World · Russia-Ukraine war: strikes and nuclear rhetoric
Ukraine's economy minister says air alerts cost $45m for each hour of halted business
Economy Minister Oleksandr Kravchenko told The Guardian that air-raid alerts cost Ukraine about $45m an hour when they stop business. He also described $10bn in damage this year and a budget shortfall now put at $20bn.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Ukraine's economy and environment minister, Oleksandr Kravchenko, estimates that air-raid alerts cost the country about $45m for every hour they bring business to a halt. The GuardianLC “Missile alerts are costing Ukraine an estimated $45m (£34m) for every hour they bring business to a halt” Read at The Guardian ↗ MeduzaLC “cost Ukraine about $45 million an hour” Read at Meduza ↗ He said sirens can last up to 10 hours a day, sending workers to shelters. The GuardianLC “with sirens lasting up to 10 hours a day” Read at The Guardian ↗ MeduzaLC “up to 10 hours a day under alerts” Read at Meduza ↗ To limit the cost, the government introduced a two-tier system: a red alert for missile threats requires shelter, while a yellow alert for drones lets many businesses stay open. The GuardianLC “A “red” alert warns of a missile threat and requires people to seek shelter” Read at The Guardian ↗ MeduzaLC “a “yellow” alert signals a drone threat and allows businesses to keep operating” Read at Meduza ↗
Kravchenko said more than half of businesses keep operating during yellow alerts, but the risk remains: on Monday a Russian drone hit the National Academy of Sciences building in central Kyiv during a yellow alert, killing two people. The GuardianLC “killing two people while staff were still inside working” Read at The Guardian ↗ MeduzaLC “On the afternoon of September 28, during a “yellow” alert” Read at Meduza ↗ He described Russian strikes on factories, warehouses, logistics sites and data centres as an effort to “destroy pretty much the entire economy”, and put damage to fixed assets at about $10bn this year. The GuardianLC “destroy pretty much the entire economy” Read at The Guardian ↗ MeduzaLC “have caused about $10 billion in damage since the start of the year” Read at Meduza ↗ President Volodymyr Zelenskyy recently put this year's budget shortfall at about $27bn; Kravchenko said spending cuts and further reserves had reduced it to $20bn. The GuardianLC “Kravchenko said the government had since narrowed the shortfall to $20bn” Read at The Guardian ↗ MeduzaLC “Kravchenko said spending cuts had reduced the deficit to $20 billion” Read at Meduza ↗
He rejected mismanagement, corruption or overspending under former defence minister Mykhailo Fedorov as causes, saying “The cost of war is simply increasing.” The GuardianLC ““The cost of war is simply increasing,” he said” Read at The Guardian ↗ MeduzaLC “Kravchenko does not attribute the deficit to mismanagement, corruption, or excessive spending” Read at Meduza ↗ Ukraine's 2027 external financing need is put at $52.6bn, with only about $20bn secured according to The Guardian, and further tax rises and spending cuts are under discussion. The GuardianLC “Ukraine’s external financing needs for 2027 are estimated at $52.6bn, but only about $20bn has so far been secured” Read at The Guardian ↗ MeduzaLC “Less than half of that amount has been secured so far” Read at Meduza ↗ Kravchenko said Ukraine needs more air defence and faster development of drones able to intercept Russia's jet-powered drones, and that it is better prepared for what could be its hardest winter of the war. The GuardianLC “The minister believed the government was better prepared this year” Read at The Guardian ↗ MeduzaLC “Ukraine is better prepared this year for what could be the hardest winter of the war” Read at Meduza ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets lead with the $45m-an-hour figure and treat it as evidence of the economic toll of Russian strikes. The Guardian frames it as a trade-off between keeping business running and protecting people. Meduza adds wider context on Russian strikes.
- Emphasis
- The Guardian covers budget gaps, European donor concerns, corruption polling and European fatigue. Meduza adds an Economist report on Russian intentions and overnight strikes on Kyiv.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Meduza leaves out the corruption poll, Fedorov's dismissal and protests, and the minister's remarks on European fatigue. Neither outlet offers independent verification of the $45m figure.
- Charged language
- “destroy pretty much the entire economy”
- For example
-
“highlights trade-offs Kyiv faces as it tries to keep normal life moving amid Russian strikes” — The Guardian
“The Kremlin intends to paralyze Kyiv before winter, The Economist reported.” — Meduza
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Kravchenko estimates alerts cost Ukraine about $45m an hour
- Sirens can last up to 10 hours a day
- Ukraine uses red (missile) and yellow (drone) alerts, and over half of businesses keep operating under yellow
- A Russian drone hit the National Academy of Sciences in Kyiv during a yellow alert, killing two
- Kravchenko says the shortfall was cut from $27bn to $20bn and is not due to corruption or mismanagement
Oleksandr Kravchenko person
Presents alerts as a large economic cost and Russian strikes as aimed at wrecking the economy. He says the budget gap comes from rising war costs and weaker revenue, not corruption or mismanagement.
““If people are in a bunker, business stops,” he said.” — The Guardian
“Kravchenko dismissed suggestions that the shortfall was the result of mismanagement or corruption.” — The Guardian
Russia place
Shown only through Ukrainian accounts: Russia is described as increasingly targeting economic infrastructure, and The Economist is cited as reporting that Putin ordered strikes on civilian sites. No Russian statement is given.
“Russia has increasingly targeted the infrastructure underpinning Ukraine's economy” — The Guardian
“Vladimir Putin had ordered strikes on civilian sites” — Meduza
UK and Ireland1 outlet
The Guardian conducted the interview in Kyiv and gives the most detail, including donor funding, corruption polling and European support.
“Speaking from the heavily protected government building in Kyiv” — The Guardian
The Guardian
Europe1 outlet
Meduza summarises the Guardian interview and places it alongside other reporting on Russian strikes on civilian sites.
“estimated in an interview with The Guardian” — Meduza
Meduza
Left2 articles
-
Missile alerts cost Ukraine $45m for every hour they halt businesses
Neutral Interview-based report centred on the minister's cost estimate and the wider strain on Ukraine's finances, including corruption concerns.
-
MeduzaLC ·
Neutral A shorter rewrite of The Guardian interview with added context on Russian strikes and overnight attacks on Kyiv.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 30 Sep 05:00 First The GuardianLC Missile alerts cost Ukraine $45m for every hour they halt businesses
- 30 Sep 21:25 +16h 25m MeduzaLC Ukraine’s air-raid sirens can sound for 10 hours a day. Its economy minister says every hour costs $45 million.
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.