Skip to content
Bramble

World

UN official warns Hormuz fertilizer plan must be agreed within weeks to avoid food crisis

UN Under-Secretary-General Jorge Moreira da Silva said that if the US and Iran do not agree within weeks on a UN-backed plan to move fertilizer through the Strait of Hormuz, planting seasons could be missed and food security in parts of Asia and Africa could suffer.

3 outlets · 1L · 0C · 2R First reported Account updated

Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from Al Jazeera.

Image: The Straits Times
Image: Al Jazeera
Image: Arab News

1 / 3

The story, neutrally told

Right · 2A UN official overseeing a proposed scheme to move fertilizer through the Strait of Hormuz said on Wednesday 14 October that a failure by the United States and Iran to agree on it within weeks could cause a food security crisis in parts of Asia and Africa. Right · 1The United Nations set up a taskforce in March to facilitate fertilizer passage through the strait but has yet to implement the mechanism it drew up; Under-Secretary-General Jorge Moreira da Silva said it could be activated within 7-10 days of an agreement between Washington and Tehran. Right · 2Speaking in an interview in Bangkok on the sidelines of the IMF and World Bank annual meetings, he said: "It's absolutely crucial to get the deal in the next few weeks. Otherwise, we will miss the planting season."

Right · 1He warned that missing that season would significantly cut agricultural productivity and push up prices. Right · 2Under the proposal, a coordination centre in Oman would register vessels and coordinate safe passage, with UN monitors working alongside local authorities at Gulf ports to verify cargo loading. Ships would be tracked in transit, and extra inspections could be carried out if countries raised concerns about a vessel or cargo. Right · 1Moreira da Silva said that passage of only five vessels a day could keep fertilizer flowing to countries in critical need.

Right · 2He said the mechanism could run alongside talks on a comprehensive deal on lasting peace and freedom of navigation, and declined to specify the exact bottlenecks to an agreement. Right · 1The White House, the US State Department and Iran's Embassy in Bangkok did not immediately reply to requests for comment. Right · 2Iran has sought to tighten its grip on the strait since US and Israeli strikes on 28 February, using it to pressure Washington, which has maintained its own naval blockade of Iranian ports. Iran and the US have exchanged proposals through intermediaries since a June interim ceasefire collapsed, but efforts to reopen the strait have stalled over Tehran's conditions and Washington's insistence on addressing Iran's nuclear programme from the outset.

Right · 1Before the war the waterway handled roughly a third of globally traded urea and nearly half of seaborne sulphur, and it is also a major conduit for oil. The Washington-based International Food Policy Research Institute said last month that fertilizer shipments out of the Gulf remained largely halted more than six months into the conflict, and that fertilizer was a "very negligible" share of the shipping that resumed during the mid-June to mid-July ceasefire. Right · 1An August International Chamber of Commerce report said continued Hormuz disruption could raise commodity prices by up to 81% for cereals, 66% for oil crops and 30% for animal products. Right · 2Moreira da Silva said food security is also threatened by attacks on cargo vessels in the Black Sea region and an offensive by Iran-backed Houthi militants along a key Red Sea shipping route, calling it "a concentration of factors" including the climate crisis.

Left · 1Al Jazeera added that in May the UN's Food and Agriculture Organization warned fertiliser scarcity could tighten food supplies from late 2026 into 2027 and hit countries facing climate or other crises hardest, that South Asian farmers who rely on imported fertiliser are already struggling with soaring costs, and that farmers in Spain protested on Wednesday over rising production costs amid high oil and fertiliser prices. Left · 1Al Jazeera also reported that Moreira da Silva did not say why the US and Iran have not yet agreed, and quoted him as saying the UN's message to both sides is: "while you continue your discussions towards a comprehensive deal, let us work, let us do our job."

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left1 outlet

Framing
Al Jazeera's own staff report leads with the UN official's warning of a 'looming food crisis' as the plan 'stalls', drawing on his Reuters interview and adding wider context on fertiliser scarcity.
Emphasis
Farmers' crop calendars, the FAO's May warning, hardship for South Asian farmers and protests by Spanish farmers; describes the strait as 'embattled' and attributes disruption to Iran targeting vessels and US-Iran exchanges of fire.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not carry the International Chamber of Commerce price projections or the Black Sea and Red Sea threats to food security that the Reuters copy includes, and has no US or Iranian response.
Charged language
“embattled Strait of Hormuz”“looming food crisis”
For example
“Farmers operate strict crop calendars, and even slight delays could severely affect yield.” — Al Jazeera
“the embattled Strait of Hormuz” — Al Jazeera

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right2 outlets

Framing
The Straits Times (Reuters copy) and Arab News run the same agency report, leading with the UN official's warning of a food crisis if the US and Iran do not agree on the fertilizer passage plan; Arab News's copy is near word-for-word the same apart from spelling and a subheading.
Emphasis
The urgency of the planting season, the mechanics of the proposed operation, and price risks from the ICC report.
Leaves out or plays down
Neither carries a response from Washington or Tehran, nor detail on what is blocking a deal; no voices other than the UN official are included.
For example
“The White House, US State Department and Iran's Embassy in Bangkok did not immediately reply to a request for comment.” — The Straits Times
“FIVE VESSELS A DAY If the Hormuz disruption continues, commodity prices could rise by up to 81 percent for cereals” — Arab News

Ask about this story

Loading…