UK nears Skynet satellite contract decision, with Lockheed Martin reported as favoured over Airbus
The Ministry of Defence is reported to favour US firm Lockheed Martin over Airbus for the next-generation Skynet military satellites, a contract valued at £2bn to £2.4bn. Sovereignty, jobs and Airbus's lobbying are at issue, and the MoD says no final decision has been made.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2The Ministry of Defence is reported to be close to awarding the Skynet next-generation military satellite contract, worth up to £2bn according to GB News and £2.4bn according to the Guardian, to US contractor Lockheed Martin rather than Airbus. GB NewsR “The Ministry of Defence is on the verge of awarding a contract worth up to £2billion for Britain's next-generation Skynet military satellites to American defence contractor Lockheed Martin.” Read at GB News ↗ The GuardianLC “intensifying a last-minute lobbying effort for the £2.4bn contract” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2The decision rests with Prime Minister Andy Burnham; GB News says Downing Street has stepped in to examine the MoD's recommendation, while the Guardian says the final call lies with Burnham and the chancellor, John Healey. GB NewsR “Downing Street has already stepped in to examine the MoD's recommendation, with Prime Minister Andy Burnham expected to make the ultimate decision.” Read at GB News ↗ The GuardianLC “The final decision will rest with Burnham and the chancellor, John Healey.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2The Guardian's sources said no final decision had been made, though some believed the MoD preferred Lockheed Martin's bid. The MoD told GB News it had not reached a final decision and that both UK-based bidders were being fully evaluated. The GuardianLC “Several sources said they believed no final decision on the contract had been made. However, some said they believed that Lockheed Martin’s bid was preferred by the Ministry of Defence.” Read at The Guardian ↗ GB NewsR “The MoD maintains that it has not reached a final decision, emphasising that both UK-based bidders are undergoing full evaluation” Read at GB News ↗
Left · 1The Skynet 6 satellites would carry the British armed forces' most sensitive communications up to 2042, replacing the Airbus-operated Skynet 5 system. A decision had been expected in the summer and was delayed, in part by Burnham's arrival in office. The GuardianLC “The military satellites under the Skynet 6 contract will carry the British armed forces’ most sensitive communications up to 2042, replacing the Skynet 5 system operated by Airbus.”“A decision had previously been expected in the summer, but it has been delayed in part by the arrival of Burnham in office.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 1Airbus chief executive Guillaume Faury has reportedly written to Burnham warning that choosing Lockheed Martin could cost the UK a key role in the European space industry for decades. The Guardian says Airbus, Thales and Leonardo are working on a merger of their space businesses, known as Project Bromo, and that Faury is understood to have warned that a non-viable UK operation could leave the UK out of the chance to be the European hub for military satellite communications. The GuardianLC “It is understood that Guillaume Faury, chief executive of France-headquartered Airbus, has written to the prime minister suggesting that the choice of provider of the Skynet system could have effects for decades”“known as Project Bromo, between their space subsidiaries” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2Both outlets report job risks, with different figures. GB News says Airbus warned that up to 3,000 jobs at Stevenage could be threatened. The Guardian says senior industry figures have claimed Airbus's UK satellite operations would not be viable without the contract, which might close its Stevenage and Portsmouth sites, employing 600 people. GB NewsR “Airbus, however, has warned that losing the Skynet work could threaten up to 3,000 positions at its Stevenage facility” Read at GB News ↗ The GuardianLC “the company might close its sites at Stevenage and Portsmouth, which employ 600 people” Read at The Guardian ↗
Right · 1Opponents of the Lockheed Martin bid raise sovereignty concerns centred on the US International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR), which GB News says let Washington block other nations from modifying, repairing or re-exporting US-supplied military equipment. An unnamed defence source told the Telegraph, as quoted by GB News, that the deal risked giving the White House a "kill switch", and analyst Francis Tusa said the satellites could be "switched off". GB NewsR “which allow Washington to prevent other nations from modifying, repairing or re-exporting American-supplied military equipment”“there will be a tether from these satellites back to the US, which means they can be switched off” Read at GB News ↗ Mixed · 2The concerns have been heightened by reports that Ukraine's access to Elon Musk's Starlink network was restricted, apparently at the behest of the US government, according to the Guardian. GB News says Defence Secretary Wes Streeting reported being assured by US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth that Starlink access had been restored. Shadow Defence Secretary James Cartlidge called for guaranteed UK sovereignty over Skynet. The GuardianLC “after Ukraine complained that its access to Elon Musk’s Starlink satellite network was restricted, apparently at the behest of the US government” Read at The Guardian ↗ GB NewsR “I am reassured, and was reassured directly by Secretary Hegseth, that the service has been restored.”“there must also be total UK sovereignty when it comes to military control of a capability” Read at GB News ↗ Right · 1The MoD said the winning supplier must assemble, integrate and test the satellites in Britain and set up a UK-based "design authority" able to make modifications independently. It declined to say whether US-sourced components would fall under ITAR, though GB News says the contract is understood to include safeguards for operational independence. GB NewsR “the winning supplier would be required to establish a UK-based "design authority" with the capacity to make modifications independently”“The department declined to address whether American-sourced components would be subject to ITAR restrictions” Read at GB News ↗
Left · 1Lockheed Martin says it cannot comment on the live procurement but that Lockheed Martin UK, a British company, would build facilities in the north-east of England to provide a "sovereign space capability", with a UK design authority and chief engineer. The Guardian says people close to the company strongly deny that the US government would control the satellites. The GuardianLC “It will have a UK design authority and a UK chief engineer.”“People close to Lockheed Martin have strongly denied that the US government would have control over the satellites.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2The bid includes a new factory, which GB News puts at £85m in the North East with about 500 jobs and the Guardian places in Durham. North Durham Labour MP Luke Akehurst and north-east mayor Kim McGuinness back it, and McGuinness cites £100m of investment and 500 skilled jobs. The union Unite has warned against "handing the British space industry over to the Americans". GB NewsR “Lockheed Martin has proposed building an £85m factory in the North East of England to assemble the satellites, promising roughly 500 new jobs in the region.” Read at GB News ↗ The GuardianLC “which would include a new factory in Durham”“handing the British space industry over to the Americans” Read at The Guardian ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Business story about Airbus's last-minute lobbying: Faury's letter warns the UK could lose its role in the European space industry.
