Two Colorado college students died when climbing anchor failed, sheriff says
The Chaffee County Sheriff's Office said Colorado Mountain College students Kaden Matsuda, 19, and Jackson Donlon, 20, died instantly in a fall after a rappel anchor failed for an unknown reason. The snowstorm was not a direct factor.
Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from Fox News, NBC News.
1 / 4
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2The Chaffee County Sheriff's Office and coroner's office said on Tuesday that two Colorado college students found dead last week died when an anchor they were using failed and they fell a "substantial distance." ABC NewsLC “died when an anchor they were using to climb failed and they fell a “substantial distance,” authorities said Tuesday.” Read at ABC News ↗ New York PostR ““fell a substantial distance” and landed in a mountain basin after their equipment malfunctioned last week” Read at New York Post ↗ Mixed · 2The victims were Kaden Matsuda, 19, of Ridgway, Colorado, and Jackson Donlon, 20, of Queensbury, New York, students at Colorado Mountain College's Leadville campus. ABC NewsLC “Matsuda, of Ridgway, Colorado, and Donlon, of Queensbury, New York, became fast friends at the small campus in Leadville” Read at ABC News ↗ New York PostR “Colorado Mountain College Leadville students Jackson Donlon, a 20-year-old Upstate New York native, and Kaden Matsuda, 19” Read at New York Post ↗ Mixed · 2An autopsy found they died instantly of multiple blunt force injuries, and the sheriff's office said neither suffered. New York PostR ““The autopsy showed that the cause of both their deaths was multiple blunt force injuries and their deaths were instant,”” Read at New York Post ↗ ABC NewsLC “died instantly from multiple blunt force injuries, an autopsy found” Read at ABC News ↗
Mixed · 2According to the statement, Donlon was beginning to rappel from a primary anchor point on a rock, apparently backed up by a piton and a secondary anchor, when it had a "catastrophic failure of unknown cause"; Matsuda was attached to the same anchor points. New York PostR “The anchor had a catastrophic failure of unknown cause. Both then fell a substantial distance,”” Read at New York Post ↗ ABC NewsLC “despite being backed up by a metal spike in the rock and a secondary anchor” Read at ABC News ↗ Mixed · 2Fox News, citing the sheriff's findings and AP, wrote that authorities identified a rock securing the rappelling equipment as the likely point of failure; the other outlets repeat the sheriff's wording that the cause of the anchor failure is unknown. Fox NewsR “saying a rock securing their rappelling equipment likely gave way during their descents” Read at Fox News ↗ NBC NewsLC “Authorities said the two men fell after their anchor had a “catastrophic failure of unknown cause.”” Read at NBC News ↗ Mixed · 2The exact distance of the fall is unknown, and the bodies were found in a snow-filled basin of West Apostle Mountain, about 100 miles southeast of Aspen. ABC NewsLC “Their bodies were found in a snow-filled basin of West Apostle Mountain, about 100 miles (160 kilometers) southeast of Aspen.” Read at ABC News ↗ New York PostR “stressing that the “exact distance” they plummeted is “unknown.”” Read at New York Post ↗
Left · 1The pair had set out from campus for a weekend trip aiming for Ice Mountain (13,958 feet); Sheriff Andy Rohrich said they appeared to switch to West Apostle Mountain (13,597 feet). ABC NewsLC “While they were originally aiming for Ice Mountain, a 13,958-foot (4,254-meter) peak, Rohrich said they appeared to switch to the 13,597-foot (4,144-meter) West Apostle Mountain.” Read at ABC News ↗ Mixed · 2A severe storm dumped up to 2 feet of snow, but the sheriff's office said the storm was not a direct factor in the deaths; it is unknown whether it had any other effect. ABC NewsLC “the heavy snowstorm was not a direct factor, according to the statement” Read at ABC News ↗ New York PostR ““It is unknown if the heavy snowstorm had a negative impact leading to the incident, but it did not play a direct contributing factor in their death,”” Read at New York Post ↗ Left · 1Rohrich said the students were prepared, saying that unlike in many similar cases it was not easy to "pick apart what was done wrong." ABC NewsLC ““In most similar cases that have led to a devastating conclusion we find it easy to pick apart what was done wrong,” said Chaffee County Sheriff Andy Rohrich. “That was not the case with Kaden and Jackson.”” Read at ABC News ↗
