Skip to content
Bramble

World

Trump says he warned Macron over immigration as nearly 1,000 are arrested at French protests

Trump said he told Emmanuel Macron his immigration policies were "destroying France", after nearly 1,000 arrests at Saturday's protests across France. Macron has criticised foreign leaders for exploiting the unrest.

3 outlets · 0L · 2C · 1R First reported Account updated
Image: Fox News
Image: Hindustan Times
Image: The Times of India

1 / 3

The story, neutrally told

Right · 1Donald Trump said he had warned French President Emmanuel Macron that his immigration policies were "destroying France", in an interview on Fox News's "Sunday Morning Futures" with Larry Kudlow. Centre · 2The day before, at a Republican campaign rally in Perry, Georgia, Trump said France was "burning down because it opens its borders to people who hate it", and used the example to attack Georgia Senator Jon Ossoff's immigration stance. Mixed · 2Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez said nearly 1,000 people were arrested during demonstrations across France on Saturday and that the figure could rise; a week earlier, 385 had been arrested by the same time. Fox News also cited an Interior Ministry figure of more than 1,300 arrests.

Mixed · 2The French government put turnout at around 410,000, while organisers estimated nearly 800,000. Most union-organised marches were peaceful, but clashes broke out later in Paris, Lyon, Lille, Marseille, Montpellier, Nantes and Toulouse, with police using tear gas and water cannons. Right · 1French authorities deployed 70,000 police officers nationwide, and Macron vowed that looters and vandals would be made to pay for damage. Fox News reported that Macron said on Thursday his government would move to ban protests organised by "individuals or groups with no legitimate authority" and blamed "ultra-left groups" for riots and looting. Mixed · 2The protests began weeks earlier with student complaints about school conditions and teacher shortages, then widened when trade unions and other groups joined over austerity, wages, pensions and the cost of living. Hindustan Times's headline said Trump claimed the protests were not related to education.

Centre · 1Macron, speaking in Doha on 21 October, said some leaders were "in campaign mode" at France's expense. He said there was no visible foreign interference in the events but there had been foreign manipulation of information afterwards, producing "equally unacceptable and stupid comments from many people, including foreign leaders". Asked if he meant Trump, he replied "Among others, yes." Centre · 1Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu also criticised France, telling i24News on 20 October that it had succumbed to an "invasion of extremist Islam", according to the Times of India citing the Times of Israel. Right · 1Asked whether Americans should fear similar unrest, Trump said "I closed the border" and claimed there had been "0 illegal aliens in the last 18 months". Fox News added that the Department of Homeland Security reported a 95% drop in southwest border apprehensions compared with the Biden administration. Fox said it had asked Macron's office for comment and not immediately heard back.

Right · 1Fox News said a French intelligence assessment, reportedly cited by a French outlet, identified Antifa and other far-left groups as instigators of some violence. It reported unrest elsewhere in Europe: Italy, where Giorgia Meloni sent 500 more soldiers to Milan; Belgium, with nearly 200 arrests; Spain, with 128 arrests in Barcelona; and Albania.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left0 outlets

No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Centre2 outlets

Framing
Indian outlets report Trump's rally remarks as a US midterm campaign story alongside the French protest figures, with Macron's pushback and Netanyahu's criticism for context.
Emphasis
Rally quotes, arrest and turnout figures, Macron's rebuke of foreign leaders, the broad left-wing coalition behind the marches.
Leaves out or plays down
Neither mentions Trump's claim to have warned Macron directly, the planned protest ban, or the intelligence assessment on far-left groups; Hindustan Times's arrest count is an early figure.
Charged language
“burning down”“anti-American third-world migrants”
For example
“Using the current situation in France as an example, Trump drew a parallel to immigration policies of the US” — Hindustan Times
“Macron hits back at foreign leaders' remarks” — The Times of India

Right1 outlet

Framing
Fox News leads with Trump's warning to Macron and presents unrest as spreading across Europe, with leaders' crackdowns and far-left involvement.
Emphasis
Trump's interview, his border record, Macron's ban on protests and blame on "ultra-left groups", Antifa claims, the State Department backing Trump.
Leaves out or plays down
Gives less space to the French government's turnout figures and the broad union coalition; Macron's reply to Trump is mostly a short paraphrase.
Charged language
“dire warning”“violent unrest”“Antifa”“rock the continent”
For example
“Trump reveals dire warning to Macron as violent unrest spreads across Europe” — Fox News
“Interior Minister Bernard Quintin accused far-left activists, including people linked to Antifa, of infiltrating demonstrations” — Fox News

Ask about this story

Loading…