Truth API suit: plaintiffs propose barring Harp and Scavino from posting for Trump
Plaintiffs suing over Truth API, a paid early-access service for Trump's Truth Social posts, say a court could bar aides Natalie Harp and Dan Scavino from posting for him. A hearing on the administration's motion to dismiss is set for Thursday.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Plaintiffs in a federal lawsuit over Truth API have proposed that the court could bar White House aides Natalie Harp and Dan Scavino from posting on President Donald Trump's Truth Social account. NewsweekN “if the court is unwilling or unable to directly restrict Trump's own posting activity, it could still reduce the alleged harm by ordering White House staff members, including Harp and Trump's deputy chief of staff Dan Scavino, to stop posting on Trump's behalf.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Raw StoryL “even if the judge declines to restrict Trump’s own posts, he could still order Harp and Scavino to stop posting for him.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Mixed · 2The proposal appears in a brief the plaintiffs filed on Friday, 13 November. The plaintiffs include The Intercept and the Freedom of the Press Foundation. Raw StoryL “The Intercept and the Freedom of the Press Foundation said in a brief filed Friday.” Read at Raw Story ↗ NewsweekN “In a filing submitted on Friday, the plaintiffs argued” Read at Newsweek ↗ Mixed · 2Truth API is a premium subscription service that gives paying subscribers earlier access to certain posts from Trump's Truth Social account. According to the filing, it can cost as much as $100,000 a month. NewsweekN “Truth API subscriptions can cost as much as $100,000 per month, according to the filing” Read at Newsweek ↗ Raw StoryL “a subscription service that costs up to $100,000 a month and gives paying customers faster access to Trump’s posts” Read at Raw Story ↗
Mixed · 2The plaintiffs say Harp and Scavino regularly post on Trump's behalf and account for a share of the official announcements on Truth Social. They argue that stopping them would mean fewer government updates reach paying customers first. NewsweekN “plaintiffs say she is among the aides, alongside Scavino, who "regularly" publish posts to Trump's Truth Social account.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Raw StoryL “stopping them from posting would mean fewer government updates going to paying customers first.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Centre · 1The plaintiffs argue that Trump's Truth Social posts are official government communications and that subscribers gain an unfair advantage from early access to "market-moving" announcements. They also say his exclusive use of the platform for certain announcements drives demand for the service. NewsweekN “paying subscribers receive an unfair advantage when they gain access to "market-moving" presidential announcements before the public.”“Trump's exclusive use of Truth Social for certain official announcements helps drive demand for the API service” Read at Newsweek ↗ Left · 1The suit was filed in August. At that time Intercept editor-in-chief Ben Muessig said, "Trump is trying to enrich himself by privatizing government information that he has no right to sell." Raw StoryL ““Trump is trying to enrich himself by privatizing government information that he has no right to sell,” Intercept editor-in-chief Ben Muessig said when the groups filed suit in August.” Read at Raw Story ↗
Centre · 1The administration is seeking dismissal. It argues that the subscription model does not violate the Constitution and that the court cannot meaningfully redress the alleged injuries. NewsweekN “arguing the court cannot meaningfully redress the plaintiffs' alleged injuries and that the platform's subscription model does not violate constitutional protections.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Left · 1Trump Media has defended the service. It says presidential communications already reach the public through many platforms and news outlets, including some that sell subscription access. Raw StoryL “Trump Media has defended the service, saying presidential communications already reach the public through many platforms and news outlets, including some that sell subscription access.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Mixed · 2U.S. District Judge J. Paul Oetken is expected to hear arguments on Thursday, 19 November, on the motion to dismiss, including whether the plaintiffs have standing. If the case proceeds, the dispute could turn to who posts on Trump's behalf and how the White House releases official news. NewsweekN “U.S. District Judge J. Paul Oetken is expected to hear arguments on Thursday as the court considers whether the case can move forward.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Raw StoryL “If Oetken lets the case proceed, the fight could turn to who posts on Trump’s behalf and how the White House releases official news through his platform” Read at Raw Story ↗
Centre · 1Newsweek said it had contacted the attorney for Trump and Harp and the attorney for Trump Media for comment. NewsweekN “Newsweek has contacted the attorney for Trump and Harp and the attorney for Trump Media for comment via email.” Read at Newsweek ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Raw Story summarises Newsweek's report with a dramatic headline suggesting Harp's posting role may end, and quotes the Intercept editor's accusation of self-enrichment.
- Emphasis
- Harp's role, the Intercept editor's criticism of Trump, and the posting proposal.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Gives little detail on the administration's legal arguments and does not note the request for comment from Trump's and Harp's attorney.
- Charged language
- “reign”“crashing halt”“Trump is trying to enrich himself by privatizing government information”
- For example
-
““Trump is trying to enrich himself by privatizing government information that he has no right to sell,” Intercept editor-in-chief Ben Muessig said when the groups filed suit in August.” — Raw Story
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Newsweek reports the filing as a procedural development, describing the proposed remedy and the stakes for White House communications.
- Emphasis
- The remedy proposal, the case's legal arguments, the plaintiffs' reasoning and the administration's dismissal arguments.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not include Trump Media's public defence or the Intercept editor's August statement.
- Charged language
- “market-moving”
- For example
-
“The dispute centers on whether government information should reach paying subscribers before other news organizations and members of the public.” — Newsweek
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Plaintiffs including The Intercept filed a brief on Friday proposing that Harp and Scavino could be ordered to stop posting for Trump.
- Truth API costs up to $100,000 a month and gives paying subscribers earlier access to Trump's posts.
- Judge J. Paul Oetken is due to hear the administration's motion to dismiss on Thursday, including the standing question.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether the court can remedy the alleged harm and whether the service is lawful
- Left
- Raw Story gives the administration's position briefly, alongside Trump Media's defence and the Intercept editor's charge that Trump is 'privatizing government information'.
- Centre
- Newsweek reports the administration's argument that the court cannot meaningfully redress the injuries and that the model does not violate constitutional protections, against the plaintiffs' claim of unfair advantage.
Natalie Harp person
Harp is named by the plaintiffs as an aide who regularly posts on Trump's account; the coverage carries no statement from her.
“Harp features prominently in the new filing because plaintiffs say she is among the aides, alongside Scavino, who "regularly" publish posts” — Newsweek
Donald Trump person
Trump is the target of the suit; the administration argues the service is constitutional and the harm cannot be remedied by the court, and Trump Media defends the service.
“The administration is seeking to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing the court cannot meaningfully redress the plaintiffs' alleged injuries” — Newsweek
“Trump Media has defended the service” — Raw Story
Left1 article
-
Natalie Harp's Truth Social reign could come to a crashing halt in court
Mixed Aggregates Newsweek with a dramatic headline and a pointed plaintiff quote against Trump.

Centre1 article
-
Natalie Harp Could Be Banned From Using Trump's Social Account: Lawsuit
Neutral Straight report of the filing, the remedy proposed and both sides' legal arguments.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 16 Nov 16:50 First NewsweekN Natalie Harp Could Be Banned From Using Trump's Social Account: Lawsuit
- 16 Nov 18:19 +1h 29m Raw StoryL Natalie Harp's Truth Social reign could come to a crashing halt in court
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…