Report says two church charities got $62M to resettle Somalis in Minnesota
The New York Post reported that Catholic Charities and Lutheran Social Services took in at least $62 million in resettlement funding tied to Somali arrivals in Minnesota. Breitbart repeated the figure with much sharper language. Both are right-leaning outlets, and both draw on one expert, Parker Thayer of the Capital Research Center.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Right · 1The New York Post reported on 16 October 2026 that Catholic Charities and Lutheran Social Services had taken in at least $62 million to build the Somali community in Minnesota. New York PostR “Two church non-profits have taken in at least $62 million to build the Somali community in Minnesota” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 2The Post said the two groups have resettled an estimated 29,000 Somalis in Minnesota since 1993, collecting a reported $2,500 per refugee for costs such as food, initial housing and social workers. New York PostR “The two church groups have resettled an estimated 29,000 Somalians into Minnesota since 1993, collecting a reported $2,500 per refugee” Read at New York Post ↗ BreitbartR “Since 1993, these two massive groups have resettled more than 29,000 Somalians into Minnesota and earned $2,500 in tax dollars per “refugee.”” Read at Breitbart ↗ Right · 1Parker Thayer of the Washington-based Capital Research Center is the main source in both articles. He said total money going into Minneapolis resettlement programs alone is "in the hundreds of millions", and that since 2021 the US Conference of Catholic Bishops, which oversees Catholic Charities, has received $140 million in migrant resettlement contracts from the federal government. New York PostR “He added the total money pouring into Minneapolis resettlement programs alone is “in the hundreds of millions.””“since 2021, the US Conference of Catholic Bishops, the body overseeing Catholic Charities, has received $140 million in migrant resettlement contracts from the federal government.” Read at New York Post ↗
Right · 2Thayer said Minnesota was chosen because of its generous state safety net and welfare programmes, and that some Somali refugees moved there after being placed elsewhere, such as South Dakota. He also said some people claiming refugee status travel back to Somalia, citing Facebook pages and indictments; the articles give no figures for this. New York PostR ““They picked Minnesota because it had extremely generous state social safety net policies and welfare programs, which of course made resettling refugees there easier,”” Read at New York Post ↗ BreitbartR “you look at their Facebook pages, or you look at indictments and find that they routinely travel out of the US back to the place they are supposedly a refugee from,”” Read at Breitbart ↗ Right · 1The Post said the Somali population in Minnesota is now over 100,000, which it attributed to family reunification ("chain migration") and the state's welfare system. New York PostR “The population today is over 100,000 in Minnesota according to data, thanks to chain migration” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1The Post links the resettlement to the rise of Rep. Ilhan Omar and to Minnesota's fraud scandals. It cites an estimated $9 billion in welfare fraud, "largely stemming from the Somali community", and says federal immigration officials raided Omar's home on the Monday before publication as part of a criminal investigation. These are the Post's statements, and the article does not show that the two charities caused the fraud. New York PostR “leading to the rise of Ilhan Omar and the fraud scandals that have gripped that state”“$9 billion in estimated welfare fraud, largely stemming from the Somali community”“was raided by federal immigration officials as part of a criminal investigation” Read at New York Post ↗
Right · 1As background, the Post describes Minnesota's earlier role as a hub for Hmong refugees, backed by Walter Mondale and Gov. Al Quie. It says Catholic Charities and Lutheran Social Services (now called Global Refuge) had run resettlement since World War II, first funded largely from the pews and later by government contracts. New York PostR “Catholic Charities and Lutheran Social Services — the latter now called Global Refuge — had built an extensive resettlement operation as far back as World War II”“their operations were largely funded from the pews, not Uncle Sam” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1Kelsey Reinhardt, president of CatholicVote, told the Post that the gospel mandates welcoming strangers but not "unbridled welcoming", and that questions about vetting and assimilation should be asked. Thayer said the controversy may hurt the groups' fundraising. New York PostR “The gospel mandates the welcoming of strangers but there’s no unbridled welcoming of people”“It is hurting the ability of these organizations to fundraise in arguably more important areas of their work.” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1A spokesperson for Catholic Charities Twin Cities told the Post the group closed its refugee and immigrant programmes in 2018. Lutheran Social Services of Minnesota did not respond to a request for comment. New York PostR “A spokesperson for Catholic Charities Twin Cities said they closed their refugee and immigrant programs in 2018.” Read at New York Post ↗
Right · 1Breitbart, citing the Post, wrote that the groups "exploited" government contracts and were instrumental in making Minnesota one of the worst places for fraud in the US. It described the $140 million as money to bring Somalis into Minnesota, whereas the Post attributes it to nationwide resettlement contracts since 2021. BreitbartR “Catholic Charities and Lutheran Social Services exploited high-dollar government contracts and were instrumental in turning Minnesota into one of worst localities for fraud in America.”“also raked in an astounding $140 million from the federal government to bring Somalians into Minnesota, the New York Post reported.” Read at Breitbart ↗ Right · 1Breitbart added that several resettlement charities have begun laying off staff as donations fell and the Trump administration cut off government funding, and that Catholic Charities laid off hundreds of workers earlier this year. It also said the Mormon Church donated $5 million in 2021 toward refugee resettlement. BreitbartR “Catholic Charities, in particular, laid off hundreds of workers earlier this year in offices across the country.”“In 2021, for instance, the church donated $5 million to help resettle foreign “refugees” into the U.S.” Read at Breitbart ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets present the money as an exposé of church charities profiting from Somali resettlement and tie it to Minnesota's fraud scandals. The Post uses a reported, quote-driven format. Breitbart is openly polemical and adds religious charges.