Right · 1Before the bodies were found, searchers located the students' tent collapsed under snow with sleeping bags, a stove and clothes inside, and Matsuda's car parked at a nearby trail. New York PostR “Prior to their bodies being found, the hikers’ tent was found collapsed under the snow.”“Matsuda’s car was found parked on a nearby trail with around eight inches of snow around it.” Read at New York Post ↗ Left · 1NBC News reported that the students were reported missing on Oct. 26, three days after leaving campus, and that friends and family described them as experienced climbers who should have been properly dressed and had shared a map of their route. NBC NewsLC “The two were reported missing Oct. 26, three days after they left campus for a hike on Colorado’s Ice Mountain.”“The pair were experienced climbers and should have been properly dressed and shared a map of their route” Read at NBC News ↗ Left · 1The sheriff's office also noted that Ice Mountain is a very technical climb, recommended only for very experienced hikers even when dry. NBC NewsLC ““Ice Mountain is a very technical climb, and it is recommended that hikers be very experienced when trying to tackle it,”” Read at NBC News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- AP copy carried by ABC News and NBC News's own report give a measured account of the sheriff's findings, with background on the students, their college and the terrain.
- Emphasis
- The students' preparation, the sheriff's tribute, the switch of peaks (ABC/AP), and NBC's missing-person timeline and note that Ice Mountain is technical.
- Leaves out or plays down
- ABC does not mention the collapsed tent or the parked car; NBC does not mention the piton and secondary anchor detail.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- New York Post leads with the dramatic cause of death; Fox News frames the finding as authorities pinpointing a likely cause, a rock giving way, and adds other recent climbing deaths.
- Emphasis
- The NY Post quotes the sheriff's technical description and the search scene; Fox stresses the rock as likely failure point, no obvious preparation mistakes, and links to other fatal climbing accidents.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The NY Post does not mention the switch to West Apostle Mountain; Fox does not mention the collapsed tent or the parked car.
- For example
-
“Authorities have identified the likely cause of a fatal fall that killed two college students in the Colorado mountains last week” — Fox News
“Horrific cause of death revealed for college students who went missing on Ice Mountain climb” — New York Post
What every side reports
- Matsuda, 19, and Donlon, 20, died in a fall after an anchor failed for an unknown reason.
- The autopsy found multiple blunt force injuries and instant death.
- The snowstorm was not a direct contributing factor, according to the sheriff's office.
- The exact length of the fall is unknown.
Where accounts differ
-
Cause of the anchor failure
- Left
- Reports the anchor failed for an unknown cause.
- Right
- NY Post repeats unknown cause; Fox says a rock securing the equipment likely gave way.
-
The anchor failed for an unknown cause.
Reported- Disputes 1
- Fox News
- Reports 3
- ABC News, NBC News, New York Post
-
The snowstorm was not a direct factor in the deaths.
Reported- Reports 4
- ABC News, NBC News, Fox News, New York Post
-
The students apparently switched from Ice Mountain to West Apostle Mountain.
Reported- Supports 1
- New York Post
- Reports 2
- ABC News, Fox News
Left2 articles
-
ABC NewsLC · · via AP
College students found dead in mountains fell to deaths when climbing anchor broke
Sympathetic AP wire copy giving the sheriff's findings plus humanising background on the two students.

-
Colorado college students fell ‘substantial distance’ to their deaths, officials say
Sympathetic NBC's own report relays the sheriff's findings and tribute, adding the missing-person timeline and the mountain's technical difficulty.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right2 articles
-
Horrific cause of death revealed for college students who went missing on Ice Mountain climb
Alarmist Sensational headline and wording around the cause of death, with extended quotes from the sheriff's statement.

-
Authorities pinpoint likely cause of 2 students' deaths after plunge off mountainside
Neutral Fox presents the sheriff's findings as pinpointing a likely cause (a rock giving way), relying on AP, and appends other recent climbing deaths.

- 4 Nov 01:54 First ABC NewsLC College students found dead in mountains fell to deaths when climbing anchor broke via AP
- 4 Nov 12:32 +10h 38m New York PostR Horrific cause of death revealed for college students who went missing on Ice Mountain climb
- 4 Nov 15:07 +13h 14m NBC NewsLC Colorado college students fell ‘substantial distance’ to their deaths, officials say
- 5 Nov 19:45 +41h 51m Fox NewsR Authorities pinpoint likely cause of 2 students' deaths after plunge off mountainside
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…