ↗ Left · 1The $500 checks went to people in the 30 states that use Healthcare.gov who earn too much to qualify for subsidies, the group hit hardest when the Republican-controlled Congress let Biden-era premium subsidies expire. Raw StoryL “The $500 checks went to people in the 30 states who use Healthcare.gov who earn too much to qualify for subsidies” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1Trump also announced $90 checks for about 20 million people enrolled in traditional Medicare. Raw StoryL “Trump also announced $90 checks for about 20 million people enrolled in traditional Medicare.” Read at Raw Story ↗
Left · 2Ellen Allen, who runs the nonprofit West Virginians for Affordable Health Care, received a $500 check near Charleston on Monday and told NPR it seemed a "political stunt"; she said she had drained her retirement savings to pay $1,967 a month for coverage until she qualified for Medicare. Raw StoryL “got a $500 check at her home near Charleston on Monday, and she told NPR the money seemed to be a "political stunt."” Read at Raw Story ↗ NPRLC “To her, it's a 'political stunt'” Read at NPR ↗ Left · 1Kathleen Clark, a professor of legal and governmental ethics at Washington University Law School, said the accompanying letters, which tout Trump's record and criticize the Biden administration, "read as electioneering", and that the payments may violate the Hatch Act or be an unauthorized use of funds. Raw StoryL “"This reads like electioneering," Clark said.”“the payments may violate the Hatch Act and could be an unauthorized use of funds” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 2The money came from marketplace fees paid by insurers and a Medicare improvement fund, neither of which has been used for direct payments before, according to Raw Story's account. NPR said experts doubt the checks will move the needle and say they are likely illegal. Raw StoryL “Neither pot of money, marketplace fees paid by insurers and a Medicare improvement fund, has ever been used for direct payments before.” Read at Raw Story ↗ NPRLC “Experts doubt it will move the needle and say it is likely illegal.” Read at NPR ↗
Left · 1Joseph Antos of the conservative American Enterprise Institute called the move "inexplicable" and said he saw no advantage for anyone, including Trump. Raw StoryL “Joseph Antos of the American Enterprise Institute called the move "inexplicable"” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1A White House spokeswoman dismissed the criticism as "out-of-touch", saying Trump "returned their hard-earned money" after Americans were "overcharged" for running the Obamacare exchange. Raw StoryL “A White House spokeswoman dismissed the criticism as "out-of-touch,"” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 2A new KFF poll found 42 percent of voters trust Democrats to handle health costs versus 22 percent who trust Republicans, double the gap from April. Raw StoryL “A new KFF poll found 42 percent of voters trust Democrats to handle health costs, compared with 22 percent who trust Republicans” Read at Raw Story ↗ NPRLC “a poll shows Americans don't trust Republicans on healthcare” Read at NPR ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets treat the checks as a likely pre-election ploy, led by a recipient who calls them a 'political stunt' and backed by ethics and legality concerns.
- Emphasis
- Recipient's scepticism, legal concerns, low trust in Republicans on health care, small size of Medicare checks.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Little detail on the White House's rationale beyond a brief response; no supporters of the checks quoted.
- Charged language
- “bribe”“midterm fiasco”“political stunt”
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Checks tied to Trump for health costs are reaching mailboxes ahead of the midterms.
- A poll shows low trust in Republicans on health care.
- Recipients and experts quoted call the checks a political stunt or likely illegal.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether the checks are legitimate or electioneering
- Left
- Critics quoted say they are a political stunt, a 'bribe' and possibly a Hatch Act violation.
- Right
- The White House says Trump returned money Americans were overcharged and calls the criticism out-of-touch (relayed by Raw Story).
Donald Trump person
Through a White House spokeswoman, Trump's side says he returned money Americans were overcharged and dismisses critics as out-of-touch.
“saying Trump "returned their hard-earned money" after Americans were "overcharged"” — Raw Story
Left2 articles
-
NPRLC ·
She got Trump's $500 check for health insurance. To her, it's a 'political stunt'
Critical Leads with a recipient calling the check a 'political stunt', citing a poll and experts who doubt its effect and call it likely illegal.
-
'People aren't fooled': Trump's election 'bribe' roundly mocked amid midterm fiasco
Critical Aggregates NPR's reporting with ethics-expert criticism and mockery, calling the checks a 'bribe'.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 7 Oct 17:15 First NPRLC She got Trump's $500 check for health insurance. To her, it's a 'political stunt'
- 7 Oct 19:24 +2h 9m Raw StoryL 'People aren't fooled': Trump's election 'bribe' roundly mocked amid midterm fiasco
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.