- Emphasis
- Government money flowing to the charities, the per-refugee payment, welfare fraud, Ilhan Omar, and the Trump-era funding cuts and layoffs (Breitbart).
- Leaves out or plays down
- Breitbart leaves out the Catholic Charities Twin Cities statement that it closed its refugee programmes in 2018, and the Post's Hmong history. Neither article includes a response from the groups or critics of the claims, apart from that one statement. Neither shows evidence that the charities caused the fraud.
- Charged language
- “Somali central”“gob-smacking”“Progressive 'Christian' Groups”“exploited”“raked in”“a religious Reich”“free government money”
- For example
-
“leading to the rise of Ilhan Omar and the fraud scandals that have gripped that state, The Post can reveal.” — New York Post
“precipitating a wave of theft, fraud, gang activity, crime and tribalism.” — Breitbart
“importing a religious Reich that would sooner see Catholicism and Lutheranism destroyed” — Breitbart
What every side reports
- Catholic Charities and Lutheran Social Services took in at least $62 million in connection with Somali resettlement in Minnesota.
- The two groups have resettled an estimated 29,000 Somalis in Minnesota since 1993, with a reported $2,500 per refugee.
- More than 100,000 Somalis live in Minnesota.
- Parker Thayer of the Capital Research Center is the main source in both articles.
Where accounts differ
-
What the $140 million paid to the US Conference of Catholic Bishops was for
- Right
- The Post says it covers migrant resettlement contracts since 2021. Breitbart says it was to bring Somalis into Minnesota.
-
Whether the charities are responsible for Minnesota's fraud and crime
- Right
- The Post links the resettlement to fraud scandals and the rise of Ilhan Omar. Breitbart states outright that it caused theft, fraud, gang activity, crime and tribalism. Neither article presents evidence of that causal link or a response from the charities beyond the Catholic Charities Twin Cities statement.
Somali refugee resettlement in Minnesota topic
The Post presents resettlement as a generously funded, church-run system that grew into a large Somali community, with fraud and cultural problems. Breitbart goes further and says it is an Islamic takeover project. Neither includes a Somali community voice.
“Catholic Charities and Lutheran Social Services were at the forefront of reshaping the frigid Land of 10,000 Lakes” — New York Post
“now they work to push Muslims into the U.S. and other western nations” — Breitbart
Minnesota place
Both outlets portray Minnesota as drawn in by its generous welfare system and as a centre of fraud. The Post cites $9 billion in estimated welfare fraud.
“Minnesota has been a flashpoint in the controversial effort” — New York Post
“one of worst localities for fraud in America” — Breitbart
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right2 articles
-
Two Christian groups were paid $62M to resettle tens of thousands of Somalis in Minnesota
Critical Investigative-style piece that ties church charities' government-funded resettlement work to Somali population growth, welfare fraud and Ilhan Omar, quoting a think-tank researcher and a Catholic advocate.
-
Progressive 'Christian' Groups Earned $62M to Settle Muslim Somalians In Minnesota
Alarmist Aggregates the Post report into a polemic accusing 'Christian' charities of exploiting contracts and importing Muslims, with religious and crime accusations stated in the outlet's own voice.
- 16 Oct 11:00 First New York PostR Two Christian groups were paid $62M to resettle tens of thousands of Somalis in Minnesota
- 16 Oct 17:26 +6h 26m BreitbartR Progressive 'Christian' Groups Earned $62M to Settle Muslim Somalians In Minnesota
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…