Skip to content
Bramble

World

Ukraine's passenger trains keep running amid Russian drone threat, with repeated evacuations

A Reuters report on a Dnipro–Odesa train shows Ukrainians still travelling by rail despite repeated air-raid evacuations and Russian drone attacks on railway infrastructure. The Independent runs the same account under a more stark headline and introduction.

2 outlets · 1L · 0C · 1R First reported Account updated
Image: The Straits Times
Image: The Independent

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Mixed · 2Ukrainian passenger trains are still running despite the threat of Russian drone attacks, but passengers face repeated evacuations and long delays, according to a report from a train between Dnipro and Odesa dated 28 October. Mixed · 2Beauty salon owner Antonina Viter, 36, who travels at least six times a month to manage two salons in Kyiv and Dnipro, said: "Every third trip, we end up evacuating once, twice or even three times." Mixed · 2On the roughly 400 km (250 miles) Dnipro–Odesa line, the outward journey featured eight evacuations of about 30 minutes each and the return journey nine; the train nonetheless arrived only an hour and 20 minutes late, although delays of 5 to 12 hours are not unusual on the route.

Mixed · 2Ukraine has set new rules for rail passengers during air-raid alerts, and during alerts passengers can be woken and forced to scramble into fields or up and down embankments, sometimes with children or pets, in sub-zero temperatures in winter. Mixed · 2The state operator Ukrzaliznytsia says Russia has attacked more than 1,700 rail facilities this year, including stations, locomotives and passenger wagons; Russia says its targets are objects used by Kyiv's military. Mixed · 2Direct attacks include a drone strike that killed two train drivers on the Dnipro–Odesa line on 13 August and a strike on a Warsaw-bound train near the Polish border in September, and some stations in the east and south have been shut indefinitely as fighting nears.

Mixed · 2The report says new Russian jet-powered drones that are hard to shoot down have hit targets from shopping centres to power plants, and that the risk to rail travellers has grown as Russia broadened its drone and ballistic-missile campaign, exploiting Kyiv's shortage of air defence missiles. Mixed · 2Ukraine's infrastructure minister said more than 50 railway workers have died on duty this year; staff close carriage curtains at the start of each journey to avoid showing light to drones, and conductors log every interruption. Mixed · 2Passengers and crew describe adapting: IT worker Larysa Konstantynova said "you just try to be positive and survive", and locomotive driver Mykola Kovalenko said: "If I quit, who will drive the trains?"

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left1 outlet

Framing
The Independent leads with the danger to passengers, with a headline and introduction stressing risk of death, then follows the same on-board account as the Reuters report.
Emphasis
Risk of being killed, forced evacuations and Russian responsibility, framed around passengers 'taking their life in their hands'.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not add its own sourcing beyond the shared on-board account; drops the Reuters dateline and subheadings.
Charged language
“take their life in their hands”“Putin's Russian drones prowling overheard”“risk of random death”
For example
“Passengers who still use Ukraine's train network take their life in their hands every time they step onboard - with Putin's Russian drones prowling overheard.” — The Independent

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right1 outlet

Framing
The Straits Times carries the Reuters feature, framed as resilience: Ukraine's trains 'keep on rolling' despite harassment by drones.
Emphasis
Everyday coping by passengers and crew, with figures on attacks and worker deaths under subheadings.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not itself add commentary beyond the agency copy.
Charged language
“Harassed by Russian drones”“keep on rolling”
For example
“Harassed by Russian drones, Ukraine's trains keep on rolling” — The Straits Times
“UKRAINIAN RAILWAYS ATTACKED 1,700 TIMES THIS YEAR” — The Straits Times

Ask about this story

Loading…