UK MPs and MSP say Israel held them eight hours, then denied West Bank entry
Labour MP Clive Lewis, SNP MP Lara Bird and Scottish Greens MSP Kate Nevens say Israeli authorities held them for eight hours and turned them away from the West Bank. The Israeli embassy and the Foreign Office had been contacted for comment.
Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from Anadolu Agency, GB News.
1 / 4
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 2Two MPs and an MSP say Israeli authorities detained them for eight hours and denied them access to the West Bank. Evening StandardN “Two MPs and an MSP have claimed they were detained for eight hours by Israeli authorities and denied access to the West Bank.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ BBC NewsN “Two MPs and an MSP have said they were detained by Israeli authorities for eight hours while trying to enter the West Bank.” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 1They are Labour MP Clive Lewis, SNP MP Lara Bird and Scottish Greens MSP Kate Nevens. They tried to enter on Monday as part of a delegation organised by Progressive International. Evening StandardN “Labour’s Clive Lewis and the SNP’s Lara Bird, along with Kate Nevens of the Scottish Greens, sought to access the territory on Monday as part of a delegation organised by political group Progressive International.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 2The delegation also included former Labour MP Sam Tarry and a former member of the Basque senate, described by the Evening Standard as Spanish Senator Josu Estarrona Elizondo. Bird said the group had 23 members. Evening StandardN “the group – which also included former MP Sam Tarry and Spanish Senator Josu Estarrona Elizondo” Read at Evening Standard ↗ BBC NewsN “the 23-strong group was "interrogated and ultimately prevented from crossing the border"” Read at BBC News ↗
Centre · 1According to Progressive International, the group was stopped while crossing from Jordan. It had planned meetings with Palestinian academics, students and civil society organisations, and to join the olive harvest after what the organisation describes as "mounting attacks" on farmers. Evening StandardN “was stopped while making the crossing from Jordan and had planned to undertake “a programme of meetings with Palestinian academics, students and civil society organisations”” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 2Lewis said in a post on X that the group was held and interrogated for more than eight hours and made to feel as though they had done something wrong. He said they had done nothing wrong and went to show solidarity with Palestinians. He also said they knew crossing risked detention, interrogation and being turned away. Evening StandardN ““For more than eight hours, we were held, interrogated and made to feel as though we had done something wrong simply by attempting to enter.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ BBC NewsN “We knew that by crossing into the occupied Palestinian territories, we risked being detained, interrogated and turned away by Israeli authorities.” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 1Bird, who was elected this year for Arbroath and Broughty Ferry, said they were turned away with no reason given. She said she had come to stand with Palestinians attacked while harvesting olives, and accused the IDF and settlers of violence against Palestinians. Evening StandardN “Instead, we were turned away, with no reason given.”“Palestinians are being subject to terror and violence by the IDF and illegal settlers.” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Centre · 2Nevens called the experience "frightening" but said the group was able to "leave safely". She said it was a small fraction of what Palestinians face at the same border, and that Israeli forces did not want them to see demolished homes or settler violence. BBC NewsN “Nevens described the experience as "frightening" but added that the group was able to "leave safely".” Read at BBC News ↗ Evening StandardN “The Israeli forces didn’t want us to see the demolished homes, or the settlers inflicting so much misery” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 3The BBC, Anadolu Agency and GB News report that the Israeli military announced on Monday that all West Bank land crossings would be closed as part of increased security measures during Tuesday's national elections. The Evening Standard says reports suggest the two MPs could have sought permission from the Israeli government. BBC NewsN “The Israeli military announced on Monday that all West Bank land crossings would be closed as part of increased security measures during Tuesday's national elections.” Read at BBC News ↗ Anadolu AgencyN “The incident came after the Israeli military announced on Monday that all West Bank land crossings would be closed” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ GB NewsR “despite the Israeli military announcing land crossings would be closed amid today's national election.” Read at GB News ↗ Centre · 1The BBC adds context: about 2,000 Palestinian residents have been displaced in Hebron in recent days, in what it describes as a reprisal for the killing of two Israeli soldiers by Palestinian gunmen. It also reports attacks on Palestinians during the olive harvest. An SNP spokesperson said the party was "proud to stand with the Palestinian people". BBC NewsN “About 2,000 Palestinian residents have been displaced in Hebron, a city in the southern West Bank, in recent days.”“A spokesperson for the SNP said the party was "proud to stand with the Palestinian people".” Read at BBC News ↗
