Two men jailed for six years for 2023 rape of woman in Dungannon car park
Luis Dos Martins Mariano and Alcino Soares, both from Dungannon, County Tyrone, were each sentenced to six years, half in custody and half on licence, for raping a 19-year-old woman in an underground car park in September 2023. Both had pleaded guilty and were aged 17 at the time.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Two men have been jailed for raping a woman in an underground car park in Dungannon, County Tyrone. BBC NewsN “Two men have been jailed for raping a woman in an underground car park in County Tyrone.” Read at BBC News ↗ The Irish TimesLC “Two men who raped a teenager in an underground car park in Co Tyrone have been jailed.” Read at The Irish Times ↗ Luis Dos Martins Mariano, 20, of Sloan Street, and Alcino Soares, 21, of Braeside, both in Dungannon, each received six years, with half to be served in custody and half on licence; both had pleaded guilty, and both moved to Northern Ireland from East Timor when younger. BBC NewsN “the judge sentenced both men to six years, three of those will be served in prison and three out on license.” Read at BBC News ↗ The Irish TimesLC “They were sentenced to six years’ imprisonment, to be served equally between custody and on licence.” Read at The Irish Times ↗ The rape happened on 10 September 2023, when both men were 17 and the victim was 19; some of it was recorded on CCTV. BBC NewsN “The rape took place on 10 September 2023 when both men were 17 and some of it was recorded on CCTV. The victim was 19 at the time.” Read at BBC News ↗
The BBC reports the sentence was passed at Downpatrick Crown Court, with both men appearing by video link from Hydebank prison, after an earlier hearing at Dungannon Crown Court on 3 September 2026. BBC NewsN “At Downpatrick Crown Court on Thursday the judge sentenced both men to six years”“Both men appeared in court via video link from Hydebank prison.” Read at BBC News ↗ The court heard the victim had been on a night out, was approached by two males and was walked, one on either side, to the car park; the BBC says she was "quite drunk" and could not stand or talk properly. BBC NewsN “The victim recalled she had difficulty standing and could not talk properly.” Read at BBC News ↗ The Irish TimesLC “She had been out with friends when the males approached and walked her – one on either side – to the empty car park.” Read at The Irish Times ↗ According to the Irish Times account of the court hearing, Mariano raped her while Soares watched and kept look-out, Soares then raped her, and Mariano filmed on his phone; the BBC's account of the prosecution case says one man raped her while the other kept watch and she was raped again in a corner of the car park. The Irish TimesLC “Mariano laughed while videoing the attack on his phone, before Soares walked away, leaving the victim on the ground.” Read at The Irish Times ↗ BBC NewsN “the victim said one of the males "started to rape" her while the other male kept watch and "stood laughing".” Read at BBC News ↗
Soares was arrested after police received reports he was following women and filming them; his DNA matched that on the victim's clothes, and he told police the sex was consensual. Mariano was arrested a week later and a detective described him as the "instigator". The Irish TimesLC “His DNA matched that found on the victim’s clothes.”“Mariano was arrested a week later. He was described in court by a detective as the “instigator”.” Read at The Irish Times ↗ Mariano admitted rape in March 2025 while Soares initially pleaded not guilty; just before Soares was due to stand trial in October 2025 he changed his plea to guilty. BBC NewsN “just before Soares was due to stand trial, in October 2025 he pleaded guilty to rape.” Read at BBC News ↗ The Irish TimesLC “Mariano admitted rape in March 2025 at Dungannon Crown Court and was remanded in custody, while Soares pleaded not guilty.” Read at The Irish Times ↗ Judge Richard Green (spelled Greene by the Irish Times) called the CCTV "disturbing viewing", described a "prolonged and humiliating ordeal" and a "cowardly attack", said the car park choice showed planning, and commended the victim's bravery. BBC NewsN “"makes for disturbing viewing"” Read at BBC News ↗ The Irish TimesLC “They knew the car park would be deserted which shows an element of planning.” Read at The Irish Times ↗
