Unite warns Apache North Sea strike could disrupt UK fuel; Apache and government play risk down
Unite says Apache offshore workers have backed strike action over pay and warns it could affect the Forties pipeline and UK fuel supplies. Apache says it has contingency plans, and the government says the pipeline carries crude oil, not fuel.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2The Unite union has said a looming strike by Apache oil workers in the North Sea could "severely disrupt" UK fuel supplies, after pay talks with the Texas-based operator broke down. The GuardianLC “could “severely disrupt” UK fuel supplies, the Unite union has said” Read at The Guardian ↗ GB NewsR “The Unite union said workers at oil and gas operator Apache have backed strike action in a pay dispute.” Read at GB News ↗ Left · 1Unite said workers had "emphatically" backed strike action over a pay offer it called unacceptable and a real-terms pay cut for many staff. It also said Apache had set deadlines for agreeing back pay and indicated payments could be withheld. The GuardianLC “Apache workers had “emphatically” backed strike action”“leaving workers potentially thousands of pounds out of pocket” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2According to Unite, action could begin later this month and involve more than 160 offshore workers, including electrical, instrument and production technicians and radio operators. It would cover seven Apache assets linked to the Forties and Beryl fields. The GuardianLC “could involve more than 160 Apache offshore workers” Read at The Guardian ↗ GB NewsR “would include seven Apache assets associated with the Forties and Beryl oil fields” Read at GB News ↗
Left · 1Unite said stoppage could bring the Forties Charlie platform to a standstill and take down the Forties pipeline system, which the Guardian says handles almost a third of the UK's oil and gas, and could ripple out to other operators. Unite industrial officer Stevie Davies said any disruption would be a "direct hit on the Forties pipeline". The GuardianLC “being brought to a standstill”, Unite said”“which is said to handle almost a third of the UK’s oil and gas” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2General secretary Sharon Graham said Unite "will not tolerate unacceptable pay offers" and accused Apache of "raking in eye-watering profits". The Guardian reports APA Corporation, Apache's parent, made $1.4bn in after-tax profit on $9.2bn revenue last year. GB NewsR “The operator is raking in eye-watering profits.” Read at GB News ↗ The GuardianLC “reported $1.4bn (£1.1bn) in after-tax profits and $9.2bn in revenues for last year” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2Apache said it had "engaged constructively" and made a final offer of a 4% pay rise, in line with that given to non-unionised staff, to employees it said are among the UK's highest earners with an offshore rota averaging 153 working days a year. It said a strike vote does not mean action will automatically follow. The GuardianLC “it had offered a 4% pay increase for staff” Read at The Guardian ↗ GB NewsR “A vote in favour of industrial action does not mean that action will automatically take place.” Read at GB News ↗
Mixed · 2Apache said its contingency plans include keeping experienced personnel on Forties Charlie to support third-party production even if all five Apache-operated Forties platforms were suspended. It said it does not expect other producers to be affected and that any pressure reduction would be comparable to a routine maintenance outage. GB NewsR “maintaining experienced personnel on Forties Charlie to operate the plant and support continued third-party production” Read at GB News ↗ The GuardianLC “similar to what occurred during routine maintenance outages” Read at The Guardian ↗ Right · 1A Department for Energy Security and Net Zero spokesperson urged all parties to resolve the issue without disruption, saying Britain has a "diverse and resilient fuel supply" and that this is "a crude oil pipeline and does not transport fuel". GB News also reported it had been suggested the pipeline is mostly used for exporting oil. GB NewsR “This is a crude oil pipeline and does not transport fuel.”“It has also been suggested the pipeline is mostly used for exporting oil, meaning it would not impact UK consumers.” Read at GB News ↗ Mixed · 2The warning comes as the average UK diesel price reached a record £2 a litre amid the US-Israel war on Iran, and G7 leaders agreed to release up to 100m barrels from emergency stockpiles after Donald Trump threatened to halt US diesel and oil exports. The GuardianLC “the average price of diesel had climbed to a record £2 a litre” Read at The Guardian ↗ GB NewsR “agreed to release 100 million barrels of fuel and oil from emergency stocks” Read at GB News ↗
Left · 1Planned Unite strikes by Neo Next offshore workers were called off this summer after a deal the union said lifted pay by more than £4,000. Ineos, which operates the Forties pipeline system, was contacted by the Guardian for comment. The GuardianLC “Planned strikes by Neo Next offshore workers, organised by Unite, were called off this summer”“Ineos, which operates the Forties pipeline system, was contacted for comment.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Labour-dispute story led by Unite's claim that workers were left no choice and that fuel supplies are at risk, set against record diesel prices.