Centre · 1Anadolu Agency, which says Bird and Nevens posted about the incident (Bird on Instagram), reports a larger Hebron figure: the Hebron municipality said 4,969 Palestinians from 780 families have been displaced from the Deir Bahha and Al-Jilda areas since the Israeli military campaign began on Friday, with the offensive in its fifth consecutive day. Anadolu AgencyN “4,969 Palestinians from 780 families have been forcibly displaced from the Deir Bahha and Al-Jilda areas since the Israeli military campaign began on Friday.”“The Israeli army continued a large-scale offensive in the West Bank city of Hebron for a fifth consecutive day on Tuesday” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ Right · 1GB News, which describes the operation as ordered by Benjamin Netanyahu after two Israeli soldiers were killed by two Palestinian gunmen at a checkpoint, also recalls that last year Labour MPs Abtisam Mohamed and Yuan Yang were denied entry to Israel, and says Israel has since banned more than a dozen public figures, including Zack Polanski and Jeremy Corbyn. GB NewsR “In a separate incident last year, Labour MPs Abtisam Mohamed and Yuan Yang were denied entrance to Israel.”“Benjamin Netanyahu announced a major operation on Friday in response to the killing of two Israeli soldiers by two Palestinian gunmen in an attack on a checkpoint” Read at GB News ↗ Centre · 3The BBC and Evening Standard say the Israeli embassy and the Foreign Office had been contacted for comment, and GB News says it approached the Foreign Office. No Israeli response is reported, so the reason for the refusal is unconfirmed beyond the closure announcement. BBC NewsN “The Israeli embassy and the Foreign Office have been contacted for comment.” Read at BBC News ↗ Evening StandardN “The Foreign Office and Israeli embassy has been contacted for comment.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ GB NewsR “GB News has approached the Foreign Office for comment.” Read at GB News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre3 outlets
- Framing
- The Evening Standard and BBC report the politicians' account as their own claims, and Anadolu Agency leads with the Scottish politicians' account and Nevens's quote, then places it alongside the Hebron offensive. Israeli and UK government comment had been sought by the Standard and BBC.
- Emphasis
- The Standard gives the delegation's aims and full statements. The BBC adds the crossing closures, Hebron displacements and olive-harvest attacks. Anadolu adds the municipality's displacement figure of 4,969 and footage of checkpoint searches.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No centre outlet carries an Israeli or Foreign Office response. The Standard omits the election-related crossing closure; the BBC omits the suggestion that the MPs could have sought Israeli permission; Anadolu does not mention Lewis's statement.
- Charged language
- “forcibly displaced”“terrifying reality”
- For example
-
“'What we experienced was only a small fraction of the terrifying reality Palestinians face,' says Scottish Greens MSP Kate Nevens” — Anadolu Agency
“Two MPs and an MSP have claimed they were detained for eight hours by Israeli authorities” — Evening Standard
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- GB News leads on Labour MP Clive Lewis, headlining his claim in quotation marks and saying he travelled despite the announced crossing closure, then adds earlier UK figures barred by Israel.
- Emphasis
- The announced closure of crossings, Lewis's and Bird's quotes, and prior bans of UK public figures such as Polanski and Corbyn.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Nevens, the Progressive International programme, or the olive-harvest plans beyond Bird's quote.
- Charged language
- “claimed he was detained”“diplomatic row”
- For example
-
“Norwich South MP Clive Lewis joined Progressive International's cross-party delegation to travel to the region despite the Israeli military announcing land crossings would be closed” — GB News
“However, a diplomatic row between the UK and Israel has resulted in authorities banning more than a dozen public figures.” — GB News
What every side reports
- Lewis, Bird and Nevens say they were held for eight hours by Israeli authorities and kept out of the West Bank.
- They were part of a Progressive International delegation that included ex-MP Sam Tarry and a Spanish/Basque former senator.
- The Israeli embassy and the Foreign Office had been contacted for comment.
Where accounts differ
-
Number of Palestinians displaced in Hebron
- Centre
- The BBC says about 2,000; Anadolu cites the Hebron municipality's figure of 4,969 people from 780 families.
- Right
- GB News says around 2,000 West Bank residents have been displaced.
-
Whether the crossing was foreseeably closed
- Centre
- The BBC and Anadolu note the closure announcement; the Standard says reports suggest MPs could have sought Israeli permission.
- Right
- GB News says the delegation travelled despite the announced closure.
-
The UK politicians were detained by Israeli authorities for about eight hours before being denied entry to the West Bank.
Reported- Reports 4
- Anadolu Agency, BBC News, Evening Standard, GB News
-
All West Bank land crossings were closed during Israel's national election.
Reported- Reports 3
- Anadolu Agency, BBC News, GB News
-
Roughly 2,000 Palestinians have been displaced in Hebron in the recent Israeli operation.
Reported- Disputes 1
- Anadolu Agency
- Reports 2
- BBC News, GB News
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre3 articles
-
MPs and MSP claim they were denied access to West Bank
Neutral Presents the delegation's claims and quotes at length, with a note that the MPs may have sought Israeli permission, and awaits comment.

-
MPs and MSP detained by Israel and barred from entering West Bank
Neutral Reports the detention as the politicians' account and sets it against Israel's election-related crossing closures and West Bank violence.

-
Scottish politicians say Israeli officials detained them for 8 hours
Sympathetic Reports the Scottish politicians' account and ties it to Palestinian hardship at the border and the Hebron offensive.

Right1 article
-
GB NewsR ·
Labour MP 'detained for eight hours' after being denied access to West Bank
Critical Presents Lewis's detention as his claim, stresses he went despite the announced closure, and adds a list of UK figures banned by Israel.

- 27 Oct 09:35 First Evening StandardN MPs and MSP claim they were denied access to West Bank
- 27 Oct 10:11 +36m BBC NewsN MPs and MSP detained by Israel and barred from entering West Bank
- 27 Oct 11:18 +1h 42m Anadolu AgencyN Scottish politicians say Israeli officials detained them for 8 hours
- 27 Oct 11:40 +2h 5m GB NewsR Labour MP 'detained for eight hours' after being denied access to West Bank
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…