In sentencing, the judge took into account the men's young age at the time, learning difficulties, guilty pleas, delays and time already spent in custody; defence barristers cited a moderate learning disability for Mariano and a language deficit for Soares, and said both had apologised. BBC NewsN “he took into account their young age at the time of offending, their learning difficulties, the fact they had both entered guilty pleas, delays to the case and time they had already spent in prison.”“an expert report had found that Mariano had a "moderate learning disability".” Read at BBC News ↗ The Irish Times adds that both were assessed as medium risk of reoffending but not dangerous, and that the judge said they "blamed the victim, minimised and justified their actions"; the judge said he did not intend to differentiate between the defendants. The Irish TimesLC “Both Soares and Mariano were classed as medium risk of reoffending”“I do not intend to differentiate between either defendant.” Read at The Irish Times ↗ Both men must stay on the sex offenders register for life; the BBC reports they are disqualified from working with children and young adults, and the Irish Times reports 10-year Sexual Offences Prevention Orders. BBC NewsN “Both men were ordered to be on the sex offenders register for life.” Read at BBC News ↗ The Irish TimesLC “made subject to Sexual Offences Prevention Orders for 10 years.” Read at The Irish Times ↗
PSNI Ch Insp Steph Finlay called it an "appalling and deeply distressing attack" and said the sentences "hold both men accountable for their actions". BBC NewsN “She said the sentences "hold both men accountable for their actions".” Read at BBC News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Court report naming the defendants in the lede and focusing on the offence narrative, police evidence and the judge's assessment of the men's attitudes.
- Emphasis
- Sequence of the attack, DNA and Soares's denial, risk assessments, lack of empathy and the judge's refusal to differentiate between them.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Leaves out the defendants' learning difficulties and language deficit cited in mitigation, the police statement, and where sentencing took place.
- Charged language
- “cowardly attack”“instigator”
- For example
-
“Alcino Soares and Luis Dos Martins Mariano each sentenced to six years for 2023 Dungannon attack” — The Irish Times
“they “blamed the victim, minimised and justified their actions”” — The Irish Times
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Straight court report led by the sentence and the defendants' ages at the time, with the CCTV, then a long recap of the earlier hearing.
- Emphasis
- Judge's remarks, defence mitigation (learning disability, language deficit, remorse) and the police statement.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the filming on a phone, DNA evidence, Soares's claim of consent, risk assessments and the 10-year preventative orders.
- Charged language
- “predatory, degrading”
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Mariano (20) and Soares (21), both of Dungannon, were each sentenced to six years, split equally between custody and licence.
- The rape took place on 10 September 2023 in an underground car park in Dungannon; the victim was 19.
- Both men moved to Northern Ireland from East Timor when younger and both pleaded guilty.
- CCTV captured the incident.
- Both are on the sex offenders register for life.
- The judge called the attack cowardly and prolonged, noted planning, and praised the victim's bravery.
Where accounts differ
-
Details of the attack and the judge's name
- Left
- Irish Times: Mariano raped her first while Soares kept look-out, then Soares raped her and Mariano filmed it; the judge is Richard Greene; sentencing court not named.
- Centre
- BBC: one man started to rape her while the other kept watch; the judge is Richard Green; sentencing at Downpatrick Crown Court.
Rape case underground car park topic
The court and police describe a planned, degrading attack on an intoxicated young woman; the defence stressed youth, cognitive and language difficulties and remorse, which the judge weighed in sentencing.
“Soares apologised and had "accepted his wrongdoing and his remorse".” — BBC News
Left1 article
-
Two men who raped teenager in underground car park jailed
Neutral Offence-focused report stressing the evidence, the defendants' attitudes and the judge's refusal to distinguish between them.

Centre1 article
-
Two men jailed for raping woman in underground car park
Neutral Detailed procedural report balancing the judge's condemnation, prosecution account, defence mitigation and police comment.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 1 Oct 14:38 First BBC NewsN Two men jailed for raping woman in underground car park
- 1 Oct 19:10 +4h 31m The Irish TimesLC Two men who raped teenager in underground car park jailed
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.