- Emphasis
- Real-terms pay cut, threatened withholding of back pay, Apache parent's $1.4bn profit, scale of the Forties system, and the earlier Neo Next deal.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not report the government statement that the pipeline carries crude, not fuel.
- Charged language
- “raking in eye-watering profits”
- For example
-
“adding that staff were left with no choice after a breakdown in pay talks with the Texas oil company Apache” — The Guardian
“Unite said the operator had also set deadlines for reaching an agreement over back pay” — The Guardian
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Frames the strike as a risk to a "fuel-deprived Britain" amid rising prices, while noting that the strike is only under consideration and carrying the government's pushback.
- Emphasis
- Fuel prices, the Iran war and Russia's invasion of Ukraine, Trump's export threat, and Apache's detailed contingency plans.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not give Unite's claim of 160+ workers, the Apache parent's profit figures or the Neo Next precedent.
- Charged language
- “fuel-deprived Britain”“shameful corporate greed”“caught red-handed”“blackmail”
What every side reports
- Apache workers represented by Unite have backed strike action in a pay dispute.
- Apache says it offered a 4% pay rise and has contingency plans for the Forties pipeline system.
- Unite's Sharon Graham and Stevie Davies warned of risks to UK fuel supplies and accused Apache of excessive profits or reckless behaviour.
- UK diesel prices have hit a record £2 a litre and G7 nations agreed to release 100m barrels from emergency stocks.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether a strike would threaten UK fuel supplies
- Left
- Leads with Unite's warning that action could take down the Forties pipeline system and "severely" affect fuel supplies; Apache's rebuttal appears lower down and the government's crude-only point is not reported.
- Centre
- No centre outlets covered the story.
- Right
- Also leads with the "severe disruption" warning, but includes the government statement that this is a crude pipeline that does not carry fuel, and the suggestion it is mostly for exports.
-
Whether the pay offer is fair
- Left
- Unite calls the offer a real-terms cut amid big profits; Apache calls its 4% fair for well-paid staff.
- Centre
- No centre outlets covered the story.
- Right
- Same competing claims, quoting Apache at greater length and Unite's "contempt" and "corporate greed" language.
Unite organisation
Says workers were left no option but to strike over an unacceptable offer and that disruption to Apache platforms would hit the Forties pipeline and UK fuel supplies.
“Unite's members are being left with no option but to take strike action.” — GB News
“We will not tolerate unacceptable pay offers.” — The Guardian
Apache organisation
Says its 4% final offer is fair, it has engaged constructively, and contingency plans mean other producers should not be affected; prefers dialogue.
“We respect the ballot result, but our preference remains to resolve this matter through constructive dialogue.” — GB News
“As a responsible operator, we are planning to maintain safe operations throughout any industrial action” — The Guardian
Left1 article
-
Strikes by North Sea oil workers could ‘severely disrupt’ UK fuel supplies
Mixed Reports Unite's warning and grievances first, with Apache's response and profit context, tying the dispute to the fuel price crisis.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
GB NewsR ·
Offshore oil worker strike to put fuel-deprived Britain at risk of 'severe disruption'
Mixed Headline stresses risk to fuel-deprived Britain, but the body gives space to Apache and the government's view that the pipeline carries crude only.
- 5 Oct 00:01 First The GuardianLC Strikes by North Sea oil workers could ‘severely disrupt’ UK fuel supplies
- 5 Oct 01:58 +1h 56m GB NewsR Offshore oil worker strike to put fuel-deprived Britain at risk of 'severe disruption'
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.