- Emphasis
- Airbus's strategic argument, the Project Bromo merger, regional investment and jobs in the north-east, and Lockheed's denials of US control.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not quote ITAR or 'kill switch' warnings and gives little space to opposition calls for guaranteed sovereignty.
- Charged language
- “last-minute lobbying effort”
- For example
-
“intensifying a last-minute lobbying effort for the £2.4bn contract” — The Guardian
“People close to Lockheed Martin have strongly denied that the US government would have control over the satellites.” — The Guardian
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Sovereignty alarm: Britain is poised to hand a military satellite deal to a US firm 'despite control fears', with the Starlink episode as evidence.
- Emphasis
- ITAR, the 'kill switch', a Falklands scenario, the Conservative shadow defence secretary's demand and criticism that the deal undercuts Burnham's support for British workers.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Faury's letter to Burnham or the Project Bromo merger, and gives less weight to local support for the Lockheed factory.
- Charged language
- “kill switch”“despite control fears”“US defence giant”
What every side reports
- The MoD is reported to be close to choosing between Lockheed Martin and Airbus for the next Skynet satellites, and no final decision has been announced.
- Burnham will take the final decision.
- Lockheed Martin's bid includes a new factory in north-east England with about 500 jobs.
- Lockheed Martin says its UK subsidiary would provide a sovereign capability.
- The Starlink restriction on Ukraine has sharpened concern about relying on US technology.
Where accounts differ
-
Value of the contract
- Left
- The Guardian puts it at £2.4bn.
- Right
- GB News says up to £2bn.
-
Jobs at risk at Airbus
- Left
- The Guardian cites 600 jobs at Stevenage and Portsmouth, based on industry claims.
- Right
- GB News says Airbus warned that up to 3,000 jobs at Stevenage could be threatened.
-
Whether US control over the satellites is a real risk
- Left
- The Guardian says people close to Lockheed Martin strongly deny any US government control.
- Right
- GB News quotes a defence source and analyst Francis Tusa warning of a US "kill switch" or veto through ITAR.
Lockheed Martin organisation
Says it cannot discuss the live procurement. Says Lockheed Martin UK, a British company, would build facilities in north-east England and deliver a sovereign capability with a UK design authority and chief engineer.
“It will have a UK design authority and a UK chief engineer.” — The Guardian
“stressed that its British division would manage the work” — GB News
Airbus organisation
Chief executive Faury is understood to have warned Burnham of long-term damage to the UK's European space role; the company has warned of job losses at Stevenage.
“could cost the UK a key role in the European space industry” — The Guardian
“losing the Skynet work could threaten up to 3,000 positions at its Stevenage facility” — GB News
Ministry of Defence organisation
Says no final decision has been reached, both bidders are being evaluated, and the winner must assemble and test in Britain and set up a UK design authority.
“both UK-based bidders are undergoing full evaluation and must offer satellites assembled, integrated, and tested in Britain” — GB News
Andy Burnham person
As prime minister he is to make the final decision. The Guardian says the delay was partly due to his arrival in office, and GB News says critics see the US bid as at odds with his commitment to British workers.
“The final decision will rest with Burnham and the chancellor, John Healey.” — The Guardian
“Critics argue that choosing the American bid would undermine Andy Burnham's commitment to supporting British workers and businesses.” — GB News
Left1 article
-
UK risks losing key role in European space industry over satellite contract, says Airbus boss
Neutral Reports Airbus's lobbying and the wider industrial stakes, setting Lockheed's UK-control assurances and north-east support alongside the sovereignty worries.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
GB NewsR ·
Britain poised to award £2bn military satellite deal to US defence giant despite control fears
Alarmist Presents the prospective award as a sovereignty risk, leading with US veto and 'kill switch' fears and the Starlink restriction on Ukraine.

- 16 Oct 02:23 First GB NewsR Britain poised to award £2bn military satellite deal to US defence giant despite control fears
- 16 Oct 15:47 +13h 24m The GuardianLC UK risks losing key role in European space industry over satellite contract, says Airbus boss
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…